Filtern
Dokumenttyp
- Zeitschriftenartikel (3)
- Beitrag zu einem Tagungsband (3)
- Vortrag (1)
- Posterpräsentation (1)
Schlagworte
Organisationseinheit der BAM
Eingeladener Vortrag
- nein (1)
Permeability estimation from induced polarization (IP) measurements is based on a fundamental premise that the characteristic relaxation time τ is related to the effective hydraulic radius reff controlling fluid flow. The approach requires a reliable estimate of the diffusion coefficient of the ions in the electrical double layer. Others have assumed a value for the diffusion coefficient, or postulated different values for clay versus clay-free rocks. We have examined the link between a widely used single estimate of τ and reff for an extensive database of sandstone samples, in which mercury porosimetry data confirm that reff is reliably determined from a modification of the Hagen-Poiseuille equation assuming that the electrical tortuosity is equal to the hydraulic tortuosity. Our database does not support the existence of one or two distinct representative diffusion coefficients but instead demonstrates strong evidence for six orders of magnitude of variation in an apparent Diffusion coefficient that is well-correlated with reff and the specific surface area per unit pore volume Spor. Two scenarios can explain our findings:
(1) the length scale defined by τ is not equal to reff and is likely much longer due to the control of pore-surface roughness or
(2) the range of diffusion coefficients is large and likely determined by the relative proportions of the different minerals (e.g., silica and clays) making up the rock. In either case, the estimation of reff (and hence permeability) is inherently uncertain from a single characteristic IP relaxation time as considered in this study.
Die Methode der Spektral Induzierten Polarisation (SIP) wird eingesetzt, um hydraulische Parameter wie Porosität und Permeabilität von Gesteinen abzuleiten. Dabei wird ein Wechselstrom im Bereich von 1 mHz bis 45 kHz in das Gestein eingespeist und die Phasenverschiebung zwischen elektrischem Strom und Spannung gemessen, woraus die komplexe Leitfähigkeit berechnet wird.
In dieser Arbeit werden die komplexen Leitfähigkeiten von Fontainebleau Sandsteinen mittels einer am Leibnitz-Institut für Angewandte Geophysik (LIAG) hergestellten Messzelle und einer SIP Apparatur des Forschungszentrums Jülich (FZJ) gemessen. Die Fontainebleau Sandsteine stammen aus Frankreich, südlich von Paris und zeichnen sich durch eine nahezu homogene Zusammensetzung aus Quartz aus. Für die Messungen wurden vier Blöcke mit jeweils vier Proben ausgewählt, die in Porosität und Permeabilität variieren. Für die SIP-Messungen werden die Gesteinsproben mit Natriumchlorid Lösung unterschiedlicher Leitfähigkeiten gesättigt, um die Abhängigkeit der IP-Spektren von der Leitfähigkeit des Porenfluids zu untersuchen. Die Messungen werden mit anderen petrophysikalischen Untersuchungen ergänzt, wie z.B. der Bestimmung der Porenradienverteilung mittels Quecksilberporosimetrie und der spezifischen inneren Oberfläche mit Gassorption (BET). Mit dem Raster-Ektronen-Mikroskop werden hochauflösende Bilder der inneren Gesteinsstruktur erzeugt und ausgewertet.
Erste Ergebnisse der SIP-Messungen zeigen deutliche Phasenmaxima im niederfrequenten Bereich, die hinsichtlich ihrer Amplitude und Frequenzlage zwischen den Blöcken variieren.
Ziel der Arbeit ist eine systematische Untersuchung der Polarisationseigenschaften bezüglich der Variabilität von Porosität, Porenradienverteilung, spezifischen inneren Oberfläche und Fluidleitfähigkeit, um die Zusammenhänge qualitativ und quantitativ zu charakterisieren.
In der Vergangenheit wurde immer wieder diskutiert, ob die Porenhalsverteilung poröser silikatischer Medien maßgeblich die Relaxationszeit in Messergebnissen der Spektralen Induzierten Polarisation (SIP) bestimmt und dementsprechend auch neuere Ansätze, Porenweitenverteilungen aus diesen Daten abzuleiten, zuverlässig sein können. Systematische Studien an Gesteinen mit sehr unterschiedlichen Porenverteilungen zeigten, dass in Materialien mit engen Porenhälsen (z.B. < 5 μm) vor allem oder zusätzlich zum vermuteten Porenhalspeak niederfrequente Relaxationen zu beobachten sind, deren Ursache noch unklar ist.
Unter Einbeziehung der Methoden Röntgen-Computertomografie (μ-CT), Quecksilberporosimetrie (MIP), Stickstoffabsortion, Nukleare Magnetische Resonanz, SIP und Auflichtmikroskopie untersuchen wir den Porenraum hinsichtlich der Parameter Porosität, Permeabilität und innere Oberfläche und bestimmen die geometrischen Eigenschaften wie Porenweitenverteilungen oder fraktale Dimension durch verschiedene Algorithmen. Dabei ist zu berücksichtigen, dass sich die Methoden hinsichtlich der Grenzen ihres Auflösungsvermögens unterscheiden. Mit einer Zusammenführung der Ergebnisse aller Methoden kann eine mehrere Längenskalen überdeckende Charakterisierung der Porenraumgeometrie erfolgen.
Die Anwendung und Auswertung der verschiedenen Methoden werden am Beispiel von Baumberger Kalksandstein und Bentheimer Sandstein verglichen und diskutiert.
We investigate the pore space of rock samples with respect to different petrophysical parameters using various methods, which provide data upon pore size distributions, including micro computed tomography (μ-CT), mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and spectral induced polarization (SIP). The resulting cumulative distributions of pore volume as a function of pore size are compared. Considering that the methods differ with regard to their limits of resolution, a multiple length scale characterization of the pore space geometry is proposed, that is based on a combination of the results from all of these methods. The findings of this approach are compared and discussed by using Bentheimer sandstone. Additionally, we compare the potential of SIP to provide a pore size distribution with other commonly used methods (MIP, NMR). The limits of resolution of SIP depend on the usable frequency range (between 0.002 and 100 Hz). The methods with similar resolution show a similar behavior of the cumulative pore volume distribution in the overlapping pore size range. The methods μ-CT and NMR provide the pore body size while MIP and SIP characterize the pore throat size. Using this difference, the average pore body to throat ratio is determined to be about three for the Bentheimer sandstone.
Our study shows that a good agreement between the pore radii distributions can only be achieved if the curves are adjusted considering the resolution and pore volume in the relevant range of pore radii. The MIP curve with the widest range in resolution should be used as reference
Other than commonly assumed the relaxation times observed in the electrical low-frequency range (1 mHz – 40 kHz) of natural porous media like sandstones and tuff stones cannot be directly related to the dominant (modal) pore throat sizes, measured (e.g.) with mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP). Working with a great variety of sandstones from very different origins and featuring great variations in textural and chemical compositions as well as in geometrical pore space properties, it was observed that particularly samples with narrow pore throats were characterized by long (low-frequency) relaxations. These, however, can (following the current theories) be rather explained by long “characteristic length scales” in these media or low diffusion coefficients along the electrical double layer. However, there is no straightforward way (or single approved method) of getting reliable numbers for properties such as the lengths of pore throats, the diameter and length of the wide pores and their respective distributions. Consequently we follow a multi-methodical approach and combine the benefits of MIP, micro-computed tomography (μ-CT) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to achieve much deeper insight due to the different resolutions and sensitivities to either pore constrictions (throats) or wide pores. This helps us to understand, whether the observed electrical relaxation phenomena actually depend on geometric length scales or rather on other properties such as chemical composition, clay content, clay type or cation exchange capacity. In this paper, we showcase selected results of a systematic study of a total of 16 sandstones and three tuffs. Findings and the particular advantage of the used method combination are discussed and shown in detail for a representative sample selection.
Permeability estimation from spectral induced
polarization (SIP) measurements is based on a
fundamental premise that the characteristic relaxation
time (t) is related to the effective hydraulic radius (reff)
controlling fluid flow. The approach requires a reliable
estimate of the diffusion coefficient of the ions in the
electrical double layer. Others have assumed a value for
the diffusion coefficient, or postulated different values for
clay versus clay-free rocks. We examine the link between
t and reff for an extensive database of sandstone samples
where mercury porosimetry data confirm that reff is
reliably determined from a modification of the Hagen-
Poiseuille equation assuming that the electrical tortuosity
is equal to the hydraulic tortuosity. Our database does not
support the existence of 1 or 2 distinct representative
diffusion coefficients but instead demonstrates strong
evidence for 6 orders of magnitude of variation in an
apparent diffusion coefficient that is well correlated with
both reff and the specific surface area per unit pore
volume (Spor). Two scenarios can explain our findings:
(1) the length-scale defined by t is not equal to reff and is
likely much longer due to the control of pore surface
roughness; (2) the range of diffusion coefficients is large
and likely determined by the relative proportions of the
different minerals (e.g. silica, clays) making up the rock.
In either case, the estimation of reff (and hence
permeability) is inherently uncertain from SIP relaxation
time.
Relaxation phenomena observed in the electrical low-frequency range (approximately 1 mHz-10 kHz) of natural porous media like sandstones is often assumed to be directly related to the dominant (modal) pore throat sizes measured, for instance, with mercury intrusion porosimetry. Attempts to establish a universally valid relationship between pore size and peak Spectral Induced Polarization (SIP) relaxation time have failed, considering sandstones from very different origins and featuring great variations in textural and chemical compositions as well as in geometrical pore space properties. In addition working with characteristic relaxation times determined in Cole-Cole or Debye decomposition fits to build the relationship have not been successful. In particular, samples with narrow pore throats are often characterized by long SIP relaxation times corresponding to long “characteristic length scales” in these media, assuming that the diffusion coefficients along the electrical double layer were constant. Based on these observations, three different types of SIP relaxation can be distinguished. We present a new way of assessing complex pore spaces of very different sandstones in a multi-methodical approach to combine the benefits of mercury intrusion porosimetry, micro-computed tomography, and nuclear magnetic resonance. In this way, we achieve much deeper insight into the pore space due to the different resolutions and sensitivities of the applied methods to both pore constrictions (throats) and wide pores (pore bodies). We experimentally quantify pore aspect ratios and volume distributions within the two pore regions. We clearly observe systematic differences between three SIP relaxation types identified previously and can attribute the SIP peak relaxation times to measured characteristic length scales within our materials. We highlight selected results for a total of nine sandstones. It seems that SIP relaxation behavior depends on the size difference of the narrow pore throats to the wide pore bodies, which increases from SIP Type 1 to Type 3.
We investigate the pore space of rock samples with respect to different petrophysical parameters using various methods, which provide data on pore size distributions, including micro computed tomography (µ-CT), mercury Intrusion porosimetry (MIP), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and spectral-induced polarization (SIP). The resulting cumulative distributions of pore volume as a function of pore size are compared. Considering that the methods differ with
regard to their limits of resolution, a multiple-length-scale characterization of the pore space is proposed, that is based on a combination of the results from all of these methods.
The approach is demonstrated using samples of Bentheimer and Röttbacher sandstone. Additionally, we compare the potential of SIP to provide a pore size distribution with other commonly used methods (MIP, NMR). The limits of Resolution of SIP depend on the usable frequency range (between 0.002 and 100 Hz). The methods with similar Resolution show a similar behavior of the cumulative pore volume distribution in the verlapping pore size range. We assume that µ-CT and NMR provide the pore body size while MIP and SIP characterize the pore throat size. Our study Shows that a good agreement between the pore radius distributions can only be achieved if the curves are adjusted considering the resolution and pore volume in the relevant range of pore radii. The MIP curve with the widest range in Resolution should be used as reference.