Mapping Forest Owners' Organisations Across Seven Countries: A Comparative Study of Governance, Membership, and Collective Action
- Forest ownership worldwide is gradually shifting from public to private hands, and this growing, fragmented private ownership has fuelled demand for Forest Owners' Organisations (FOOs) that help owners overcome scale disadvantages, access markets, and achieve sustainable forest management. While FOOs are widely acknowledged in the literature, existing research is largely country-specific, leaving forest owners and institutional investors without a systematic basis for comparing associative structures across regulatory and geographical contexts. This thesis addresses that gap through a comparative case study of FOOs in seven countries spanning four continents: Germany, Finland, Sweden, the United States, Australia, New Zealand, and Chile, selected because the study partner, MEAG, holds forest assets in these countries. Using a qualitative approach combining a literature and document review, semi-structured expert interviews, and the researcher's own observations, each country was analysed against a six-dimensional framework covering ownership context, governance structure, membership eligibility, service provision, financing, and institutional constraints, before findings were synthesised across countries.
The study identifies two dominant governance patterns driven by land tenure. In countries with fragmented private ownership, such as Germany, Finland, and Sweden, bottom-up, multi-tier models prevail. These organizations offer integrated operational services, including timber marketing, silviculture, and forest caretaking through power-of-attorney arrangements. Conversely, in Chile, New Zealand, and Australia, where plantation ownership is highly concentrated, top-down, industry-led models dominate. These entities focus primarily on national policy advocacy and industry-wide representation, often leaving small-scale owners with limited local support. The United States exhibits a hybrid model where state-level FOOs maintain grassroots through County Forestry Associations; at the same time, national organisations split along ownership lines, with some prioritising PFOs and IFOs.
The findings highlight significant structural challenges facing FOOs globally, including a loss of political influence due to shifting governmental priorities, power asymmetries (elite capture) favouring industrial actors, and declining participation driven by urbanization and aging demographics. Furthermore, FOOs must navigate complex social license issues related to Indigenous rights and environmental legitimacy. The resulting country profiles and cross-country patterns provide MEAG and other investors with a practical, comparative basis for engaging with FOOs and support broader efforts to close the sector's communication gap between forest owners and the organisations meant to serve them.