Kühne Foundation Endowed Chair of Logistics Management
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (13)
- Article (1)
Language
- English (14)
Has Fulltext
- yes (14)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (14)
Keywords
- Luftverkehr (4)
- Supply chain management (3)
- Air traffic (2)
- Air transport (2)
- Business plan (2)
- Container shipping (2)
- Geschäftsmodell (2)
- Predictive analytics (2)
- Prädiktive Analytik (2)
- Supply Chain Management (2)
Institute
Airport slot allocation
(2023)
This dissertation addresses the concept of airport slot allocation as a major regulatory directive in air transport management. In three sequential parts, today’s slot allocation procedure, addressing the assignment of time windows for departure and landing operations at coordinated airports, is being assessed and critically evaluated. The three sections evolve from the evaluation and revision of a suitable criteria set to the development and implementation of a network solution. As a key feature, a carbon emissions price including the air carriers’ CO2 emissions is being provided, serving as the allocation principle. In all three parts, explicit reference to the IATA Worldwide Slot Guidelines, representing today’s regulatory framework, is being provided, highlighting explicit deficits and drawbacks of that solution. In the first part, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), as a concept of decision making based on a comparison of criteria and alternatives, is being applied guiding the allocation decision at a single airport. In this section, a set of multiple criteria is being proposed and weighted according a set of slot coordinators’ preferences. As a key feature, the concept of Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is being extended by the conduction of a Pairwise Comparison-based Preference Measurement (PCPM) representing one stage of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). In part two, the perspective of the dissertation changes from a single-point to a multiple-point allocation environment. In this part, a model is being provided that includes the allocation of slots in an airport network. As a key feature, slots are being allocated such that the two complementary cost functions are being minimized. On one hand, the developed carbon cost function includes the minimization of the carbon footprint per traveling passenger. On the other hand, the developed handling cost function is being minimized incorporating a dedicated airport perspective to the solution. In part three, the proposed model is being further extended by the incorporation of a third directive, the minimization of connection cost, related to the application of solution in a hub-and-spoke network. As a result, the study demonstrates how slot allocation can be conducted efficiently in an airport network, and how the consideration of the carbon footprint per traveling passenger serves to calculate the allocation optimum.
Door-to-door (D2D) air travel is gaining momentum for airlines, airports, and feeder traffic providers. The mobility industry and researchers are broadening their scope to include the entire travel chain, from origin to final destination. Intermodal mobility products are already on the market. At the same time, widespread trends affect transport service providers (as the suppliers) and passengers (regarding demand). Acquiring a better understanding of future D2D air travel trends is crucial for the mobility sector for long-term planning, product adaptation, the services provided and the pricing of these, and improvements in the passenger experience. Focusing on the European market, the overall objective of this doctoral thesis is to identify and understand the future trends of D2D air travel. It is divided into three parts; these provide different perspectives on trends and employ a range of methods that lead to results that develop from each other.
In Part One, the Delphi technique is utilized to identify future travel trends. The study considers projections of European air passengers and their requirements for their entire air travel chain, including airport access, a long-haul flight, and airport egress. The research focuses on 2035 and is based on a two-round Delphi survey involving 38 experts from the transport industry, academia, and consultants. The Delphi survey is supplemented with findings from a preliminary study, consisting of a literature review, interviews with 18 experts in the field of air travel, and a workshop attended by experts. Results reveal that digitalization and personalization will be the main drivers in 2035 and that passengers might demand value-added use of their travel time. In addition, environmentally friendly travel products are considered desirable but only somewhat probable by 2035. Passenger type, age, origins, and travel budget will still be influential factors in 2035. Based on the results from a hierarchical cluster analysis, Part One presents three possible future scenarios: (1) personalized D2D travel, (2) integrated D2D travel, and (3) the game-changer. A technical chapter elaborates on the Delphi technique and individual research steps.
Part Two explores the supply aspect and to what extent transport service providers consider strategically relevant trends. The scope of D2D air travel is adapted by applying multi-labeled text classification models to 52 corporate reports from a sample of transport service providers that operate in the European market. Trends identified in the first Delphi study and from an additional literature review are used to develop seven classes. Two prototype models are developed: a dictionary-based classifier and a supervised learning model using the multinomial naive Bayes and linear support vector machine classifiers. The latter yields the best model output, revealing which trends have a higher, medium, or lower relevance on the supply side. The results show that providers consider environmentally friendly air transport and related products to be highly relevant while disruption management, leveraging passengers’ data, and improving airport feeder traffic through innovative mobility initiatives are considered to be of medium relevance.
Part Three explores air passengers’ preferences and willingness to pay for ancillary services in the current transition into the new normal, brought about by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, high uncertainty, and changing market dynamics. A choice-based conjoint analysis is used to test six attributes within a hypothetical travel scenario for a long-haul one-way air trip. Choice data from 269 German business and leisure passengers are analyzed using a hierarchical Bayes estimator. Results reveal that the total ancillary service upgrade price influences passengers’ choices the most, followed by a seat upgrade for greater comfort and the CO2-compensation of a flight. Hygiene-related ancillaries bring low utilities. Female and senior passengers care more for environmentally friendly ancillaries. Confirming previous research, business passengers and frequent flyers care more for onboard comfort.
Transportation is the backbone of globalization and international trade. Moving goods over long distances enables companies to access new markets and consumers to buy products from other parts of the world. Global trade is particularly driven by sea freight due to low cost and air cargo owing to its high speed, making both transport modes key for many industries. Anticipating future developments in transportation remains a black box for many companies. The logistics sector is characterized by high price uncertainty, market volatility, and product complexity. Transport is often organized manually and only based on employees’ experience, making it prone to error. Recent trends in international trade further complicate companies’ decisionmaking. Trends include changes in global demand, particularly driven by growing wealth in Asian countries, leading to shifts in freight rates on major trade lanes. The risk of supply chain disruptions, such as delays of container vessels, has also been increasing in the last few years. More frequent extreme weather events caused by climate change and higher traffic on shipping routes make on-time arrivals more challenging than ever. Recent breakthroughs in research indicate that novel data analytics-based methods can help to increase transparency in transportation by supporting the decision-making of shipping players. It has become evident that machine learning enhances forecast accuracy, which could enable companies to reduce uncertainty in their logistics. In our first study (Chapter 2), we1 analyze the container shipping industry to predict delays of vessels. With a forecast accuracy of 77%, we identify important influencing factors for shipping delays. This primarily includes the time between ports, piracy risk, demographics, weather, traffic in maritime chokepoints, and port congestion. In our second study (Chapter 3), we present what methods need to be applied to predict spot rates in container shipping. With an accuracy of 89%, our forecasts support the decision-making of various shipping players in negotiating their transportation contracts. My dissertation journey then took me to the air cargo industry in our third study (Chapter 4). By assessing the predictability of long-term air freight rates, we show that machine learning improves forecasts, especially for trade lanes with volatile and complex price trends. As a result, we achieve an accuracy of 93%, enabling air carriers and freight forwarders to increase their operating profits by 30%. By proposing prediction solutions featuring high accuracy, robustness, and applicability in practice, this dissertation demonstrates that predictive analytics enhance transparency in transportation. It is our hope that more advanced technologies, such as machine learning, will play an increasingly important role in future decision-making on transportation.
1The term “we” in this dissertation always refers to the authors of Viellechner and Spinler (2020, 2021a,b,c)
In 2020, approximately 151,000 warehouses were operating worldwide, with a total annual expenditure of e300 billion, representing roughly half of total supply chain costs. Optimized warehouse management may provide competitive advantages from both cost and customer service perspectives. One way to achieve these is to leverage the abundance of data collected in supply chains in combination with powerful algorithms. This dissertation investigates how novel data sources and optimization algorithms, such as machine learning, can be applied in the context of warehouse advancement. In this research, we1 analyze the warehouse environment from two perspectives. On the one hand, we examine two available resources in warehouses—equipment and employees—and explore how predicting breakdowns and productivity, respectively, may improve warehouse performance. On the other hand, we investigate whether the warehouse concept of crossdocking can be applied virtually to allow dynamic transfers between delivery vehicles.
In our first paper, we partner with one of the largest logistics service providers to examine how master, usage and sensor data on material handling equipment can be incorporated into a predictive maintenance model. Existing literature focuses on either time- or condition-based variables, whereas we show, in a comprehensive study of statistical learning methods, that both variable types can be included simultaneously. Our predictive maintenance model is able to capture the majority of breakdowns (> 85%), while maintaining a low false-positive ratio (< 7%).
In our second paper, we work with the same logistics service provider and apply Extreme Gradient Boosting to predict the productivity of new hires. We include operator, shift and product data to show that productivity can be predicted on an individual employee basis while substantially decreasing the forecasting error (50%), which translates into cost savings.
In our third paper, we look at dynamic and synchronized transshipments during direct deliveries. This concept uses transfers between vehicles, as carried out in cross-docking, but without the need for a physical warehouse. This reduces the proportion of empty return trips by increasing the proximity of vehicles to their location of origin. Our easy-to-implement multi-algorithm reduces the total distance by 15% on average compared with simple direct deliveries, and solves large problem instances within reasonable computational times.
This dissertation with its individual research contributions highlights how novel data sources and optimization algorithms can contribute to advancing warehouse management, and highlights the managerial implications of all three topics.
1The term “we” refers to the authors of the respective chapters, as denoted at the beginning of each chapter.
This dissertation investigates the value of customer behavior in supply chain management through the application of (big) data analytics in demand forecasting. The use of advanced analytics in supply chain management is not novel. However, the growing expansion of data volumes provides companies with new opportunities to optimize their supply chain. Despite the rising interest from both academia and practice and the recent increase in publications in this area, empirical insights are still limited. At the same time, changes in customer expectations towards instant product delivery require companies to rethink their supply chain, where accurate demand forecasts are often at the core of enabling efficient and flexible processes. This makes the development of demand prediction models that can be used in practice especially relevant. We1 analyze the use of customer behavior in demand forecasting in three separate research papers. Leveraging data from research partners in the online fashion and construction industry, we assess the potential of the developed prediction models in three areas of application in supply chain management, namely order fulfillment, order picking, and inventory planning. In the first paper, we develop a prediction model for anticipatory shipping in the fashion industry, which predicts customers’ online purchases with the aim of shipping products in advance, and subsequently minimizing delivery times. Using various forecasting methods and data on customers’ behavior on the website, we test if, and how early, it is possible to predict online purchases. Results indicate that customer purchases are, to a certain extent, predictable, but anticipatory shipping comes at a high cost due to wrongly sent products. The second paper assesses the extent to which clickstream data can improve forecast accuracy for fashion products. Specifically, we assess which clickstream variables are most suitable for predicting demand, and identify the products that benefit most from this. Results indicate that clickstream data is especially useful for forecasting medium- and certain intermittent-demand products. A simulation of order picking for these products shows that using clickstream data in the forecast substantially decreases picking times. The third paper investigates how sequential pattern mining can be used to determine products with correlated demand, and how to leverage this as an input into forecasting for a supplier in the construction industry. We find that sequential pattern mining may be beneficial when used in combination with traditional forecasting methods, and that support vector regression models seem especially suited to forecast intermittent-demand products. An application to inventory planning shows that our developed forecasting model might reduce the company’s costs of inventory holding and lost sales by up to 6.9%. Overall, our research highlights the value of using customer behavior to enhance demand forecasting and the benefit of using improved forecasts in various applications in supply chain management.
1Referring to the authors of the respective chapters as noted at the beginning of each chapter.
Supply chain complexity
(2019)
Supply chain management (SCM) is known as a competitive strategy in today’s business. Through increasing product variety, structures and processes, managers struggle with an increase in supply chain complexity (SCC), which leads to a negative influence on a firm’s efficiency in terms of lead times, flexibility and costs. In order to manage complexity, supply chain managers need to know its drivers or define appropriate management measures. However, managers can no longer manage SCC internally. In order to cope with this challenging issue and achieve overall benefits, it is necessary that the complete supply chain is involved in optimising supply chain processes. An aligned supply chain should ensure that supply chain partners benefit from cost savings. At the same time, supply chain processes should be agile to respond to market volatility, while also being cost-efficient to survive in the highly competitive world.
In this dissertation, three research cases are conducted with different focus areas whereby first drivers for internal and external SCC are explored in a single case study. In order to gain a representative overview of relevant drivers, not only interviews with top managers from a manufacturer are held but also with key managers from suppliers and customers. With the interviews held from the upstream to downstream supply chain, this part of the dissertation sheds light on topical SCC drivers and provides some hypotheses for managing detailed and dynamic SCC. With this case, an academic contribution is provided to better understand the relevance of SCC.
In a second step, another qualitative study addresses the requirements of a supply chain. The basis for this part is the triple-A supply chain of Hau Lee (2004), where he states from a theoretical perspective the prerequisites of a supply chain, namely agility, adaptability and alignment. In this dissertation, this approach is reviewed from a managerial perspective. It is analysed which key performance indicators of a firm are affected by the three aforementioned qualities. Finally, it is presented how agility, adaptability and alignment are linked together. In order to gain a common understanding, semi-structured interviews are conducted to extend literature through managerial experience.
In a third step, a quantitative simulation creating a discrete-event simulation model is provided to evaluate inventory and logistics costs’ effects in a company that faces significant SCC. The target is to align the supply chain by changing the existing distribution channel to direct delivery. The result shall demonstrate the financial benefit for the supply chain partners, as well as illustrating the conditions and risks when changing supply chain processes.
This dissertation shows that companies are increasingly faced by SCC. In order to respond flexibly to market volatility, supply chains must be agile to ensure that financial risk shall not alarm a company’s existence. Therefore, it is recommended to align the supply chain with a collaborative supply chain model.
This dissertation investigates different applications of data analytics in supply chain planning. In the last years, data analytics became more important, because of the increase of computational power and the larger availability of data. Data analytics is used in various domains to improve operations performance, increase customer satisfaction and revenues. However, both the research and the application of data analytics in supply chain management is still lacking behind other industries. We1 analyze the potential of data analytics in the field of supply chain planning in three exemplary fields: demand forecasting, partial defection prediction and price discrimination. In addition, we demonstrate how to deal with three common challenges in the field of data analytics: the manual effort for method selection and hyperparameter tuning, the difficult interpretability of machine learning methods and the risks associated with data collection through randomized experiments. In the first paper, we develop a method selection approach in the field of intermittent demand prediction. Our model combines high predictive performance with automation and calculation efficiency. Unlike common practice, the prediction method gets automatically chosen for each data set without any manual selection. Our results are stable across three different data sets that come from different sources but all contain intermittent demand time series. We showcase the impact of the proposed forecasting approach with a warehouse operation simulation. We thereby prove the financial benefit with empirical data. In the second paper, we deal with partial defection prediction in a business-tobusiness environment in the logistics industry. The predictions must combine predictive performance with interpretability and profit maximization. Our model uses a large variety of customer-based and time-series-based features to predict the probability of partial defection for each customer. We use a data permutation approach to make the best performing, black-box models interpretable. Furthermore, we use a profit assessment to identify the method that leads to the highest revenue through successful retention actions. In the third paper, we study price sensitivity prediction. We do not use any randomized experiments, because the risk of loosing customers through such experiments is too high. Thereby, we address the challenge of data availability
1The term “we” refers to the authors of the respective chapters as denoted at the beginning of each chapter. For the abstract, this refers to the authors of Faber and Spinler (2019a,b,c).
This dissertation integrates three papers on risk management in complex new product development projects (NPD) with an integrated perspective on the automotive industry. It seeks to provide a comprehensive access to the topic by highlighting the most relevant risk management aspects in NPD – processes and methods (chapter 2), organization and coordination (chapter 3) as well as culture and strategy (chapter 4).
The focus of chapter 2 lies on the identification and assessment of risks as the initial and most critical risk management steps. It illustrates the application of the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) method as an established multi-criteria decision analysis method to create transparency on the overall risk position of a selected highly complex NPD in the automotive industry. Chapter 2 confirms the AHP method as a suitable approach for stronger preventive risk management in complex NPD with stakeholders with conflicting functional perspectives. This sets the stage for chapter 3 and a subsequent consideration of organization and coordination.
Chapter 3 considers an issue of organization and coordination in complex NPD that is mainly based on the fact that the involved stakeholders have individual targets and rely on concurrent processes. The selected automotive industry example illustrates the resulting managerial challenge of balancing the overall NPD requirements such as product characteristics and development lead time (system perspective) and the targets of single stakeholders in NPD (individual perspective). The NK model as an important setting for search builds the methodical basis to solve this issue and results in optimized organizational and coordination setups.
The implications on risk management in complex NPD as a result of newly emerging NPD types in the automotive industry are subject to chapter 4. These implications are in line with profound industry changes that include changes in the requirements of customers and markets. Chapter 4 uses complexity theory and deploys the lens of complex adaptive systems (CAS) to NPD to outline the emerging NPD types and their implications on risk framing activities. An extended risk framework is derived as basis that addresses the cultural and strategic shift in the automotive industry with regard to managing risk in emerging NPD types.
This dissertation assesses the characteristics and viability of the emerging longhaul Low Cost Carriers (LCCs). In particular, the aim is to understand their business model, evaluate the cost and revenue performance, and investigate its impact on other carriers. Existing academic literature is inconclusive about characteristics and viability of the business model. To validate its defining characteristics, 37 airlines flying on North Atlantic routes are clustered using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) along a newly constructed long-haul airline business model framework. To contribute to the evaluation of business model viability, cost differences between clusters are uncovered followed by a discussion of their sustainability. Key findings include the characterization of the emerging long-haul LCC business model and its significant differences from Full-Service Network Carrier (FSNC) and leisure carrier models. On a cluster average, 33% lower unit costs compared to FSNCs are identified, of which 24 percentage points are evaluated as sustainable. As these cost advantages over FSNCs are smaller compared to the original savings of short-/medium-haul LCCs, revenue competitiveness on the longhaul becomes more critical. To assess long-haul revenue performance, a new metric for benchmarking the revenue per equivalent flight capacity is defined. Subsequently, a revenue model combining traffic, fare, load factor, and seat data from the North Atlantic is developed to determine the revenue per flight capacity across a sample of city-pairs. The results show that LCCs earn revenue per flight capacity comparable to FSNCs on shorter long-haul routes. Key factors to compensate lower direct yields are fewer low-yield connecting passengers, sales of ancillary services, higher load factors, and significantly more passengers per aircraft. Long-haul LCC market impact, and in particular their impact on incumbents’ fare levels, has not yet been assessed and short-/medium-haul LCC-related findings cannot be readily applied. To evaluate the impact of long-haul LCC presence on the incumbents’ pricing, a stylized analytical model is proposed for hypotheses development. Subsequently, Two-Steps Least Squares (2SLS) regressions with Instrumental Variables (IVs) are performed, distinguishing between economy, premium economy, and business classes, based on a sample of North Atlantic routes. Confirming the first hypothesis, LCC presence reduces incumbents’ long-haul economy and premium economy fares by -10% and -13%, respectively, ceteris paribus. LCC presence, however, does not significantly impact long-haul business class fare levels, confirming the second hypothesis. These findings are particularly relevant as the North Atlantic market represents to date one of the remaining profit pools for North American and European legacy carriers. The findings of this research implicate that the long-haul LCC model is economically viable, at least on trunk routes with high demand. FSNC management should be aware of the rising competition and fare impact on North Atlantic routes. Potential reactions could include the de-bundling of entry fares with the option of ancillary sales even on long-haul routes, a re-evaluation of the revenue impact of low-yield connecting passengers, a focus on premium passengers, and a continuous reduction of operating costs.
This dissertation investigates the application of machine learning to improve decision making in airline operations. In an introductory overview, we1 discuss the airline industry and the challenges of decision making in airline operations: e. g., complex IT infrastructure, interconnected resources, delay management, fuel price volatility and future environmental regulation. Machine learning can efficiently integrate a large volume of data from a variety of data sources and formats to generate accurate predictions. To assess the viability of using machine learning models for decision making in airline operations, we develop a model based on linear regression and gradient boosting to predict aircraft arrival time. Furthermore, we integrate cost index optimization to model the impact of aircraft speed on arrival time. While we find that machine learning can improve prediction accuracy by more than 30 %, the optimal cost index varies according to fuel cost, flight distance and delay costs. We propose an overall reduction in cost index for short-haul flights to reduce fuel cost while maintaining punctual operations. Arrival time predictions serve as input for daily operations planning and control. For network carriers accurate arrival time predictions are key for efficient hub operations. In a next step, we focus on aircraft arrival time prediction for intercontinental flights. We analyze the accuracy of en-route weather data provided by the flight plan, generate features based on en-route weather data and integrate them in our prediction model. We evaluate three machine learning models: linear regression, random forest and gradient boosting. Through our approach, we can assess the impact of en-route weather data. Overall, an increase in prediction accuracy of 25 % is achieved. By including en-route weather data, prediction accuracy is improved by 5 %. Our model outlines the essential features for intercontinental arrival time predictions and assess the value of en-route weather data. Furthermore, we outline organizational challenges in implementing predictive analytics. Future environmental regulations are a challenge for the airline industry. From 2020 onwards net growth in CO2 emissions is prohibited. Thus, airlines need to focus on initiatives to limit fuel consumption. We develop a prediction model for fuel consumption considering ten different aircraft types. Our results show that fuel consumption can be improved by more than 30 % for short and long-haul flights resulting in an annual reduction of 10.5 million e in fuel costs and a reduction on green house gas emissions of 66.000 tons. Furthermore, we assess the pilots’ willingness to integrate our prediction model in their fuel decision. Our analysis shows that high prediction accuracy, model understanding and a long testing phase are essential for acceptance of the prediction model. The main implication is that decision making in airline operations can be substantially improved through machine learning. Therefore, more prediction.
1The term “we” refers to the authors of the respective chapters as denoted at the beginning of each chapter. For the abstract, this refers to the authors of Achenbach and Spinler (2018a,b), Achenbach et al. (2017).
This dissertation investigates capacity and technology choice decisions in maritime container shipping under demand and regulatory uncertainty. In an introductory overview, we discuss the industry and the challenges that complicate investment decisions in shipping: e. g., the multitude of decisions, market volatility, excess capacities and the trend of new environmental regulation. Real option valuation methods can account for strategic options and the uncertainties in capacity decisions in shipping. To assess the impact of chartering on maritime investment, we analyze investment and charter options individually in a continuous-time model. We combine both in a discrete-time approach taking into account key features of the industry: investment with time to build, divestment, chartering, an endogenous charter rate, layup, and demand uncertainty. While we find demand volatility to increase optimal capacities if only investment with time to build is possible, chartering reduces this effect. It adds value to the overall project, should be mainly applied to compensate unexpected capacity shortages and needs to be considered in decision-making. Uncertainty about future eco-regulation is a further challenge for the industry. In an approximate dynamic programming model extension, we account for a stochastic introduction of operating cost-increasing regulation to assess optimal capacity choice under regulatory uncertainty. Regulation can allow for grandfathering, affecting only newly acquired vessels. We find uncertainty about future regulation with grandfathering to induce heavy up-front investment to secure a low cost base even in regulated markets. Such uncertainty may increase excess capacities and industry emissions. Uncertainty without grandfathering, however, reduces overall investment and emissions. In this case, the market may contract as investors resort to chartering until uncertainty is resolved. To also assess technology choice in light of uncertain future regulation, we develop a two-phase regime-switching model. We derive analytical solutions and study the effects of regulatory uncertainty on technology choice in a numerical extension that relaxes restrictive assumptions. We find that such uncertainty can increase optimal capacities and that a single-technology strategy is preferable over a fleet of mixed technologies in most cases. We further extend the model and compare the effectiveness of two different regimes—an emissions cap and an emissions tax. Results suggest that an emissions cap is more effective at reducing overall emissions while a tax causes lower regulation cost. The regime choice also determines the optimal technological fleet composition. The main implication is that chartering and regulatory uncertainty have a strong effect on optimal investment in shipping and should be considered in project valuation. Further, regulatory uncertainty can lead to unintended investment behavior that undermines regulatory goals. Lastly, regulatory regimes are not equally effective/efficient in reducing the environmental footprint of shipping and constitute varying incentives for investing in eco-friendly technology.