Hesse, Holger
Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
Publication reviewed
- begutachtet (46)
- nicht begutachtet (5)
Keywords
- Batterie (5)
- Akkumulator (4)
- Battery energy storage system (1)
- Carbon dioxide emissions (1)
- Charging station (1)
- Electric vehicles (1)
- Energy management (1)
- Energy storage (1)
- High-power charging (1)
- LEES (1)
The rapid increase of renewable energy sources made coordinated control of the distributed and intermittent generation units a more demanded task. Matching demand and supply is particularly challenging in islanded microgrids. In this study, we have demonstrated a mixed-integer quadratic programming (MIQP) method to achieve efficient use of sources within an islanded microgrid. A unique objective function involving fuel consumption of diesel generator, degradation in a lithium-ion battery energy storage system, carbon emissions, load shifting, and curtailment of the renewable sources is constructed, and an optimal operating point is pursued using the MIQP approach. A systematic and extensive methodology for building the objective function is given in a sequential and explicit manner with an emphasis on a novel model-based battery aging formulation. Performance of the designed system and a sensitivity analysis of resulting battery dispatch, diesel generator usage, and storage aging against a range of optimization parameters are presented by considering real-world specifications of the Semakau Island, an island in the vicinity of Singapore.
Stationäre Batteriespeicher gewinnen sowohl im privaten als auch im gewerblichen Bereich weiterhin an Relevanz:
Fortschritte in Zell- und Systemtechnologie erlauben innovative und kostengünstigere Lösungen, neue Geschäftsfelder werden erschlossen und rechtliche Rahmenbedingungen sind im stetigen Wandel. Dieser Artikel fasst die wichtigsten Entwicklungen und Branchen-Trends für 2021 in Deutschland zusammen und untermauert diese anhand von Umfragen des Experten-Fachforums „BVES Fachforum Batteriespeicher“. Zusätzlich zu einer Markt- und Kostenprognose erlaubt die Auswertung einen Blick auf mögliche neue Anwendungsfelder sowie eine Branchenempfehlung zu Handlungsfeldern in den Bereichen Recht und Regulatorik.
The market ramp-up of electromobility is shifting vehicle-to-grid (V2G) issues into the focus of research and industry. Electric vehicles (EVs) have the potential to support the trend towards renewable energies in their role as storage units during idle times. To participate in balancing power and energy markets, EVs are pooled via aggregators. Instead of a random composition, aggregators can smartly compose their pools and add only those vehicles that actually contribute to the pool’s performance, gaining advantages over competitors. The optimization methods presented in this paper form optimized pool combinations based on the power and energy capability profiles of commercial EVs. Genetic algorithms are used to determine the revenues of the possible pools per participating EV. The use cases analyzed are the provision of balancing power on the frequency containment reserve (FCR) market of Central Europe and energy arbitrage trading on the European power exchange intraday continuous and day-ahead auction spot markets. The results show that through smart pool composition, an aggregator can increase revenue per vehicle by up to seven-fold across the markets compared to randomly assembled pools. In the Central European market, for example, the potential V2G revenues on the FCR market (380 €) exceeded those of arbitrage trading (28 € − 203 €) in 2020. In a simulation, we show the increased degradation of the vehicle battery in V2G operation compared to sole use for mobility with a smart charging strategy. However, the additional revenue can make V2G financially worthwhile, depending on costs for measuring equipment, bidirectional charging stations, and aggregator costs.
Electric vehicles (EVs) can participate in various markets through a vehicle-to-grid (V2G) interface. Aggregators can combine the individual contributions of EVs to offer them, for example, on the frequency containment reserve (FCR) market or to use them for arbitrage trading. A simple approach is combining EVs in random fashion until the pool is able to reach the threshold for a service of choice. Alternatively, aggregators can compose their pools in smart fashion and include only EVs that contribute significantly to the pool's performance. In a previous publication, we have shown that optimizing the aggregated pools of commercial vehicles for the provision of FCR or arbitrage trading can increase revenues by up to 7-fold. In this work, we analyze the optimally composed pools and show that large vehicle batteries in the order of 80 kWh are particularly useful for arbitrage trading, while FCR provision is also possible with medium-sized EV batteries in the range of 30 kWh due to the small cycle depths. The inclusion of EVs with very small vehicle batteries around 20 kWh in aggregated pools is neither economically optimal for arbitrage trading nor for FCR provision. An analysis of the economic sectors of the commercial EVs selected for the optimal EV pools shows that some economic sectors are more suitable for V2G than others: In particular EVs of the sector “human health and social work activities” are unsuitable for V2G provision due to regular and long travel times during the day. In contrast, EVs from the "manufacturing" sector are particularly well represented in all applications and the "transportation and storage" sector in the arbitrage application. In addition to these analyses of the optimized pools, we reveal that a reduction in the required minimum power and increments would make the FCR market even more attractive to EV pools by increasing revenues by 50% to 66%. It would also better exploit the potential of EVs, as increments could be better utilized than they are in the current 1 MW minimum power requirement in central Europe.
Utility-scale battery storage systems typically consist of multiple smaller units contributing to the overall power dispatch of the system. Herein, the power distribution among these units is analyzed and optimized to operate the system with increased energy efficiency. To improve the real-life storage operation, a holistic system model for battery storage systems has been developed that enables a calculation of the energy efficiency. A utility-scale Second-Life battery storage system with a capacity of 3.3 MWh/3 MW is operated and evaluated in this work. The system is in operation for the provision of primary control reserve in combination with intraday trading for controlling the battery state of charge. The simulation model is parameterized with the system data. Results show that losses in power electronics dominate. An operational strategy improving the energy efficiency through an optimized power flow distribution within the storage system is developed. The power flow distribution strategy is based on the reduction of the power electronics losses at no-load/partial-load by minimizing their in-operation time. The simulation derived power flow distribution strategy is implemented in the real-life storage system. Field-test measurements and analysis prove the functionality of the power flow distribution strategy and reveal the reduction of the energy throughput of the units by 7%, as well as a significant reduction of energy losses in the units by 24%. The cost savings for electricity over the system’s lifetime are approximated to 4.4% of its investment cost
A high electric vehicle penetration in urban distribution grids leads to challenges, such as line over loading for the grid operator. In such a case smart charging strategies or the installation of grid integrated storage systems represent an alternative to conventional grid reinforcement. This paper examines the influence of various charging strategies at electric vehicle charging parks to the peak grid load. Furthermore, the battery energy storage systems with various capacities located at these charging parks are simulated with a control strategy aiming to reduce the impact to the grid. Results show that with controlled charging strategies the capacity of the storage systems at the charging parks can be reduced from 2MWh to 600kWh while achieving the same reduction of peak load at the point of common coupling
Energy efficiency is a key performance indicator for battery storage systems. A detailed electro-thermal model of a stationary lithium-ion battery system is developed and an evaluation of its energy efficiency is conducted. The model offers a holistic approach to calculating conversion losses and auxiliary power consumption. Sub-models for battery rack, power electronics, thermal management as well as the control and monitoring components are developed and coupled to a comprehensive model. The simulation is parametrized based on a prototype 192 kWh system using lithium iron phosphate batteries connected to the low voltage grid. The key loss mechanisms are identified, thoroughly analyzed and modeled. Generic profiles featuring various system operation modes are evaluated to show the characteristics of stationary battery systems. Typically the losses in the power electronics outweigh the losses in the battery at low power operating points. The auxiliary power consumption dominates for low system utilization rates. For estimation of real-world performance, the grid applications Primary Control Reserve, Secondary Control Reserve and the storage of surplus photovoltaic power are evaluated. Conversion round-trip efficiency is in the range of 70–80%. Overall system efficiency, which also considers system power consumption, is 8–13 percentage points lower for Primary Control Reserve and the photovoltaic-battery application. However, for Secondary Control Reserve, the total round-trip efficiency is found to be extremely low at 23% due to the low energy throughput of this application type.
For reliable lifetime predictions of lithium-ion batteries, models for cell degradation are required. A comprehensive semi-empirical model based on a reduced set of internal cell parameters and physically justified degradation functions for the capacity loss is developed and presented for a commercial lithium iron phosphate/graphite cell. One calendar and several cycle aging effects are modeled separately. Emphasis is placed on the varying degradation at different temperatures. Degradation mechanisms for cycle aging at high and low temperatures as well as the increased cycling degradation at high state of charge are calculated separately. For parameterization, a lifetime test study is conducted including storage and cycle tests. Additionally, the model is validated through a dynamic current profile based on real-world application in a stationary energy storage system revealing the accuracy. Tests for validation are continued for up to 114 days after the longest parametrization tests. The model error for the cell capacity loss in the application-based tests is at the end of testing below 1% of the original cell capacity and the maximum relative model error is below 21%.
The connection to the electrical grid is a key component of stationary battery energy storage systems. Utility-scale systems comprise of several power electronics units. Various grid connection topologies may be used, depending on the conversion stages within each unit, the load distribution between the power electronics and additionally the grid level to which the system is connected. The energy efficiency, which is a key performance indicator for storage systems, is compared between various scenarios. Detailed models are developed for the key components: The inverter/rectifier, the DC-DC converter, and the transformer. The respective model parameterization is based on state-of-art industry components and compared against experimental data. Two grid application scenarios, namely Primary Control Reserve and Secondary Control Reserve, are simulated for a comparison in reference application scenarios often discussed for utility-scale battery energy storage systems. Results show that grid connection setups without an intermediate DC link conversion stage are more efficient than those with. The optimum number of inverters in dependence on the actual load is determined. The connection to the low-voltage grid is more efficient due to the absence of the transformer which introduces significant additional losses. The topology models developed herein can be integrated into system models that include the overall systems or used for the design of novel battery systems grid connection topologies with detailed evaluation down to the component level.
Produzierende Unternehmen stehen aufgrund steigender Preise für elektrische Energie großen Herausforderungen gegenüber. Der durchschnittliche Strompreis für die Industrie stieg in Deutschland von 12,07 ct pro kWh im Jahr 2010 auf 21,38 ct pro kWh im Jahr 2021. Batteriespeicherlösungen bieten vielfältige Anwendungsfälle, um Industriebetriebe energiewirtschaftlich zu optimieren. Dazu gehören beispielsweise die intensive Netznutzung, oder eine Kombination aus der atypischen Netznutzung und der Primärregelleistungsvermarktung. Der vorliegende Beitrag beschreibt zunächst diese Anwendungsfälle und geht im Anschluss auf unterschiedliche Typen von Batteriespeichersystemen ein, die hierfür eingesetzt werden können. Es wird daraufhin ein exemplarisches Batteriespeichersystem bei einem Industrieunternehmen vorgestellt. Der Beitrag schließt mit der Beschreibung eines innovativen, auf künstlicher Intelligenz basierenden Ansatzes zur zuverlässigen Steuerung von Batteriespeichersystemen, um einer hohen Komplexität des Gesamtsystems zu begegnen.
The industry is facing major challenges due to rising prices for electrical energy. The average electricity price for industry in Germany rose from 12.07 ct per kWh in 2010 to 19.09 ct per kWh in 2021. Battery storage solutions offer a wide range of applications to optimize industrial companies in terms of energy management. These are, for example, the intensive grid use or a combination of atypical grid use and the marketing of primary balancing power. This article describes these use cases and explains different types of suitable battery storage systems. In the following, an exemplary battery storage system at an industrial company is presented. The article closes with the description of an innovative approach based on artificial intelligence. This enables the control of battery storage systems in the case of challenges due to the high complexity of the overall system.
Battery-Assistance vs. Grid Reinforcement for High-Power EV Charging: An Emissions Perspective
(2021)
An increasingly large number of battery electric vehicles (BEVs) and electric buses are hitting the roads globally each year. These numbers are expected to grow further in light of ever-more favourable costs, and improved battery technology that addresses concerns about range anxiety and charging times. This upward trend in electrification of the automobile sector essentially shifts the mobility energy demand from the oil & gas sector to the electricity sector. Power transmission bottlenecks in the grid, caused on the supply-side by periods of strong renewable generation, may get further aggravated by adding demand-side bottlenecks to the mix as well. The grid, at several locations, will need to be overhauled to be able to supply huge bursts of power intermittently to cover large power demands to support fast-charging simultaneously at multiple locations. This can entail huge monetary investments for the upgradation of grid infrastructure. Battery-assisted high power charging (BA-HPC) is thought of as a convenient solution to this problem. This solution enables demand-side peak- load shaving, and draws energy more uniformly over extended periods of time. While this solution may well be economically profitable in some cases, an investigation of the environmental impact of this solution can yield interesting insights, and aid decision-makers by identifying scenarios in which one solution is more favorable over the other. This is crucial, since the rationale for shifting to electromobility is the curbing of greenhouse gas emissions. In this work, we employ in-house python-based time-series analysis simulation tools to simulate the grid reinforcement and the battery energy storage systems, and present comparative lifetime emissions analyses for both solutions in a variety of configurations.
Electrical energy storage systems are key to the integration of intermittent renewable energy technologies such as photovoltaic solar systems and wind turbines. As installed battery energy storage system capacities rise, it is crucial that the environmental impacts of these systems are also positive. In this work, a methodology to ascertain the effect and effectiveness of integration of energy storage on the carbon footprint of isolated island grid energy systems and its reduction is presented. Two metrics are introduced — the Levelized Emissions of Energy Supply (LEES), and the reduction in emissions per additional unit of energy storage (R). The proposed methodology is applied to an island grid scenario to ascertain the variation in the LEES value with the peak power and energy storage capacity of the BESS. A simplified LCA of a utility-scale Lithium-ion BESS is also carried out for this purpose. It is found that for the considered scenarios, incorporation of battery systems is always effective in reducing emissions, with a maximum possible reduction of nearly 50% compared to no storage. With the help of the metric R, the proposed methodology is also useful in identifying isolated energy systems which should be prioritized for incorporation of additional energy storage capacity.
This paper presents a comprehensive calendar aging study on a lithium-ion battery with a test duration of 29 months. This aging study was realized with a widely used commercial LiFePO4/graphite cell from Sony/Murata, which promises both long calendar and cycle lifetime, which is especially required for stationary battery applications. The development of the cells’ capacity, as well as the resistances, are shown in a static calendar aging study for 17 test points, each with 3 cells, having constant storage conditions of temperature and state of charge. Based on the measurement data, a semi-empirical aging model is presented for the capacity loss and resistance increase, consisting of only 5 parameters which are valid for all storage conditions. An additional dynamic calendar aging study is performed with 9 months test duration for model validation, consisting of 15 test points with varying conditions of temperature and state of charge. The absolute model errors against the validation data points remain below 2.2% for the capacity loss and below 6.9% for the resistance increase for all dynamic validation tests. In conclusion, this calendar aging model allows the prognosis of the calendar lifetime of LiFePO4/graphite batteries in different applications with varying storage conditions over time.
This work discusses the grid-level suitability for stationary battery energy storage systems based on lithium ion technology in general, focusing on the integration of such systems in the low-voltage grid-level in Europe. The vast majority of recent research regarding stationary battery storage systems focuses on single-electricity-grid voltage levels, whereas the interaction of different electricity grid-levels has been widely neglected. Challenges in distribution grids mostly originate from the quantity of challenges in low-voltage grids, stationary battery energy storage systems that are operated in low-voltage grids may reduce these challenges. Therefore, this work investigates stationary battery energy storage systems installed in low-voltage grids and their effects on superimposed grid-levels. Simulation results show that grid challenges, addressed by battery storage systems in low-voltage grids, have positive multiplicative impacts on upper grid levels, reducing local grid demand and lowering power peak stress. A proposal is presented for a low-voltage grid battery storage system that can be operated to fulfill the aforementioned functionality and yield the benefits via a multi-purpose or multi-tasking battery storage system.
Recent attention to industrial peak shaving applications sparked an increased interest in battery energy storage. Batteries provide a fast and high power capability, making them an ideal solution for this task. This work proposes a general framework for sizing of battery energy storage system (BESS) in peak shaving applications. A cost-optimal sizing of the battery and power electronics is derived using linear programming based on local demand and billing scheme. A case study conducted with real-world industrial profiles shows the applicability of the approach as well as the return on investment dependence on the load profile. At the same time, the power flow optimization reveals the best storage operation patterns considering a trade-off between energy purchase, peak-power tariff, and battery aging. This underlines the need for a general mathematical optimization approach to efficiently tackle the challenge of peak shaving using an energy storage system. The case study also compares the applicability of yearly and monthly billing schemes, where the highest load of the year/month is the base for the price per kW. The results demonstrate that batteries in peak shaving applications can shorten the payback period when used for large industrial loads. They also show the impacts of peak shaving variation on the return of investment and battery aging of the system.
For reliable lifetime predictions of lithium-ion batteries, models for cell degradation are required. A comprehensive semi-empirical model based on a reduced set of internal cell parameters and physically justified degradation functions for the capacity loss is developed and presented for a commercial lithium iron phosphate/graphite cell. One calendar and several cycle aging effects are modeled separately. Emphasis is placed on the varying degradation at different temperatures. Degradation mechanisms for cycle aging at high and low temperatures as well as the increased cycling degradation at high state of charge are calculated separately.For parameterization, a lifetime test study is conducted including storage and cycle tests. Additionally, the model is validated through a dynamic current profile based on real-world application in a stationary energy storage system revealing the accuracy. The model error for the cell capacity loss in the application-based tests is at the end of testing below 1 % of the original cell capacity.
The growing global electricity demand and the upcoming integration of charging options for electric vehicles is creating challenges for power grids, such as line over loading. With continuously falling costs for lithium-ion batteries, storage systems represent an alternative to conventional grid reinforcement. This paper proposes an operation strategy for battery energy storage systems, targeted at industrial consumers to achieve both an improvement in the distribution grid and electricity bill savings for the industrial consumer. The objective is to reduce the peak power at the point of common coupling in existing distribution grids by adapting the control of the battery energy storage system at individual industrial consumer sites. An open-source simulation tool, which enables a realistic simulation of the effects of storage systems in different operating modes on the distribution grid, has been adapted as part of this work. Further information on the additional stress on the storage system is derived from a detailed analysis based on six key characteristics. The results show that, with the combined approach, both the local peak load and the global peak load can be reduced, while the stress on the energy storage is not significantly increased. The peak load at the point of common coupling is reduced by 5.6 kVA to 56.7 kVA and the additional stress for the storage system is, on average, for a six month simulation, period only 1.2 full equivalent cycles higher.
The imminent coupling of the transport sector with the electricity sector and the possibilities of grid integrated energy storages are creating new potentials and challenges.
With open_BEA (open battery models for electrical grid applications), the following open questions are addressed:
• Which storage technology is costoptimal for a given application?
• How must stationary storage systems optimally positioned, dimensioned and operated in order to provide gridrelated services?
• To which extend are battery electric vehicles capable to serve as a flexibility option in a future power grid?
• Which potential has an energy storage system performing active peak-shaving for future grid planning?
Lithium-ion batteries are used for both stationary and mobile applications. While in the automotive industry standard profiles are used to compare the performance and efficiency of competing vehicles, a similar comparative metric has not been proposed for stationary battery energy storage systems. Because standard profiles are missing, the comparable evaluation of different applications with respect to efficiency, long-term behavior and profitability is very difficult or not possible at all. This work presents a method to create these standard profiles and the results are available as open data for download. Input profiles including frequency data, industry load profiles and household load profiles are transformed into storage profiles including storage power and state of charge using a holistic simulation framework. Various degrees of freedom for the energy management system as well as for the storage design are implemented and the results are post-processed with a profile analyzer tool in order to identify six key characteristics, these being: full-equivalent cycles, efficiency, depth of cycles, resting periods, number of changes of sign and energy throughput between changes of sign. All applications examined in this paper show unique characteristics which are essential for the design of the storage system. E.g., the numbers for annual full-equivalent cycles vary from 19 to 282 and the efficiency lies between 83% and 93%. With aid of this work in conjunction with the open data results, users can test and compare their own cell types, operation strategies and system topologies with those of the paper. Furthermore, the storage power profiles and state of charge data can be used as a reference for lifetime and profitability studies for stationary storage systems.
To achieve maximum profit by dispatching a battery storage system in an arbitrage operation, multiple factors must be considered. While revenue from the application is determined by the time variability of the electricity cost, the profit will be lowered by costs resulting from energy efficiency losses, as well as by battery degradation. In this paper, an optimal dispatch strategy is proposed for storage systems trading on energy arbitrage markets. The dispatch is based on a computationally-efficient implementation of a mixed-integer linear programming method, with a cost function that includes variable-energy conversion losses and a cycle-induced battery capacity fade. The parametrisation of these non-linear functions is backed by in-house laboratory tests. A detailed analysis of the proposed methods is given through case studies of different cost-inclusion scenarios, as well as battery investment-cost scenarios. An evaluation with a sample intraday market data set, collected throughout 2017 in Germany, offers a potential monthly revenue of up to 8762 EUR/MWh cap installed capacity, without accounting for the costs attributed to energy losses and battery degradation. While this is slightly above the revenue attainable in a reference application—namely, primary frequency regulation for the same sample month (7716 EUR/MWh cap installed capacity)—the situation changes if costs are considered: The optimisation reveals that losses in battery ageing and efficiency reduce the attainable profit by up to 36% for the most profitable arbitrage use case considered herein. The findings underline the significance of considering both ageing and efficiency in battery system dispatch optimisation.