Filtern
Dokumenttyp
- Vortrag (17)
Referierte Publikation
- nein (17)
Schlagworte
- Rubber (6)
- EPDM (5)
- FKM (5)
- HNBR (5)
- Ageing (3)
- Degradation (3)
- Compression set (2)
- Activation energy (1)
- Arrhenius (1)
- Compression (1)
Organisationseinheit der BAM
Eingeladener Vortrag
- nein (17) (entfernen)
Aging of elastomer O-rings and PE neutron shielding materials for radioactive waste containers
(2021)
Our institution BAM in Berlin, Germany is concerned with research and testing of materials in the context of safety in chemistry and technology. Our working group is involved in the licensing procedures of casks for radioactive waste. Besides, we’re doing research on aging and lifetime prediction of elastomer O-rings and investigate degradation and thermal expansion of PE neutron shielding materials.
At BAM, which is a federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany, it is our responsibility to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radio-active material. This includes assessment of the elastomeric seals applied in the containers. Besides examining the low-temperature behaviour of elastomeric seals, it is our goal to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. Therefore, we started an ageing programme with selected rubbers (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) which are oven-aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) up to 1.5 years. In order to assess sealability, O-rings are aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates as well as in flanges that allow leakage rate measurements. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings are aged as well. Further methods characterising seal performance are compression stress relaxation (CSR) reflecting the loss of sealing force of a compressed seal over time, and compression set (CS) which represents the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression. Many other properties, e.g. hardness or glass transition temperature, are influenced in opposite directions by crosslinking and chain scission reactions during ageing. By contrast, CSR and CS are influenced additively by each reaction type, as crosslinking leads to the formation of network chains that are in equilibrium with the compressed geometry, and broken chains lose their recovery potential and their contribution to the sealing force. The experimental results indicate that while CSR and CS show considerable degradation effects, the leakage rate stays constant or even decreases until shrinkage and the loss of resilience of the aged sample leads to the formation of a leak path.
BAM is the federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany. One of our tasks is to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive waste. As elastomeric seals are used in the containers as safety-relevant parts, it is our goal to be able to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. For this reason, an accelerated ageing programme with selected rubbers often used for seals (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) was started. Ageing was performed at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) for up to 2 years. For assessing properties related to the sealability, O-rings were aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings were aged as well. The aged materials were characterized with conventional polymer analysis methods such as hardness and tensile tests, but also with more seal-specific methods such as compression stress relaxation (CSR, reflecting the loss of sealing force of a compressed seal over time), and compression set (CS, representing the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression). CS is chosen as the property for lifetime prediction as it is both sensitive to degradation and related to the seal performance. CS data is extrapolated to 60 °C, which yields lifetimes of approximately 5 years for HNBR and 64 years for EPDM for a criterion of 85 % CS respectively, and approx. 40 years for FKM for a criterion of 65 % CS (the highest value measured so far).
At BAM, which is a federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany, it is one of our tasks to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive material. This includes assessment of elastomeric seals applied in the containers. Besides examining the low-temperature behaviour and irradiation effects of elastomeric seals, it is our goal to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. Therefore, we started an accelerated ageing programme with selected rubbers often used in seals (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) which are aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) up to 1.5 years. In order to assess sealability, O-rings are aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates as well as in flanges that allow leakage rate measurements. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings are aged as well. Further methods characterising seal performance are compression stress relaxation (CSR) reflecting the loss of sealing force of a compressed seal over time, and compression set (CS) which represents the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression. In order to understand the underlying ageing mechanisms in each material, the change in material properties is examined using thermal and mechanical analysis. The experimental results indicate that while material properties, CSR and CS show considerable degradation effects, the leakage rate stays constant or even decreases until shrinkage and the loss of resilience of the aged seal leads to the formation of a leakage path. This indicates that static leakage rate, which is the most relevant criterion for seal performance, has only limited sensitivity for the degradation of the seal material.
The ageing of polymers, including elastomers, is an undesirable but inevitable process leading to a limited lifetime of rubber products such as seals. In order to investigate the degradation of material properties of elastomers used as seals, an ageing programme was started with hydrogenated acrylonitrile butadiene rubber (HNBR), ethylene propylene diene rubber (EPDM) and fluorocarbon rubber (FKM) [1-3]. Sheets of 2 mm thickness were aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) for time periods of 1 day up to 1 year. The aged samples were examined using standard analytical methods such as hardness, dynamic-mechanical analysis (DMA), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), mass loss, density and tensile tests. Additionally, DMA equipment was used to investigate relaxation and recovery behaviour which is more sensitive to degradation effects and can help to correctly interpret data from hardness and DMA measurements. The results show e.g. an increase in hardness and glass transition temperature for HNBR and, less pronounced, for EPDM. This confirms ageing mechanisms described in the literature, e.g. dominant crosslinking reactions in HNBR and both chain scissions and crosslinking for EPDM. FKM, which is very heat resistant, exhibits only minor degradation. Where possible, shift factors for time-temperature data sets were determined. The values obtained from different methods are compared and discussed.
BAM is the federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany. One of our tasks is to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive waste. As elastomeric seals are used in the containers as safety-relevant parts, it is our goal to be able to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. For this reason, an accelerated ageing programme with selected rubbers often used for seals (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) was started. Ageing was performed at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) for up to 2 years. For assessing properties related to the sealability, O-rings were aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings were aged as well. The aged materials were characterized with conventional polymer analysis methods such as hardness and tensile tests, but also with more seal-specific methods such as compression stress relaxation (CSR, reflecting the loss of sealing force of a compressed seal over time), and compression set (CS, representing the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression). CS is chosen as the property for lifetime prediction as it is both sensitive to degradation and related to the seal performance. CS data is extrapolated to 60 °C, which yields lifetimes of approximately 5 years for HNBR and 64 years for EPDM for a criterion of 85 % CS respectively, and approx. 40 years for FKM for a criterion of 65 % CS (the highest value measured so far).
Elastomeric seals are used in many containers, including casks for radioactive waste. However, like all polymers, elastomers are prone to aging, which leads to a loss of sealing force and the ability for recovery which can ultimately result in leakage. Therefore it is important to be able to define an end-of-lifetime criterion and to judge the lifetime of elastomeric seals. For this reason, we started an aging program on three kinds of rubbers (HNBR, EPDM, FKM), monitoring the change of properties at four different aging temperatures over extended periods up to five years. The measured data is used for lifetime prediction by applying a suitable model.
At BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing in Germany, it is our responsibility to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive material. This includes investigating the elastomer seals used in the containers. Our current goal is a deeper understanding of ageing processes and examination of service lifetime of compressed O-ring seals with regard to interim storage periods which might be longer than the currently licensed 40 years in Germany. For this reason, we started an ageing programme with selected rubbers (HNBR, EPDM, FKM) for investigating the change of properties during accelerated ageing over long periods of time (up to five years). In contrast to standard procedure which recommends the ageing of standard test pieces, we are ageing O-rings, both uncompressed and compressed [1]. This approach takes into account the specific geometry and stress state of compressed O-rings. Additionally, it allows leakage rate measurements as the most important property of the sealing system under conditions relevant to the application. Other investigated properties and applied methods include hardness, dynamic mechanic analysis (DMA), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), compression stress relaxation (CSR, loss of sealing force over time), compression set (CS, increases if resilience decreases), density and tensile tests. The aim is to correlate leakage rate with common material properties in order to identify a suitable and easily measurable end-of-lifetime criterion for elastomer O-ring seals. Furthermore, the appearance of diffusion-limited oxidation (DLO) effects is investigated, as these effects can lead to heterogeneous ageing and thus distorted bulk properties, resulting in overestimated lifetimes [2].
Extrapolations are made using time-temperature shifts and Arrhenius graphs. For hardness and compression set data the extrapolation leads to different lifetimes. This is because crosslinking and chain scission reactions influence hardness in opposite directions [3], whereas both effects add up to increase compression set [4]. After 0.5 years of ageing, EPDM exhibits only slight hardness increase except at 150 °C, while CS increases substantially at all ageing temperatures. On the other hand, for HNBR, both hardness and CS increase strongly. This confirms that crosslinking is the major degradation mechanism in HNBR [5], while in EPDM both crosslinking and chain scission are apparent [6]. Consequently, hardness is not a suitable measure for extrapolation, as a slight hardness increase can be accompanied by significant chain scission, resulting in severe degradation in other properties, such as CS. NMR, TGA, DMA and density measurements can give further information about the contribution of crosslinking or chain scission in the materials at different ageing stages. The experiments are in progress and results will be presented at the conference.
References
[1] Kömmling A, Waste Management Symposia 2015.
[2] Gillen KT, Polym. Eng. Sci. 1989:29:1.
[3] Snijders EA, Polym. Degrad. Stab. 2005:89:2.
[4] Andrews RD, J. Appl. Phys. 1946:17:5.
[5] Bhattacharjee S, Polym. Degrad. Stab. 1991:31:1.
[6] Bender H, Kautsch. Gummi Kunststoffe 2001:54.
At BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing in Germany, it is our responsibility to audit the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive material. With regard to the requirements on long-term safety of the containers, it is necessary to evaluate the service lifetime of the elastomeric seals used in the containers. With ageing, the elastomers will gradually lose their elasticity and their ability for recovery, which might result in a leakage above the allowed level or in a release of radioactivity during an incident. It is important to know the rate of degradation and which property can be used as an practical and easily measurable end-of-lifetime criterion. For this reason, we devised ageing experiments on different kinds of elastomers, namely FKM, EPDM and HNBR. The former two are actually used in containers for radioactive wastes – either as auxiliary seal in casks containing high activity waste, or as main seal in casks for medium or low activity waste. The latter is an often used seal material that is tested for comparative reasons. In our ageing program, these three materials are aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) in order to extrapolate the data to service temperature using a suitable model. They are examined at logarithmic time intervals of several days up to 5 years. The samples are aged in their undeformed O-ring state as well as compressed between flanges with a deformation corresponding to the actual compression during service. Thus we can compare the ageing between relaxed and stressed sample. Additionally, we are ageing samples in flanges that allow leakage rate measurements. Other measurements include monitoring of the recovery force of the seal and the compression set. Furthermore, the samples are examined by thermal and dynamic-mechanical analysis for detecting changes in the glass transition temperature due to crosslinking or chain scission in the material. Besides, hardness is measured as a practical macroscopic indicator. Until now, we have analyzed samples aged up to 100 days. At the highest ageing temperature of 150 °C, the compressed EPDM has already reached a compression set of 95 %, while HNBR and FKM have reached 80 % and 30 %, respectively. Furthermore, HNBR has reached a Shore D hardness of 85, which is an immense increase after the initial value of 80 Shore A. However, when looking at the cross-section of the sample, it was obvious that only a layer of about 1 mm thickness has become so hard, while the inner part remained rubbery. This shows that there has been intense crosslinking mostly near the surface of the HNBR which forms a kind of oxygen diffusion barrier, inhibiting the thermooxidation of the inner part of sample which can retain elastic properties. In EPDM, the oxygen permeability is much greater, which leads to a more homogeneous degradation across the whole sample and thus resulted in a higher compression set. The low compression set of FKM shows the outstanding high-temperature properties of this material.
At BAM Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing in Germany, it is our responsibility to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive material. This includes the investigation of elastomeric seals applied in the containers. Besides examining the low-temperature behavior of elastomeric seals, it is our goal to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. Furthermore, we deem it necessary to exceed the requirements given in the ageing standard DIN 53508 and take into account diffusion-limited oxidation (DLO) effects [1] and non-Arrhenius behavior [2] when making lifetime predictions. Therefore, we started an ageing programme with selected rubbers (HNBR, FKM and EPDM) which are oven-aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) in order to extrapolate the data to service temperature using different models and check which one is appropriate. Samples are examined at different times up to 5 years. In order to be able to compare between compressed and relaxed rubber, they are aged in two conditions: the undeformed O-ring state as well as compressed between plates with a compression of 25 % corresponding to the actual compression during service. Additionally, we are ageing samples in flanges that allow leakage rate measurements which is the central performance criterion. Analysis methods include hardness as a quick indicator, compression set and compression stress relaxation as measures reflecting the actual properties of a compressed seal. Additionally, we are applying classical polymer analysis methods like dynamic mechanic analysis and thermogravimetric analysis which show changes in the polymeric structure due to chain scission and crosslinking. Furthermore, we are testing the leakage rate of the O-rings in order to correlate the changes in physical properties to the actual performance of the seal.
First results of samples aged up to 100 days show a strong increase in hardness for HNBR, a moderate increase for EPDM and hardly a change for FKM. A similar result is seen in the compression set of samples aged 100 d at 100 °C in compression as HNBR has reached 60 %, EPDM 25 % and FKM 15 % compression set. However, after ageing at 150 °C, EPDM shows a worse performance with 95 % compression set compared to HNBR with only 80 %. This is probably due to DLO effects in HNBR that appear because of the fast ageing and low oxygen permeability in HNBR. This leads to a deficit of oxygen in the center of the sample which is thus protected from ageing and can retain elastic properties. The full paper shall discuss the changes in material properties observed to date and the impact on the performance of elastomeric seals.
BAM is the federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany. One of our tasks is to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive waste. As elastomeric seals are used in the containers as safety-relevant parts, it is our goal to be able to evaluate the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. For this reason, an accelerated ageing programme with selected rubbers often used for seals (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) was started. Ageing was performed at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) for up to 2 years. For assessing properties related to the sealability, O-rings were aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings were aged as well. The aged materials were characterized with conventional polymer analysis methods such as hardness and tensile tests, but also with more seal-specific methods such as compression stress relaxation (CSR, reflecting the loss of sealing force of a compressed seal over time), and compression set (CS, representing the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression). CS is chosen as the property for lifetime prediction as it is both sensitive to degradation and related to the seal performance. CS data is extrapolated to 60 °C, which yields lifetimes of approximately 5 years for HNBR and 64 years for EPDM for a criterion of 85 % CS respectively, and approx. 40 years for FKM for a criterion of 65 % CS (the highest value measured so far).
Unsere Aufgabe im Fachbereich 3.4 der Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und prüfung (BAM) ist die sicherheitstechnische Begutachtung von Transport- und Lagerbehältern für radioaktiven Abfall, die für langfristige Zwischenlagerung ausgelegt sind. Ein Arbeitsschwerpunkt ist die Bewertung der Lebensdauer von Metall- und Elastomerdichtungen in den Behältern im Hinblick auf die Anforderungen für langfristige Behältersicherheit (min. 40 Jahre in Deutschland). Um die Eigenschaftsänderungen der Elastomerdichtungen während einer beschleunigten Alterung über lange Zeiträume (bis zu fünf Jahre) untersuchen zu können, wurde ein Alterungsprogramm an ausgewählten Elastomeren (HNBR, EPDM, FKM) begonnen.
Im Gegensatz zu Normalterungsverfahren altern wir keine Normteile, sondern O-Ringe im unverpressten sowie verpressten Zustand. Diese Vorgehensweise ermöglicht die Bewertung des Einflusses der Verpressung auf die Alterung sowie die Untersuchung des Bauteilversagens mittels Leckageratenmessungen unter anwendungsnahen Bedingungen. Weitere Charakterisierungsmethoden sind Härtemessung, dynamisch-mechanische Analyse (DMA), Thermogravimetrie (TGA), Druckspannungsrelaxation, Druckverformungsrest (DVR), Dichtebestimmung und Zugversuch. Das Ziel ist, die Leckagerate mit anderen Eigenschaften bzw. Methoden zu korrelieren, um so ein aussagekräftiges und leichter zu bestimmendes Lebensdauerkriterium für elastomere O-Ringe abzuleiten.
Während der Alterung können in Abhängigkeit von Material sowie Alterungsdauer und –temperatur Inhomogenitäten aufgrund von diffusionsbegrenzter Oxidation auftreten, durch die sich unterschiedliche Eigenschaften an der Oberfläche und im Volumen der Dichtung ergeben, was zu falschen Lebensdauerabschätzungen führen kann. Mittels Mikrohärtemessung über den Querschnitt werden diese Effekte charakterisiert und bei der Extrapolation mittels Zeit-Temperatur-Verschiebung und Arrheniusgraph berücksichtigt. Bisher liegen Daten von bis zu einem Jahr bei vier verschiedenen Temperaturen (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C und 150 °C) gealterten Proben vor. Nach 100 Tagen bei 150 °C weisen HNBR und EPDM schon einen DVR von über 80 % auf, aber noch keinen signifikanten Anstieg der Leckagerate. Diese sinkt zunächst während der Alterung, da die Permeabilität aufgrund von Vernetzungsreaktionen sinkt. Bei HNBR ist dies aufgrund der dominanteren Vernetzungsreaktionen während der Alterung noch stärker ausgeprägt als bei EPDM.
Elastomeric O-ring seals are used in a wide range of applications due to their excellent elasticity. However, like all polymers, elastomers degrade under the influence of e.g. time, temperature, oxygen, radiation and mechanical stress. Especially in applications where a replacement of seals after a certain time is hard or almost impossible, it is important to know the seal lifetime. Therefore, an extensive ageing programme with elastomers made of EPDM, HNBR and other materials was started with the aim of determining suitable methods for accelerated ageing and lifetime prediction.
In order to determine the lifetime of polymeric parts, the time-temperature superposition principle is commonly used to shift property changes obtained by accelerated ageing at higher temperatures to lower temperatures. If the shift factors yield a straight line in an Arrhenius diagram, a corresponding activation energy can be determined. However, we have found that the shift factors and thus the predicted lifetime depends on the test method that yielded the shifted data. For example, the shift factor between 125 °C and 150 °C ageing temperature was roughly the same (5/5/4.5 respectively) for hardness, density and maximum of loss factor tan measured on HNBR, but different for elongation at break (8) and compression set (2.2, excluding DLO-affected data). A possible explanation might be that while the different oxidation reactions proceed with a fixed activation energy, they have differing impact on the measured properties. For example, hardness is lowered by chain scission reactions, and increases by crosslinking reactions during ageing. As usually both chain scission and crosslinking reactions occur during ageing, the measured hardness increase reflects only the net effect of both reaction types. On the other hand, compression set is influenced additively by both reaction types: chain scission leads to an increase of the remaining deformation, as broken chains lose their recovery potential, and crosslinking reactions during ageing fix the compressed geometry, which also leads to less recovery. Thus, compression set reflects the total number of changes in the network and shows degradation effects much faster, which results in lower shift factors and lower activation energy. This phenomenon was observed for EPDM as well.
In order to verify our hypotheses and to gain further insights, temperature-dependent oxygen consumption measurements are currently being performed and results will be presented at the conference. The shift factors and activation energy determined by oxygen consumption measurements are expected to be close to the values for compression set.
At BAM, which is a federal institute for materials research and testing in Germany, it is one of our tasks to evaluate the safety of casks designed for transport and/or storage of radioactive material. This includes assessment of elastomeric seals applied in the casks. One of the aims is to identify a suitable method for estimating the service lifetime of the seals with regard to the requirements for long-term safety (40 years and more) of the containers. Therefore, we started an accelerated ageing programme with selected rubbers often used for seals (HNBR, EPDM and FKM) which are aged at four different temperatures (75 °C, 100 °C, 125 °C and 150 °C) for up to five years. In order to assess sealability, O-rings were aged in compression by 25 % (corresponding to the compression during service) between plates as well as in flanges that allow leakage rate measurements. For comparison, uncompressed O-rings were aged as well. In order to understand the underlying ageing mechanisms in each material, material properties such as hardness, density and tensile properties were examined. Additionally, compression set (CS), which represents the recovery behaviour of a seal after release from compression, is measured. For obtaining results closely related to practical conditions, O-rings with a full-scale cord diameter of 10 mm were aged. However, this set-up can lead to heterogeneous ageing caused by diffusion-limited oxidation (DLO) effects especially for HNBR, resulting in distorted bulk properties such as compression set. However, if DLO-affected data is excluded, extrapolations of CS data are possible using time-temperature shifts.
For selecting an appropriate end-of-lifetime criterion, leakage rate measurements were performed, since leakage rate is the only characteristic directly correlated to the performance of the sealing system. A significant increase in leakage rate was considered as the end of the lifetime. However, the O-rings remained leak tight under static conditions even though material properties had already degraded strongly. For this reason, a modified, more demanding leakage test involving a fast small decompression of the seal was developed that allowed determining a more conservative end-of-lifetime criterion with a safety margin for EPDM seals. FKM, which is a very heat and oxidation resistant material, exhibited only little degradation, even though it had the smallest activation energy.
Safety of long term containment and storage of radioactive waste is an essential issue, which is increasingly gaining international attention. Extending interim storage beyond initial license periods is one of the major challenges worldwide.
BAM has been involved in all kinds of radioactive waste container safety evaluation for storage and transportation including their long term performance from the very beginning. Today, all work related to the safe management of radioactive waste is linked by the activity field “Nuclear Waste Management” within the Focus Area “Energy” at BAM and in conjunction with a research strategy and agenda. Most recently, the working group “Long Term Safety of Container Systems and Components” was established to launch and perform research projects related to safety issues concerning the extended interim storage of radioactive waste.
For example, within our project LaMEP, we investigate ageing effects of metal and elastomer seals as well as polymeric neutron shielding materials, which are container components that fulfil major safety functions. The results of the experiments help to understand the long term behaviour of these components. Likewise, our project BRUZL started at BAM in 2018 with the aim of developing a fracture mechanics approach to understand and describe a potential brittle failure mechanism of fuel cladding during long-term interim storage. BAM also contributes to the GRS project “Development of methods and models and international exchange for safety evaluation in the frame of interim storage of radioactive waste”. Additionally, BAM is involved in several international research programmes dealing with extended interim storage, such as the European Joint Programme on Radioactive Waste Management (EURAD), the Extended Storage Collaboration Program (ESCP) and IAEA Coordinated Research Projects.
The present contribution provides a comprehensive overview of BAM research activities contributing to national and international gap analyses and to filling knowledge gaps regarding the safe long term management of radioactive waste.