@article{CsizmadiaBerthold2020, author = {Csizmadia, Zsolt and Berthold, Timo}, title = {The confined primal integral: a measure to benchmark heuristic MINLP solvers against global MINLP solvers}, journal = {Mathematical Programming}, doi = {10.1007/s10107-020-01547-5}, year = {2020}, abstract = {It is a challenging task to fairly compare local solvers and heuristics against each other and against global solvers. How does one weigh a faster termination time against a better quality of the found solution? In this paper, we introduce the confined primal integral, a new performance measure that rewards a balance of speed and solution quality. It emphasizes the early part of the solution process by using an exponential decay. Thereby, it avoids that the order of solvers can be inverted by choosing an arbitrarily large time limit. We provide a closed analytic formula to compute the confined primal integral a posteriori and an incremental update formula to compute it during the run of an algorithm. For the latter, we show that we can drop one of the main assumptions of the primal integral, namely the knowledge of a fixed reference solution to compare against. Furthermore, we prove that the confined primal integral is a transitive measure when comparing local solves with different final solution values. Finally, we present a computational experiment where we compare a local MINLP solver that uses certain classes of cutting planes against a solver that does not. Both versions show very different tendencies w.r.t. average running time and solution quality, and we use the confined primal integral to argue which of the two is the preferred setting.}, language = {en} } @article{WitzigBerthold2021, author = {Witzig, Jakob and Berthold, Timo}, title = {Conflict Analysis for MINLP}, volume = {33}, journal = {INFORMS Journal on Computing}, number = {2}, doi = {10.1287/ijoc.2020.1050}, pages = {421 -- 435}, year = {2021}, abstract = {The generalization of MIP techniques to deal with nonlinear, potentially non-convex, constraints have been a fruitful direction of research for computational MINLP in the last decade. In this paper, we follow that path in order to extend another essential subroutine of modern MIP solvers towards the case of nonlinear optimization: the analysis of infeasible subproblems for learning additional valid constraints. To this end, we derive two different strategies, geared towards two different solution approaches. These are using local dual proofs of infeasibility for LP-based branch-and-bound and the creation of nonlinear dual proofs for NLP-based branch-and-bound, respectively. We discuss implementation details of both approaches and present an extensive computational study, showing that both techniques can significantly enhance performance when solving MINLPs to global optimality.}, language = {en} } @article{GamrathBertholdSalvagnin2020, author = {Gamrath, Gerald and Berthold, Timo and Salvagnin, Domenico}, title = {An exploratory computational analysis of dual degeneracy in mixed-integer programming}, journal = {EURO Journal on Computational Optimization}, number = {8}, doi = {10.1007/s13675-020-00130-z}, pages = {241 -- 246}, year = {2020}, abstract = {Dual degeneracy, i.e., the presence of multiple optimal bases to a linear programming (LP) problem, heavily affects the solution process of mixed integer programming (MIP) solvers. Different optimal bases lead to different cuts being generated, different branching decisions being taken and different solutions being found by primal heuristics. Nevertheless, only a few methods have been published that either avoid or exploit dual degeneracy. The aim of the present paper is to conduct a thorough computational study on the presence of dual degeneracy for the instances of well-known public MIP instance collections. How many instances are affected by dual degeneracy? How degenerate are the affected models? How does branching affect degeneracy: Does it increase or decrease by fixing variables? Can we identify different types of degenerate MIPs? As a tool to answer these questions, we introduce a new measure for dual degeneracy: the variable-constraint ratio of the optimal face. It provides an estimate for the likelihood that a basic variable can be pivoted out of the basis. Furthermore, we study how the so-called cloud intervals—the projections of the optimal face of the LP relaxations onto the individual variables—evolve during tree search and the implications for reducing the set of branching candidates.}, language = {en} } @article{KochAchterbergAndersenetal.2011, author = {Koch, Thorsten and Achterberg, Tobias and Andersen, Erling and Bastert, Oliver and Berthold, Timo and Bixby, Robert E. and Danna, Emilie and Gamrath, Gerald and Gleixner, Ambros and Heinz, Stefan and Lodi, Andrea and Mittelmann, Hans and Ralphs, Ted and Salvagnin, Domenico and Steffy, Daniel and Wolter, Kati}, title = {MIPLIB 2010}, volume = {3}, journal = {Mathematical Programming Computation}, number = {2}, doi = {10.1007/s12532-011-0025-9}, pages = {103 -- 163}, year = {2011}, language = {en} } @inproceedings{AchterbergBertholdKochetal.2008, author = {Achterberg, Tobias and Berthold, Timo and Koch, Thorsten and Wolter, Kati}, title = {Constraint Integer Programming: A New Approach to Integrate CP and MIP}, volume = {5015}, booktitle = {Integration of AI and OR Techniques in Constraint Programming for Combinatorial Optimization Problems, 5th International Conference, CPAIOR 2008}, editor = {Perron, Laurent and Trick, Michael}, publisher = {Springer}, doi = {10.1007/978-3-540-68155-7_4}, pages = {6 -- 20}, year = {2008}, language = {en} } @misc{ShinanoAchterbergBertholdetal.2010, author = {Shinano, Yuji and Achterberg, Tobias and Berthold, Timo and Heinz, Stefan and Koch, Thorsten}, title = {ParaSCIP - a parallel extension of SCIP}, doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-24025-6_12}, url = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0297-zib-11921}, number = {10-27}, year = {2010}, abstract = {Mixed integer programming (MIP) has become one of the most important techniques in Operations Research and Discrete Optimization. SCIP (Solving Constraint Integer Programs) is currently one of the fastest non-commercial MIP solvers. It is based on the branch-and-bound procedure in which the problem is recursively split into smaller subproblems, thereby creating a so-called branching tree. We present ParaSCIP, an extension of SCIP, which realizes a parallelization on a distributed memory computing environment. ParaSCIP uses SCIP solvers as independently running processes to solve subproblems (nodes of the branching tree) locally. This makes the parallelization development independent of the SCIP development. Thus, ParaSCIP directly profits from any algorithmic progress in future versions of SCIP. Using a first implementation of ParaSCIP, we were able to solve two previously unsolved instances from MIPLIB2003, a standard test set library for MIP solvers. For these computations, we used up to 2048 cores of the HLRN~II supercomputer.}, language = {en} } @inproceedings{BertholdGleixnerHeinzetal.2012, author = {Berthold, Timo and Gleixner, Ambros and Heinz, Stefan and Koch, Thorsten and Shinano, Yuji}, title = {SCIP Optimization Suite を利用した 混合整数(線形/非線形) 計画問題の解法}, booktitle = {Proceedings of the 24th RAMP symposium. The Operations Society of Japan, RAMP: Research Association of Mathematical Programming}, pages = {165 -- 192}, year = {2012}, abstract = {この論文ではソフトウェア・パッケージSCIP Optimization Suite を紹介し,その3つの構成要素:モデリン グ言語Zimpl, 線形計画(LP: linear programming) ソルバSoPlex, そして,制約整数計画(CIP: constraint integer programming) に対するソフトウェア・フレームワークSCIP, について述べる.本論文では,この3つの 構成要素を利用して,どのようにして挑戦的な混合整数線形計画問題(MIP: mixed integer linear optimization problems) や混合整数非線形計画問題(MINLP: mixed integer nonlinear optimization problems) をモデル化 し解くのかを説明する.SCIP は,現在,最も高速なMIP,MINLP ソルバの1つである.いくつかの例により, Zimpl, SCIP, SoPlex の利用方法を示すとともに,利用可能なインタフェースの概要を示す.最後に,将来の開 発計画の概要について述べる.}, language = {ja} } @article{BertholdGleixnerHeinzetal.2012, author = {Berthold, Timo and Gleixner, Ambros and Heinz, Stefan and Vigerske, Stefan}, title = {Analyzing the computational impact of MIQCP solver components}, volume = {2}, journal = {Numerical Algebra, Control and Optimization}, number = {4}, doi = {10.3934/naco.2012.2.739}, pages = {739 -- 748}, year = {2012}, abstract = {We provide a computational study of the performance of a state-of-the-art solver for nonconvex mixed-integer quadratically constrained programs (MIQCPs). Since successful general-purpose solvers for large problem classes necessarily comprise a variety of algorithmic techniques, we focus especially on the impact of the individual solver components. The solver SCIP used for the experiments implements a branch-and-cut algorithm based on a linear relaxation to solve MIQCPs to global optimality. Our analysis is based on a set of 86 publicly available test instances.}, language = {en} } @inproceedings{BertholdHeinzSchulz2011, author = {Berthold, Timo and Heinz, Stefan and Schulz, Jens}, title = {An approximative Criterion for the Potential of Energetic Reasoning}, volume = {6595}, booktitle = {Theory and Practice of Algorithms in (Computer) Systems}, pages = {229 -- 239}, year = {2011}, language = {en} } @inproceedings{HendelBertholdAchterberg2011, author = {Hendel, Gregor and Berthold, Timo and Achterberg, Tobias}, title = {Rounding and Propagation Heuristics for Mixed Integer Programming}, booktitle = {Operations Research Proceedings 2011}, pages = {71 -- 76}, year = {2011}, abstract = {Primal heuristics are an important component of state-of-the-art codes for mixed integer programming. In this paper, we focus on primal heuristics that only employ computationally inexpensive procedures such as rounding and logical deductions (propagation). We give an overview of eight different approaches. To assess the impact of these primal heuristics on the ability to find feasible solutions, in particular early during search, we introduce a new performance measure, the primal integral. Computational experiments evaluate this and other measures on MIPLIB~2010 benchmark instances.}, language = {en} } @misc{BertholdSalvagnin2013, author = {Berthold, Timo and Salvagnin, Domenico}, title = {Cloud branching}, volume = {7874}, journal = {Integration of AI and OR Techniques in Constraint Programming for Combinatorial Optimization Problems}, editor = {Gomes, Carla and Sellmann, Meinolf}, publisher = {Springer}, doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-38171-3_3}, pages = {28 -- 43}, year = {2013}, abstract = {Branch-and-bound methods for mixed-integer programming (MIP) are traditionally based on solving a linear programming (LP) relaxation and branching on a variable which takes a fractional value in the (single) computed relaxation optimum. In this paper we study branching strategies for mixed-integer programs that exploit the knowledge of multiple alternative optimal solutions (a cloud) of the current LP relaxation. These strategies naturally extend state-of-the-art methods like strong branching, pseudocost branching, and their hybrids. We show that by exploiting dual degeneracy, and thus multiple alternative optimal solutions, it is possible to enhance traditional methods. We present preliminary computational results, applying the newly proposed strategy to full strong branching, which is known to be the MIP branching rule leading to the fewest number of search nodes. It turns out that cloud branching can reduce the mean running time by up to 30\% on standard test sets.}, language = {en} } @misc{BertholdHeinzVigerske2012, author = {Berthold, Timo and Heinz, Stefan and Vigerske, Stefan}, title = {Extending a CIP framework to solve MIQCPs}, volume = {154}, journal = {Mixed Integer Nonlinear Programming}, editor = {Lee, Jon and Leyffer, Sven}, publisher = {Springer}, isbn = {978-1-4614-1927-3}, pages = {427 -- 444}, year = {2012}, abstract = {This paper discusses how to build a solver for mixed integer quadratically constrained programs (MIQCPs) by extending a framework for constraint integer programming (CIP). The advantage of this approach is that we can utilize the full power of advanced MIP and CP technologies. In particular, this addresses the linear relaxation and the discrete components of the problem. For relaxation, we use an outer approximation generated by linearization of convex constraints and linear underestimation of nonconvex constraints. Further, we give an overview of the reformulation, separation, and propagation techniques that are used to handle the quadratic constraints efficiently. We implemented these methods in the branch-cut-and-price framework SCIP. Computational experiments indicates the potential of the approach.}, language = {en} } @article{Berthold2013, author = {Berthold, Timo}, title = {Measuring the impact of primal heuristics}, volume = {41}, journal = {Operations Research Letters}, number = {6}, doi = {10.1016/j.orl.2013.08.007}, pages = {611 -- 614}, year = {2013}, abstract = {In modern MIP solvers, primal heuristics play a major role in finding and improving feasible solutions early in the solution process. However, classical performance measures such as time to optimality or number of branch-and-bound nodes reflect the impact of primal heuristics on the overall solving process badly. This article discusses the question of how to evaluate the effect of primal heuristics. Therefore, we introduce a new performance measure, the "primal integral" which depends on the quality of solutions found during the solving process as well as on the points in time when they are found. Our computational results reveal that heuristics improve the performance of MIP solvers in terms of the primal bound by around 80\%. Further, we compare five state-of-the-art MIP solvers w.r.t. the newly proposed measure.}, language = {en} } @article{BertholdGleixner2014, author = {Berthold, Timo and Gleixner, Ambros}, title = {Undercover: a primal MINLP heuristic exploring a largest sub-MIP}, volume = {144}, journal = {Mathematical Programming}, number = {1-2}, doi = {10.1007/s10107-013-0635-2}, pages = {315 -- 346}, year = {2014}, abstract = {We present Undercover, a primal heuristic for nonconvex mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) that explores a mixed-integer linear subproblem (sub-MIP) of a given MINLP. We solve a vertex covering problem to identify a minimal set of variables that need to be fixed in order to linearize each constraint, a so-called cover. Subsequently, these variables are fixed to values obtained from a reference point, e.g., an optimal solution of a linear relaxation. We apply domain propagation and conflict analysis to try to avoid infeasibilities and learn from them, respectively. Each feasible solution of the sub-MIP corresponds to a feasible solution of the original problem. We present computational results on a test set of mixed-integer quadratically constrained programs (MIQCPs) and general MINLPs from MINLPLib. It turns out that the majority of these instances allow for small covers. Although general in nature, the heuristic appears most promising for MIQCPs, and complements nicely with existing root node heuristics in different state-of-the-art solvers.}, language = {en} } @inproceedings{BertholdHeinzPfetschetal.2011, author = {Berthold, Timo and Heinz, Stefan and Pfetsch, Marc and Vigerske, Stefan}, title = {Large Neighborhood Search beyond MIP}, booktitle = {Proceedings of the 9th Metaheuristics International Conference (MIC 2011)}, isbn = {978-88-900984-3-7}, pages = {51 -- 60}, year = {2011}, abstract = {Large neighborhood search (LNS) heuristics are an important component of modern branch-and-cut algorithms for solving mixed-integer linear programs (MIPs). Most of these LNS heuristics use the LP relaxation as the basis for their search, which is a reasonable choice in case of MIPs. However, for more general problem classes, the LP relaxation alone may not contain enough information about the original problem to find feasible solutions with these heuristics, e.g., if the problem is nonlinear or not all constraints are present in the current relaxation. In this paper, we discuss a generic way to extend LNS heuristics that have been developed for MIP to constraint integer programming (CIP), which is a generalization of MIP in the direction of constraint programming (CP). We present computational results of LNS heuristics for three problem classes: mixed-integer quadratically constrained programs, nonlinear pseudo-Boolean optimization instances, and resource-constrained project scheduling problems. Therefore, we have implemented extended versions of the following LNS heuristics in the constraint integer programming framework SCIP: Local Branching, RINS, RENS, Crossover, and DINS. Our results indicate that a generic generalization of LNS heuristics to CIP considerably improves the success rate of these heuristics.}, language = {en} } @misc{ShinanoAchterbergBertholdetal.2013, author = {Shinano, Yuji and Achterberg, Tobias and Berthold, Timo and Heinz, Stefan and Koch, Thorsten and Winkler, Michael}, title = {Solving hard MIPLIB2003 problems with ParaSCIP on Supercomputers: An update}, issn = {1438-0064}, url = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0297-zib-42888}, year = {2013}, abstract = {Contemporary supercomputers can easily provide years of CPU time per wall-clock hour. One challenge of today's software development is how to harness this wast computing power in order to solve really hard mixed integer programming instances. In 2010, two out of six open MIPLIB2003 instances could be solved by ParaSCIP in more than ten consecutive runs, restarting from checkpointing files. The contribution of this paper is threefold: For the first time, we present computational results of single runs for those two instances. Secondly, we provide new improved upper and lower bounds for all of the remaining four open MIPLIB2003 instances. Finally, we explain which new developments led to these results and discuss the current progress of ParaSCIP. Experiments were conducted on HLRNII, on HLRN III, and on the Titan supercomputer, using up to 35,200 cores.}, language = {en} } @article{AchterbergBerthold2007, author = {Achterberg, Tobias and Berthold, Timo}, title = {Improving the Feasibility Pump}, volume = {Special Issue 4}, journal = {Discrete Optimization}, number = {1}, pages = {77 -- 86}, year = {2007}, language = {en} } @article{Berthold2008, author = {Berthold, Timo}, title = {Heuristiken im Branch-and-Cut-Framework SCIP}, journal = {OR News}, number = {32}, pages = {24 -- 25}, year = {2008}, language = {en} } @misc{Berthold2013, author = {Berthold, Timo}, title = {Primal MINLP Heuristics in a nutshell}, issn = {1438-0064}, url = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0297-zib-42170}, year = {2013}, abstract = {Primal heuristics are an important component of state-of-the-art codes for mixed integer nonlinear programming (MINLP). In this article we give a compact overview of primal heuristics for MINLP that have been suggested in the literature of recent years. We sketch the fundamental concepts of different classes of heuristics and discuss specific implementations. A brief computational experiment shows that primal heuristics play a key role in achieving feasibility and finding good primal bounds within a global MINLP solver.}, language = {en} } @misc{GamrathMelchioriBertholdetal.2015, author = {Gamrath, Gerald and Melchiori, Anna and Berthold, Timo and Gleixner, Ambros and Salvagnin, Domenico}, title = {Branching on multi-aggregated variables}, issn = {1438-0064}, doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-18008-3_10}, url = {http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0297-zib-53829}, year = {2015}, abstract = {In mixed-integer programming, the branching rule is a key component to a fast convergence of the branch-and-bound algorithm. The most common strategy is to branch on simple disjunctions that split the domain of a single integer variable into two disjoint intervals. Multi-aggregation is a presolving step that replaces variables by an affine linear sum of other variables, thereby reducing the problem size. While this simplification typically improves the performance of MIP solvers, it also restricts the degree of freedom in variable-based branching rules. We present a novel branching scheme that tries to overcome the above drawback by considering general disjunctions defined by multi-aggregated variables in addition to the standard disjunctions based on single variables. This natural idea results in a hybrid between variable- and constraint-based branching rules. Our implementation within the constraint integer programming framework SCIP incorporates this into a full strong branching rule and reduces the number of branch-and-bound nodes on a general test set of publicly available benchmark instances. For a specific class of problems, we show that the solving time decreases significantly.}, language = {en} }