Filtern
Erscheinungsjahr
- 2019 (221) (entfernen)
Dokumenttyp
- Vortrag (221)
Sprache
- Englisch (132)
- Deutsch (85)
- Mehrsprachig (3)
- Russisch (1)
Referierte Publikation
- nein (221) (entfernen)
Schlagworte
- Additive Manufacturing (24)
- Additive Fertigung (18)
- Additive manufacturing (14)
- NDT (12)
- Thermografie (12)
- Concrete (11)
- Ultraschall (10)
- Ultrasound (10)
- Zerstörungsfreie Prüfung (10)
- Magnetocaloric (8)
Organisationseinheit der BAM
- 8 Zerstörungsfreie Prüfung (221) (entfernen)
Eingeladener Vortrag
- nein (221) (entfernen)
Non-destructive testing for surface crack detection and head check depth quantification at the gauge cor-ner of railway tracks can be achieved using eddy current methods. With the extension of the tested zone to the running surface, rail defect signal types other than head checks can be measured. Due to their most-ly irregular shape, a quantitation based on a calibration against regular test cracks of varying depth may not be linear. Estimates of the expected influence of more complex crack patterns may be obtained by a finite element simulation of sufficiently simple limiting cases, like two displaced or intersecting cracks or a simply branched or flexed crack. As a first step, a 3D finite element model of the HC10 eddy current probe distributed by Prüftechnik Linke und Rühe (PLR), Germany was built and verified against meas-ured results from an (easily fabricated) reference block with isolated long cracks.
Bei der mechanisierten Prüfung von verlegten Eisenbahnschienen mit Schienenprüfzügen werden große Prüfdatenmengen mit einer komplexen Prüfkopfanordnung in kurzer Zeit bei hohen Prüfgeschwindigkeiten aufgenommen. Der Typ und der Zustand des Gleises kann während der Prüfung in schnellem Wechsel streckenabhängig variieren, z.B. unterschiedliche Schienentypen oder Abnutzung sowie beim Durchfahren von Weichenstraßen. Der logistische Aufwand diese Prüfung insgesamt durchzuführen ist dabei sehr hoch und eine Wiederholung der Prüfung in einem kurzen Zeitintervall nicht möglich.
Es werden während der Prüfdatenaufnahme bereits Datenreduktionsverfahren, Rekonstruktionsverfahren und Online-Parametervariationen eingesetzt, um die Ergebnisdaten zum einen in Ihrer Menge zu begrenzen zum anderen auf die lokalen Geometrie- und Zustandsänderungen des Prüfobjektes Schiene zu reagieren.
Im Regelwerk EN 16729-1 „Zerstörungsfreie Prüfung an Schienen im Gleis -Teil 1: Anforderungen an Ultraschallprüfungen und Bewertungsgrundlagen“ werden Bezugsreflektoren definiert, um die Leistung automatisierter Ultraschallsysteme für die Schienenprüfung zu verifizieren.
Um die Einflüsse der komplexen Randbedingungen der mechanisierten Schienenprüfung auf das Prüfergebnis evaluieren zu können, wurde ein Softwarewerkzeug erarbeitet, mit dem eine Prüffahrt auf einer Schiene simuliert werden kann. Basierend auf der Datenaufnahme mit dem Glassy-Rail-Diagramm können alle relevanten Prüfparameter und Artefakte in Schienen sowie Störeinflüsse bei der Simulation berücksichtigt werden.
For more than 60 years ultrasonic rail inspection is used as non-destructive testing method to ensure the safe operation of rail tracks. Constantly increasing traffic density and heavy loads have been the motor for the development of new test equipment from handheld devices to rail inspection trains. (Krull 2003)Up to the present most of the system solutions feature conventional ultrasonic transducers housed in wheel-type and slide-type probes. Different tasks have to be carried out during an in-service inspection for flaws in the rail head, rail web and rail foot as well as rolling contact fatigue (Heckel 2018). The more tasks the inspection system has to perform, the more probes are needed. Compared against standard ultrasonic testing methods the application of array probes offers advantages and flexibility by the electronic steering possibilities to control the transmitted and received sound fields. This allows to increase functionality by software while decreasing the number of probes needed in hardware in parallel. One drawback in application of phased array probes is that the repetition frequency of the subsequent measurements will be reduced by the number of virtual probe functions each phased array probe has to perform. This may limit the range of use for phased array probes in high speed applications. To overcome these limits special designs for array probes and signal processing are necessary.
Damage Quantification in Aluminium-CFRP Composite Structures using Guided Wave Wavenumber Mapping
(2019)
The use of composite materials is associated not only with the advantages of weight reduction and improved structural performance but also with the risk of barely visible impacts or manufacturing damages. One of the promising techniques for the detection and characterisation of such damages is based on ultrasonic guided wave propagation and analysis. However, the multimodal nature and dispersive behaviour of these waves make their analysis difficult. Various signal processing techniques have been proposed for easier interpretation of guided wave signals and extraction of the necessary information about the damage. One of them is the wavenumber mapping which consists of creating a cartography of the wavenumber of a propagating mode over an inspected area, using a dense wavefield acquisition measured for example with a scanning laser Doppler vibrometer. This technique allows both the quantification of the in-plane size and the depth of damage, for example, impact-induced delamination in composite laminates.
In this contribution, wavenumber mapping is applied to a delaminated aluminium-CFRP composite structure which corresponds to composite-overwrapped pressure vessels used for storing gases in aerospace and automotive industries. The analysis of experimental data obtained from measurements of guided waves propagating in an aluminium-CFRP composite plate with impact-induced damage is performed. The output of the imaging is a three-dimensional representation of the delamination induced by the impact. Good agreement between conventional ultrasonic testing and guided wave damage mapping can be found.
Aluminum alloys are extensively used in the automotive industry. Particularly, squeeze casting production of Al-Si alloys is employed in the conception of metal matrix composites (MMC) for combustion engines. Such materials are of a high interest since they allow combining improved mechanical properties and reduced weight and hence improve efficiency. We investigate two types of MMCs, which can be potentially used for production of combustion engine pistons: 1) a near-eutectic cast AlSi12CuMgNi alloy reinforced with 15%vol. Al2O3 random planar oriented short fibers and 2) the same alloy reinforced with 7%vol. Al2O3 random planar oriented short fibers + 15%vol. SiC particles.
Complex 3D microstructure of the samples in as-cast condition, consisting of four and five phases (Al matrix, eutectic Si, intermetallics, Al2O3 fibers and SiC particles) was investigated by synchrotron computed tomography (CT). Advanced methods based on machine learning were applied for segmentation of all phases. This allowed extracting quantitative information such as volume fraction, shape and interconnectivity of every phase.
In-situ compression tests during neutron diffraction experiments were used to track the load transfer among phases, while CT on pre-strained samples to monitor and quantify damage. A micromechanical model was developed to simulate the evolution of the internal stress of each phase during uniaxial compression. We showed that in composites with the Al2O3 fiber mat plane perpendicular to the load axis the Al-alloy matrix presents a large hydrostatic stress component, i.e. undergoes compression also in the direction transverse to the external load. This feature holds with and without the addition of SiC ceramic reinforcement and is absent in the case when the Al2O3 fiber mat plane is parallel to the load axis. We show, that the intermetallics play a decisive role at very high loads, when all other reinforcement phases suffer (extensive) damage. The addition of SiC particles does alleviate the load on the Al2O3 fibers, on the eutectic Si, and on the intermetallic phases in both cases of parallel and orthogonal (to the load axis) Al2O3 fiber orientation. Apart from the beneficial addition of ceramic reinforcement, the presence of intermetallic phase and eutectic silicon, forming an interconnected network even at high loads, when single particles break, confers peculiar properties to these multi-phase composites.
Die Varroose gilt weltweit als eine der bedeutendsten Erkrankungen der westlichen Honigbiene, Apis mellifera. Verursacht wird sie durch den Ektoparasiten Varroa destructor, der durch Saugen der Hämolymphe und Virenübertragung sowohl die Bienenbrut als auch die adulten Individuen schädigt.
Ohne imkerliche Unterstützung gehen betroffene Bienenvölker in der Regel innerhalb von drei Jahren ein. Als bewährte, häufige Behandlung wird flächendeckend 60%ige Ameisensäure (AS) - im Bienenstock appliziert über verschiedene Verdampfungssysteme - eingesetzt. Sie wirkt als einziger zugelassener Stoff gegen die Varroamilbe auch in die verdeckelte Brut hinein und birgt kein Risiko der Resistenzentwicklung.
Allerdings ist das therapeutische Fenster, der Bereich zwischen Milbenabtötung und Bienenschädigung, relativ schmal und die tatsächliche AS-Konzentration im Bienenstock stark abhängig von äußeren Einflussfaktoren, wie Temperatur, Luftfeuchte oder Applikationsart.
Eine Bestimmung der exakten AS-Konzentration im Bienenstock ist also notwendig, um einerseits das Wirkungsoptimum zu bestimmen und andererseits bei Übersteigen der Maximalkonzentrationen mit Folge-Schädigung der Bienen, ein rechtzeitiges Eingreifen der Imker zu ermöglichen.
Reinforced concrete (RC) is used as structural material in most diverse civil engineering applications. For the variability of its physical properties it is still an engineering challenge to meet all necessary requirements for the prediction of dynamic effects under impact loading. In this paper, investigations are shown within the scope of quantifying and evaluating the damage caused by an impact. The experimental investigations are performed in the field of low- and medium-velocity impact. The chosen flat nose shape results in small penetrations on the top side and scabbing on the bottom side. The plate is scanned with an adapted planar tomographic examination after the impact, and the damage is analysed, afterwards. Cracks and spalling are made visible with a reconstruction. The numerical model validated on the tomographic results justifies the application for further predictions of the damage description.
The application of phased arrays in either linear or matrix arrangement in combination with signal processing opens the door for the mechanized inspection of different thin wall materials itself as well as their joining methods.
Modern lightweight components are typically manufactured by a composition of different types of e.g. steels, metals, fiber reinforced plastics and glass. Dependent on the material combinations e.g. welding, brazing, bonding, cladding or coating may be applied during the manufacturing process to join different semi-finished products to form the component.
The resulting complex material composition and different damage mechanisms pose new challenges to non-destructive testing with ultrasound due to the different material properties and the overall arrangement of the materials employed.
The sound field variation capabilities of array probes may be helpful to overcome some of these challenges if adapted to the specific inspection task.
Examples for the non-destructive mechanized phased array inspection of different types of materials and joining methods will be presented.
Despite of the significant advances in AM process optimization there is still a lack of experimental results and understanding regarding the mechanical behavior and microstructural evolution of AMparts, especially in loading conditions typical for safety-relevant applications e.g. in the aerospace or power engineering. Within the scope of the presented investigations, a characterization of the fatigue behavior of additively manufactured Ti-6Al-4V in the low cycle fatigue regime was carried out in the range of 0.3 to 1.0 % strain amplitude at room temperature, 250°C and 400°C. The Ti-6Al-4V specimens are machined out of lean cylindrical rods, which were fabricated using powder laser metal deposition (LMD) with an improved build-up strategy. The improved strategy incorporates variable track overlap ratios to achieve a constant growth in the shell and core area. The low-cycle-fatigue behavior is described based on cyclic deformation curves and strain-based fatigue life curves. The lifetimes are fitted based on the Manson-Coffin-Basquin relationship. A characterization of the microstructure and the Lack-of-Fusion (LoF)-defect-structure in the as-built state is performed using optical light microscopy and high-resolution computed tomography (CT) respectively. The failure mechanism under loading is described in terms of LoF-defects-evolution and crack growth mechanism based on an interrupted LCF test with selected test parameters. After failure, scanning electron microscopy, digital and optical light microscopy and CT are used to describe the failure mechanisms both in the longitudinal direction and in the cross section of the specimens. The fatigue lives obtained are comparable with results from previous related studies and are shorter than those of traditionally manufactured (wrought) Ti-6Al-4V. In this study new experimental data and understanding of the mechanical behavior under application-relevant loading conditions (high temperature, cyclic plasticity) is gained. Furthermore, a better understanding of the role of LoFdefects and AM-typical microstructural features on the failure mechanism of LMD Ti-6Al-4V is achieved.
An essential task in many industries, e.g. food, petrol or chemical industry, is the precise and accurate characterization of liquids. Therefore, the development of innovative in-line sensors is of great interest. New concepts based on periodic structures, so-called phononic crystals (PnCs), are an interesting idea for the design of innovative sensors.
A PnC-based sensor can be designed by introducing a resonance inside a bandgap, a frequency region where no wave propagation is allowed. High-Q measurement systems using PnCs are already reported in the literature. However, existing designs cannot be implemented into a piping system directly, but need special fittings, openings or by-passes to be in contact with the liquid.
To circumvent this issue, we develop a new sensor based on PnCs, which can be directly implemented as part of the piping system. For this purpose, we use a PnC consisting of hollow cylinders with a periodic change of the outer diameter.
A bandgap could be found for the described geometry without fluid in simulation and measurement. However, simulations show, that a bandgap for fluid-filled cylinders can only be obtained for quasi-longitudinal modes. Hence, we propose a mode selective excitation for the sensor.
Residual stresses count among the most limiting factors in the application of additively manufactured materials in safety relevant components subject to cyclic loading. The source of such stresses is inherent in the manufacturing Laser Beam Melted (LBM) process due to rapid cooling and solidification and their distribution in the specimen or component is not homogeneous, but it is usually characterized by high gradients. Moreover, the magnitude of the residual stress field depends very much on the orientation, being higher in the build direction.
Many works in the literature advise to carry out a post-LBM treatment to relieve residual stresses, even though particular attention should be paid in choosing the parameters for the thermal treatment in order to avoid microstructural/phase transformations, which would affect greatly the mechanical properties of the material.
Particularly in the case of the austenitic stainless steel 316L, it has been shown that annealing at high temperatures (above 900°C), besides relieving the residual stresses, may cause recrystallization, grain growth and even phase transformation. In contrast, if a too low annealing temperature is chosen in order to preserve the microstructure, the residual stresses cannot be completely relieved.
This work aims to address the effect of residual stresses on short and long crack propagation for SEN(B) specimens made of 316L fabricated by LBM, in which notches have been machined by electro-discharge machining (EDM) on the mid-plane, perpendicular to the build direction. The specimens underwent different annealing treatments in inert atmosphere, in which the maximum temperature has been varied up to 900°C. The amount of residual stresses and their distribution has been measured by X-ray and neutron diffraction and the specimens have been subject to cyclic loading in a resonant testing machine. The tests show a massive influence of the residual stresses in the build direction on the resistance to fatigue crack propagation of additively manufactured 316L. Finally, a comparison with conventionally manufactured 316L is presented.
The present study deals with the experimental characterization of short crack propagation in SLM (selective-laser-melting) manufactured stainless steel. More specifically, the determination of cyclic R-curves is discussed. This describes the dependency of the crack propagation threshold on crack growth during the short crack propagation stage. For metals, the threshold, starting at a material-intrinsic value, increases until it reaches a value independent of the crack length due to crack closure phenomena which build up at that stage. The cyclic R-curve, when used in the frame of a cyclic R curve analysis, characterizes the resistance of a material to fatigue crack growth and the ability to arrest a physically short crack. Thus, it is the link between classical fatigue and fracture mechanics. In the high-cycle-fatigue range, the short crack propagation stage dominates the overall lifetime, i.e., the number of cycles until failure. Below the fatigue limit crack arrest of hitherto propagable micro-cracks will occur. The effort for the experimental characterization of the short fatigue crack propagation behavior and the cyclic R-curve is very high compared to experiments on long crack propagation. A very exact measurement of crack extension is required, since small increments need to be depicted. Pre-cracking must leave a closure free initial crack, since closure must be build up only by the cyclic R-curve. The closure-free status is achieved by compression pre-cracking. The aim of the present study is an insight into the influence of an AM process on the short crack propagation threshold. Cyclic R-curves are experimentally determined at different load-ratios for 316L austenitic steel specimens produced by SLM and conventional manufacturing. Residual stresses are measured in the crack plane and their influence on the cyclic R-curve is discussed.
Die Verwendung von Verbundwerkstoffen ist nicht nur mit den Vorteilen einer Gewichtsreduzierung und einer verbesserten strukturellen Leistung verbunden, sondern auch mit der Gefahr von kaum sichtbaren Impakt- oder Herstellungsschäden. Eine der vielversprechenden Methoden zur Erkennung und Charakterisierung solcher Schäden basiert auf der Ausbreitung und Analyse geführter Ultraschallwellen. Der multimodale und dispersive Charakter dieser Wellen erschweren jedoch die Analyse. Verschiedene Signalverarbeitungsmethoden wurden vorgeschlagen, um die Interpretation von Signalen und die Extraktion der notwendigen Informationen über den Schaden zu erleichtern. Eine davon ist die Erstellung einer Wellenzahlkarte. Die Wellenzahlkarte erlaubt es jeden Punkt in einer hochaufgelöste Wellenfeldaufnahme eine Wellenzahl zuzuordnen. Diese Methode ermöglicht sowohl die Quantifizierung der Größe als auch der Tiefe des Schadens.
In diesem Beitrag wird diese Bildgebungsmethode auf delaminierte Aluminium-CFK-Verbundstrukturen angewendet. Solche Strukturen entsprechen den umwickelten Druckbehältern, die zur Speicherung von Gasen in der Luft- und Raumfahrt sowie in der Automobilindustrie verwendet werden. Zunächst werden die numerischen Untersuchungen zur einfachen Delamination in unterschiedlicher Tiefe vorgestellt. Als nächstes wird die Analyse von experimentellen Ergebnissen von einer geschädigten Aluminium-CFK-Platte präsentiert. Das Ergebnis der Bildgebung ist eine dreidimensionale Darstellung, die sowohl die Größe als auch die Tiefe des Impakt-Schadens liefert.
Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) is one of the most promising additive manufacturing (AM) technologies for the production of complex metallic real part components. Due to the multitude of factors influencing process conditions and part quality and due to the layer-wise characteristic of the process, monitoring of process signatures seems to be mandatory in case of the production of safety critical components. Here, the iterative process nature enables unique access for in-situ monitoring during part manufacture. In this talk, the successful test of the synchronous use of a high-frequency infrared camera and a camera for long time exposure, working in the visible spectrum (VIS) and equipped with a near infrared filter (NIR), will be introduced as a machine manufacturer independent thermal detection monitoring set-up. Thereby, the synchronous use of an infrared camera and a VIS NIR camera combines the advantages of high framerate and high spatial resolution. The manufacture of a 316L stainless steel specimen, containing purposely seeded defects and volumes with forced changes of energy inputs, was monitored during the build. The measured thermal responses are analysed and compared with a defect mapping obtained by micro X-ray computed tomography (CT).
The first results regarding methods for data analysis, derived correlations between measured signals and detected defects as well as sources of possible data misinterpretation are presented in this talk.
Residual stresses in Laser Beam Melting (LBM) – Critical Review and outlook of activities at BAM
(2019)
Additive manufacturing (AM) technologies have experienced an exceedingly rapid growth, which is coupled with the knowledge about the resulting material properties and performance. In particular, residual stress (RS) was soon recognized as an important issue in AM parts, such that parts are usually subjected to a post build-heat-treated. Significant effort has been spent on simulations of RS in AM, especially using finite element methods. As a consequence, the experimental determination of RS has thereby become increasingly important as a validation tool for simulations, as well as a method for assessing the influence of process parameters. In particular, diffraction methods, which are fundamentally non-destructive, offer enormous possibilities to gain knowledge on the residual stress state in real components, since synchrotron radiation and neutrons can penetrate even heavy metals up to several millimeters or centimeters, respectively. Indeed, significant progress has been achieved, in the understanding of the origins of the RS fields as a function of process parameters, as well as their stability under thermal and/or mechanical exposure.
In this paper, a few success stories will be outlined. It will be shown how the determination of RS in metallic parts (with the focus on those produced by laser powder bed fusion) has even revealed that process parameters that were previously considered unimportant (e.g. the position and orientation on the base plate) play a major role in the onset of residual stress accumulation.
However, while RS characterization is starting to be considered in the component design, deposition strategy (e.g. build plate temperature), and even in the definition of the relevant metric to assess the quality of a part, much is still to be investigates about the hypotheses underlying its experimental determination. Therefore, some aspects to be aware of, or even those which to date are unclear, will also be discussed. These include the determination of the stress-free reference and of the principal axes of stress. All of these aspects will lead towards a comprehensive understanding of the process-structure-performance relationships in AM materials and parts.
Issues that prevent Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) based on Guided Waves (GW) from being a part of today’s monitoring solutions in industry are not all obvious to the scientific community. To uncover and overcome these issues, scientists working on SHM and GW problems joined in an expert committee under the patronage of the German Society for Non-Destructive Testing. An initiated online survey among more than 700 experts and users reveals the hurdles hindering the practical application of GWbased SHM. Firstly, methods for proof of reliability of SHM approaches are missing.
Secondly, detailed understanding of phenomenological described wave-damage interactions is needed. Additionally, there are significant unsolved implementation issues and unsolved problems of signal processing including handling of environmental influences.
To enable substantial proof of reliability without unaffordable experimental effort also efficient simulation tools including realistic damage interaction are needed, enabling the joint use of experimental and simulated data to predict the capabilities of the Monitoring system. Considering these issues, the committee focusses on simulation, signal processing, as well as probability of detection and standardization. In the presented work, recent activities of the expert committee starting with survey results are summarized. An open access data basis of life-like measurements is presented to allow testing and comparison of signal processing and simulation algorithms. Finally, a strategy for efficient proof of reliability increasing the acceptance of SHM in industry and for successful Integration of SHM into real-world engineering structures is proposed.
3D images such as those produces by X-ray tomography can provide a wealth of information on the internal structure of materials, but quantification of specific geometrical or topological characteristics linked to some bulk physical property is far from being straightforward. This study focuses on methods to quantify the differences in physical properties as a function of direction, i.e. their anisotropy, and how it can be linked to measures of anisotropy of the internal structure of the material. The auto-correlation function gives a similarity measure in the volume as a function of distance and direction. This is a cross-correlation of the image with itself fast to compute and relatively insensitive to noise. It is why we focus on this method to compare with the physical property of our DPF material. Diesel Particulate Filter (DPF) materials are porous ceramics that; a) can be used at very high temperatures; b) have very good thermal shock resistance; c) are inert; d) can be manufactured with tailored porosity. Their usual way of production consists of the extrusion of a slurry into the desired filter shape, with successive ceramming at high temperature. This process causes anisotropy at both microscopic and macroscopic levels.
Der Beitrag beschreibt den Aufbau und die Entwicklung einer Heißluftquelle als Wärmequelle für die aktive Thermografie. Als Ausgangspunkt wird zunächst die Quellenlage betrachtet. In der Literatur über Thermografie spielt Heißluft als Wärmequelle nur in weniger als 0,1% eine Rolle, die Ursache dafür ist nicht bekannt. Es wird vermutet, dass dieser Erwärmungsmethode unterstellt wird, sie hätte Nachteile bezüglich Homogenität der Erwärmung sowie Leistungseintrag. In einer der raren Publikationen über einen Verfahrensvergleich schnitt die Heißluft-Thermografie jedoch nicht schlechter als die Vergleichsverfahren mit optischer Anregung ab, bei gleichzeitig deutlichem Zeitgewinn und geringerem technischen Aufwand.
Danach wird der fertige Versuchsaufbau mit seinen wesentlichen Komponenten dargestellt. Der Einfluss der Geometrie der Luftaustrittsdüse auf die erreichbare Wärmeverteilung an einem flachen Blech wurde an mehreren Düsen untersucht. Hierbei erwies sich eine langgestreckte Umlenkdüse mit einer Strahlumlenkung von etwa 20° als optimal zur Erzeugung einer möglichst homogenen Erwärmung.
Ein weiterer zu optimierender Parameter war die erreichbare Schaltdynamik des Heißgasstromes. Beim schnellen Schalten großer Volumenströme treten Druckstöße mit entsprechenden Temperaturänderungen auf. Hinzu kommt, dass der verwendete MFC (mass flow controller) bei großen Volumenströmen zum Einschwingen bei Schaltprozessen neigt.
Daher enthält der Aufbau einen offenen Bypass zur Stabilisierung des Volumenstroms. Mit dem so realisierten Messplatz wurde die Reproduzierbarkeit der erzielten Erwärmung durch mehrfache Wiederholungsmessungen über einen längeren Zeitraum untersucht. Hierzu wurde ein auch zu Validierungszwecken genutzter PVC-Block mit 13 mm Dicke jeweils für 60 s erwärmt und die Oberflächentemperatur des PVC-Blocks mit einer IR-Kamera aufgezeichnet. Bei jeweiligem Neuaufbau ohne Justierhilfe ergab sich eine Reproduzierbarkeit von etwa 22% bei 5 Versuchen. Unter Nutzung einer Justierhilfe (Schablone für Abstand in der Kamerasoftware) ließ sich die Reproduzierbarkeit auf 5% bei 7 Versuchen reduzieren.
Ein weiterer zu klärender Punkt war der erzielbare Wärmeeintrag im Vergleich zu einer Anregung mit Blitzlampen. Hierzu wurde eine Messung mit 60 s Heißluftheizung direkt mit einer Evaluierungsmessung mit Blitzlampen am gleichen PVC-Probekörper mit 4 FBB an der Rückseite verglichen. Die Inhomogenität der Erwärmung wurde durch eine Phasenauswertung unterdrückt. Die Phasenauswertung gestattete den Nachweis aller 4 FBB, wobei das Signal zu Rausch-Verhältnis bei der Heißlufterwärmung deutlich besser war. Der direkte Vergleich der Temperaturkurven zeigt, dass bei 60 s Heizlufterwärmung ca. 4,5 mal mehr Energie als bei der Blitzanregung vom Probekörper absorbiert wurde. Hieraus lässt sich die eingekoppelte Heizleistung mit 100 mW/cm² abschätzen. Das entspricht in etwa dem Niveau, wie es auch mit bewegten Halogenstrahlern, bewegten IR-Strahlern oder der Sonne erreicht wird.
Diese Ergebnisse belegen, dass eventuell vorhandene Vorbehalte gegenüber einer Heißluft als Wärmequelle für die aktive Thermografie zumindest für thermisch langsame Materialien wie Kunststoffe oder mineralische Baustoffe unbegründet sind. Die Einsatzgrenzen bei der Untersuchung thermisch schnellerer Materialien wie Metalle steht noch aus, hier ist mit Abstrichen zu rechnen. Auf der anderen Seite lässt eine mögliche Düsenoptimierung noch deutliche Verbesserungen erwarten.