TY - JOUR A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Rückel, Bastian A1 - Sölch, Christian A1 - Zöttl, Gregor T1 - Regionally differentiated network fees to affect incentives for generation investment JF - Energy N2 - In this paper we propose an equilibrium model that allows to analyze subsidization schemes to affect locational choices for generation investment in electricity markets. Our framework takes into account generation investment decided by private investors and redispatch as well as network expansion decided by a regulated transmission system operator. In order to take into account the different objectives and decision variables of those agents, our approach uses a bi-level structure. We focus on the case of regionally differentiated network fees which have to be paid by generators (a so called g-component). The resulting investment and production decisions are compared to the outcome of an equilibrium model in the absence of such regionally differentiated investment incentives and to an overall optimal (first-best) benchmark. To illustrate possible economic effects, we calibrate our framework with data from the German electricity market. Our results reveal that while regionally differentiated network fees do have a significant impact on locational choice of generation capacities, we do not find significant effects on either welfare or network expansion. KW - Electricity Markets, Network Expansion, Generation Expansion, Investment Incentives, Computational Equilibrium Models Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2019.04.035 IS - 177 SP - 487 EP - 502 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Grübel, Julia A1 - Rückel, Bastian A1 - Sölch, Christian A1 - Zöttl, Gregor T1 - Storage investment and network expansion in distribution networks: The impact of regulatory frameworks JF - Applied Energy N2 - In this paper we propose a bi-level equilibrium model that allows to analyze the impact of different regulatory frameworks on storage and network investment in distribution networks. In our model, a regulated distribution system operator decides on network investment and operation while he anticipates the decisions of private agents on storage investment and operation. Since, especially in distribution networks, voltage stability and network losses have a decisive influence on network expansion and operation, we use a linearized AC power flow formulation to adequately account for these aspects. As adjustments of the current regulatory framework, we consider curtailment of renewable production, the introduction of a network fee based on the maximum renewable feed-in, and a subsidy scheme for storage investment. The performance of the different alternative frameworks is compared to the performance under rules that are commonly applied in various countries today, as well as to a system-optimal (first-best) benchmark. To illustrate the economic effects, we calibrate our model with data from the field project Smart Grid Solar. Our results reveal that curtailment and a redesign of network fees both have the potential to significantly reduce total system costs. On the contrary, investment subsidization of storage capacity has only a limited impact as long as the distribution system operator is not allowed to intervene in storage operation. KW - Computational Equilibrium Models; Electricity Markets; Investment Incentives; Distribution Network Expansion Planning; Storage Investment and Operation; Renewable Energy Production; (Self-) Consumption Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2019.114017 IS - 262 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Runge, Philipp A1 - Sölch, Christian A1 - Albert, Jakob A1 - Wasserscheid, Peter A1 - Zöttl, Gregor A1 - Grimm, Veronika T1 - Economic comparison of different electric fuels for energy scenarios in 2035 JF - Applied Energy N2 - Electric fuels (e-fuels) enable CO2-neutral mobility and are therefore an alternative to battery-powered electric vehicles. This paper compares the cost-effectiveness of Fischer-Tropsch diesel, methanol and Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers. The production costs of those fuels are to a large part driven by the energy-intensive electrolytic hydrogen production. In this paper, we apply a multi-level electricity market model to calculate future hourly electricity prices for various electricity market designs in Germany for the year 2035. We then assess the economic efficiency of the different fuels under various future market conditions. In particular, we use the electricity price vectors derived from an electricity market model calibrated for 2035 as an input for a mathematical model of the entire process chain from hydrogen production and chemical bonding to the energetic utilization of the fuels in a vehicle. Within this model, we perform a sensitivity analysis, which quantifies the impact of various parameters on the fuel production cost. Most importantly, we consider prices resulting from own model calculations for different energy market designs, the investment cost for the electrolysis systems and the carbon dioxide purchase price. The results suggest that the use of hydrogen, which is temporarily bound to Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers, is a favorable alternative to the more widely discussed synthetic diesel and methanol. KW - Sector Coupling, Eletricity Markets, Electric fuels, Hydrogen Utilization, LOHC, Mobility Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2018.10.023 IS - 233-234 SP - 1078 EP - 1093 ER - TY - INPR A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Martin, Alexander A1 - Sölch, Christian A1 - Weibelzahl, Martin A1 - Zöttl, Gregor T1 - Market-Based Redispatch May Result in Inefficient Dispatch N2 - In this paper we analyze a uniform price electricity spot market that is followed by redispatch in the case of network congestion. We assume that the transmission system operator is incentivized to minimize redispatch cost and compare a cost-based redispatch (CBR) to a market-based redispatch (MBR) mechanism. For networks with at least three nodes we show that in contrast to CBR, in the case of MBR the redispatch cost minimizing allocation may not be short-run efficient. As we demonstrate, in case of MBR the possibility of the transmission system operator to reduce redispatch cost at the expense of a reduced welfare may be driven by the electricity supply side or the electricity demand side. If, however, the transmission system operator is obliged to implement the welfare maximizing (instead of the redispatch cost minimizing) dispatch by regulation, this will result in an efficient dispatch also in case of MBR. KW - Electricity Markets, Redispatch, Congestion Management, Computational Equilibrium Models Y1 - 2019 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Ambrosius, Mirjam A1 - Egerer, Jonas A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - van der Weijde, Adriaan H. T1 - Uncertain bidding zone configurations: The role of expectations for transmission and generation capacity expansion JF - European Journal of Operational Research N2 - Ongoing policy discussions on the reconfiguration of bidding zones in European electricity markets induce uncertainty about the future market design. This paper deals with the question of how this uncertainty affects market participants and their long-run investment decisions in generation and transmission capacity. Generalizing the literature on pro-active network expansion planning, we propose a stochastic multilevel model which incorporates generation capacity investment, network expansion, and market operation, taking into account uncertainty about the future bidding zone configuration. Using a stylized two-node network, we disentangle different effects that uncertainty has on market outcomes. If there is a possibility that future bidding zone configurations provide improved regional price signals, welfare gains materialize even if the change does not actually take place. As a consequence, welfare gains of an actual change of the bidding zone configuration are substantially lower due to those anticipatory effects. Additionally, we show substantial distributional effects in terms of both expected gains and risks, between producers and consumers and between different generation technologies. Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2020.01.024 IS - 285 (1) SP - 343 EP - 359 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Bichler, Martin A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Kretschmer, Sandra A1 - Sutterer, Paul T1 - Market Design for Renewable Energy Auctions: An Analysis of Alternative Auction Formats JF - Energy Economics N2 - Auctions are widely used to determine the remuneration for renewable energies. They typically induce a high concentration of renewable energy plants at very productive sites far-off the main load centres, leading to an inefficient allocation as transmission line capacities are restricted but not considered in the allocation, resulting in an inefficient system configuration in the long run. To counteract these tendencies effectively, we propose a combinatorial auction design that allows to implement regional target capacities, provides a simple pricing rule and maintains a high level of competition between bidders by permitting package bids. By means of extensive numerical experiments we evaluate the combinatorial auction as compared to three further RES auction designs, the current German nationwide auction design, a simple nationwide auction, and regional auctions. We find that if bidders benefit from high enough economies of scale, the combinatorial auction design implements system-optimal target capacities without increasing the average remuneration per kWh as compared to the current German auction design. The prices resulting from the combinatorial auction are linear and anonymous for each region whenever possible, while minimal personalised markups on the linear prices are applied only when necessary. We show that realistic problem sizes can be solved in seconds, even though the problem is computationally hard. KW - renewable energy auction, combinatorial auction, market design Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2020.104904 IS - 92 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Kretschmer, Sandra A1 - Mehl, Simon T1 - Green innovations: The organizational setup of pilot projects and its influence on consumer perceptions JF - Energy Policy N2 - Pilot-, test- and demonstration-projects (PTDs) are a prominent policy tool to promote the adoption of smart, green technologies. However, as technology adoption is heavily dependent on the individual attributes and beliefs of potential adopters, it is important to understand the influence of a PTD’s organizational setup on technology perception. By varying the information about a PTD’s organizational setup in a survey experiment among a selected sample of potential PTD-participants, we gather first experimental evidence for the effect of different setups on the perception of green technologies. We show that the organizational setup has a significant impact on a product’s perceived contribution to the energy transition, its establishment in the market, cost-reduction potential, innovativeness and environmental friendliness. In particular, full organizational cooperation between government, university and industry consistently improves perceptions compared to a partial setup. Regarding the willingness to participate in a PTD, we find that communication and support are the most imperative aspects and even more important than economic benefits. Our findings provide policy-makers with a more ample foundation on how PTDs should be designed to successfully transfer technologies to the market. KW - Pilot projects, Organizational setup, Adoption decision, Quadruple Helix, Innovation diffusion Y1 - 2019 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2020.111474 IS - 142 ER - TY - INPR A1 - Veronika, Grimm A1 - Kretschmer, Sandra A1 - Mehl, Simon T1 - Home energy storage: A characterization of potential adopters in Germany N2 - Home energy storage (HES) poses a promising option to foster flexible electricity demand and grid-stabilising self-supply. Understanding the characteristics of potential storage adopters and their motives for adopting is essential to enable targeted measures to promote diffusion. This paper presents an in-depth analysis of motivational and psychological factors as well as product characteristics that affect the willingness to adopt domestic energy storage. Based on a selective sample of solar panel owners as the main energy storage target group, we find that potential adopters differ systematically in their evaluation of economic and non-economic characteristics of home energy storage. Using correlation-based average linkage clustering, we identify four distinct types of storage adopters: finance-oriented, independence-oriented, idealistic and multilaterally oriented households. Our findings emphasise that segment-specific policy strategies and support mechanisms are needed to stimulate HES adoption to pave the way for a sustainable energy system. KW - Energy storage, Consumer segmentation, Adoption decision, Innovation diffusion Y1 - 2019 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Kleinert, Thomas A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Schmidt, Martin T1 - Outer Approximation for Global Optimization of Mixed-Integer Quadratic Bilevel Problems JF - Mathematical Programming (Series B) N2 - Bilevel optimization problems have received a lot of attention in the last years and decades. Besides numerous theoretical developments there also evolved novel solution algorithms for mixed-integer linear bilevel problems and the most recent algorithms use branch-and-cut techniques from mixed-integer programming that are especially tailored for the bilevel context. In this paper, we consider MIQP-QP bilevel problems, i.e., models with a mixed-integer convex-quadratic upper level and a continuous convex-quadratic lower level. This setting allows for a strong-duality-based transformation of the lower level which yields, in general, an equivalent nonconvex single-level reformulation of the original bilevel problem. Under reasonable assumptions, we can derive both a multi- and a single-tree outer-approximation-based cutting-plane algorithm. We show finite termination and correctness of both methods and present extensive numerical results that illustrate the applicability of the approaches. It turns out that the proposed methods are capable of solving bilevel instances with several thousand variables and constraints and significantly outperform classical solution approaches. KW - Bilevel optimization KW - Outer approximation KW - Quadratic programming KW - Convex mixed-integer nonlinear optimization Y1 - 2019 ER - TY - JOUR A1 - Grimm, Veronika A1 - Kleinert, Thomas A1 - Liers, Frauke A1 - Schmidt, Martin A1 - Zöttl, Gregor T1 - Optimal Price Zones of Electricity Markets: A Mixed-Integer Multilevel Model and Global Solution Approaches JF - Optimization Methods and Software N2 - Mathematical modeling of market design issues in liberalized electricity markets often leads to mixed-integer nonlinear multilevel optimization problems for which no general-purpose solvers exist and which are intractable in general. In this work, we consider the problem of splitting a market area into a given number of price zones such that the resulting market design yields welfare-optimal outcomes. This problem leads to a challenging multilevel model that contains a graph-partitioning problem with multi-commodity flow connectivity constraints and nonlinearities due to proper economic modeling. Furthermore, it has highly symmetric solutions. We develop different problem-tailored solution approaches. In particular, we present an extended KKT transformation approach as well as a generalized Benders approach that both yield globally optimal solutions. These methods, enhanced with techniques such as symmetry breaking and primal heuristics, are evaluated in detail on academic as well as on realistic instances. It turns out that our approaches lead to effective solution methods for the difficult optimization tasks presented here, where the problem-specific generalized Benders approach performs considerably better than the methods based on KKT transformation. KW - Multilevel Optimization KW - Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Optimization KW - Graph Partitioning KW - Generalized Benders Decomposition KW - Electricity Market Design} Y1 - 2017 IS - 34(2) SP - 406 EP - 436 ER -