TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Drobne, D. A1 - Novak, S. A1 - Kranjc, E. A1 - Bohmer, N. A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Data quality for Nanorisk Governance N2 - Nanomaterials bring various benefits and have become a part of our daily lives. However, the risks emerging from nanotechnology need to be minimized and controlled at the regulatory level and therefore, there is a need for nanorisk governance. One of the prerequisites for successful nanorisk governance is the availability of high-quality data on nanomaterials and their impact with the human body and the environment. In recent decades, a countless number of publications and studies on nanomaterials and their properties have been produced due to the fast development of nanotechnology. Despite such a vast amount of data and information, there are certain knowledge gaps hindering an efficient nanorisk governance process. Knowing the state of the available data and information is an important requirement for any decision maker in dealing with risks. In the specific case of nanotechnology, where most of the risks are complex, ambiguous, and uncertain in nature, it is essential to obtain complete data and metadata, to fill knowledge gaps, and to transform the available knowledge into functional knowledge. This can become possible using a novel approach developed within the NANORIGO project (Grant agreement No. 814530) – the Knowledge Readiness Level (KaRL). In analogy to NASA’s Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs), we define KaRLs as a categorization system of data, information, and knowledge which enables transformation of data and information into functional knowledge for nanorisk governance. Our approach goes beyond the technical curation of data and metadata and involves quality and completeness filters, regulatory compliance requirements, nanorisk-related tools, and most importantly, human input (inclusion of all stakeholder groups). With the KaRL approach we also address key issues in nanotechnology such as societal and ethical concerns, circular economies and sustainability, the Green Deal, and the traceability of data, knowledge, and decisions. The KaRL approach could be used for nanorisk governance by a nanorisk governance council (NRGC), which is currently under development by three EU projects (NANORIGO, GOV4NANO, and RISKGONE). T2 - Nanosafety Training School: From Basic Science To Risk Governance CY - Online meeting DA - 20.06.2021 KW - Data KW - Knowledge KW - Risk Governance KW - Knowledge Readiness Level PY - 2021 UR - https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:kobv:b43-529255 AN - OPUS4-52925 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Drobne, D. A1 - Novak, S. A1 - Kranjc, E. A1 - Bohmer, N. A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Knowledge Readiness for Nanorisk Governance N2 - Nanomaterials bring various benefits and have become a part of our daily lives. However, the risks emerging from nanotechnology need to be minimized and controlled at the regulatory level and therefore, there is a need for nanorisk governance. One of the prerequisites for successful nanorisk governance is the availability of high-quality data on nanomaterials and their impact with the human body and the environment. In recent decades, a countless number of publications and studies on nanomaterials and their properties have been produced due to the fast development of nanotechnology. Despite such a vast amount of data and information, there are certain knowledge gaps hindering an efficient nanorisk governance process. Knowing the state of the available data and information is an important requirement for any decision maker in dealing with risks. In the specific case of nanotechnology, where most of the risks are complex, ambiguous, and uncertain in nature, it is essential to obtain complete data and metadata, to fill knowledge gaps, and to transform the available knowledge into functional knowledge. This can become possible using a novel approach developed within the NANORIGO project (Grant agreement No. 814530) – the Knowledge Readiness Level (KaRL). In analogy to NASA’s Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs), we define KaRLs as a categorization system of data, information, and knowledge which enables transformation of data and information into functional knowledge for nanorisk governance. Our approach goes beyond the technical curation of data and metadata and involves quality and completeness filters, regulatory compliance requirements, nanorisk-related tools, and most importantly, human input (inclusion of all stakeholder groups). With the KaRL approach we also address key issues in nanotechnology such as societal and ethical concerns, circular economies and sustainability, the Green Deal, and the traceability of data, knowledge, and decisions. The KaRL approach could be used for nanorisk governance by a nanorisk governance council (NRGC), which is currently under development by three EU projects (NANORIGO, GOV4NANO, and RISKGONE). T2 - Gov4Nano: data management core group CY - Online meeting DA - 05.07.2021 KW - Data Management KW - Knowledge Readiness Level KW - Nanorisk Governance KW - Participatory Approach KW - Sustainability PY - 2021 UR - https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:kobv:b43-529264 AN - OPUS4-52926 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Kranjc, E. A1 - Bohmer, N. A1 - Drobne, D. A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Testing the quality of nanomaterial properties data for nano-risk assessment – towards guidance for all types of users N2 - Data quality is a vast term, which comprises the completeness, relevance (adequacy), and reliability of data. So far, many attempts to assure data quality have been pursued, and evaluation criteria for data quality have been established. One relatively novel but already well-known aspect of data quality refers to the concept of data FAIRness, which states that data should be: findable, accessible, interoperable and re-usable. In order to find, use, and access data, a user has to be guided properly. Such guidelines already exist for regulators and the scientific community. However, a ‘simple’ non-academic user from general society is very unlikely to be able to access or understand such data. Our objective in the H2020 project NANORIGO is to help and guide all types of users (i.e., scientists, regulators, industry workers, citizens, etc.) to access and make use of high-quality data and information from available and suitable data repositories in order to increase the transparency of and trust in nanotechnology. T2 - nanoSAFE 2020 CY - Online Meeting DA - 16.11.2020 KW - Nano-related data KW - Nanomaterial properties KW - Nano-risk assessment PY - 2020 AN - OPUS4-51701 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Drobne, D. A1 - Novak, S. A1 - Kranjc, E. A1 - Bohmer, N. A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan A1 - Reuther, R. T1 - Knowledge, Information and Data Readiness Levels (KaRL) approach for Nanorisk Governance N2 - Nanomaterials may have brought many beneficial innovations with them in our daily lives and and have become indispensable for the society. However, one needs to be concerned of the risks which are still unknown and not sufficietly studied and therefore there is a need for a nanorisk governance. At the core of nanorisk governance is gathering, processing and analysing reliable data which will be used for decision making. The challenge is to assure data reliability and transform it into knowledge. To address this challenge, we used analogy to technology readiness level (TRL) approach (developed by NASA), and elaborated knowledge readiness level (KaRL). KaRL is a nine-scale system to categorize data and knowledge (documents) into levels of readiness for particular purposes and to enhance readiness level by using quality and completeness filters, compliance requirements, nanorisk-related tools, stakeholders’ input. By our approach we addressed key issues in nanotechnology such as societal and ethical concerns, circular economy and sustainability, traceability of data, knowledge and decisions. T2 - EC - HORIZON EUROPE NMBP-13 Joint Conference Risk Governance of nanotechnology CY - Online meeting DA - 12.04.2021 KW - Knowledge Readiness Level KW - Nanorisk KW - Nanomaterials KW - Data PY - 2021 AN - OPUS4-52471 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Drobne, D. A1 - Novak, S. A1 - Kranjc, E. A1 - Bohmer, N. A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Knowledge Readiness Level (KaRL) approach for nanorisk governance and beyond N2 - Regulatory decisions require reliable data and knowledge derived from this. Among stakeholders in nanotechnology, however, there is often uncertainty about the quality of data for regulatory purposes. In addition, the general public often finds itself excluded from nanoregulation and policy decisions. This creates uncertainty in the nanotechnology field and also in other branches of technology and leads to concerns among the society. To address these issues, NANORIGO elaborates a framework to support decision making as well as data, information and knowledge sharing and use. We refer to “reliability” of data and knowledge as a degree of readiness or maturity. According to these criteria we worked out a 9-level scale in analogy to TRL (technology readiness level), the KaRL system (Knowledge, Data and Information Readiness Level). KaRL allows assessment of knowledge readiness for decision making by applying defined quality criteria for each level. It also provides guidance on how to enhance the readiness level by the help of available tools and procedures. KaRL addresses SEIN[1] principles, circular economy and thus involves the public concerns in regulation. A specialized nanorisk governance council (being under development in NANORIGO) is suggested to perform quality check of an actionable document, thus, aiding in consensus on the reliability (maturity) of knowledge for decision making. Moreover, KaRL facilitates traceability of knowledge before its use in decision making. This enables the transparency demanded by all stakeholders. T2 - EuroNanoForum 2021 CY - Online meeting DA - 05.05.2021 KW - Knowledge Readiness Level KW - Nanorisk KW - Nanomaterials KW - Data PY - 2021 UR - https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:kobv:b43-524725 AN - OPUS4-52472 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Altmann, Korinna A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan A1 - Braun, U. T1 - Requirements for inter-lab comparison studies and cooperation with CUSP and JRC N2 - Results from different methods applied to micro- and nanoplastics (MNPs) analysis show that there are large gaps in harmonisation with respect to terminology, size classes, sample preparation protocols and, finally, to the comparability of the measurands and descriptors. Within the European research cluster to understand the health impacts of micro- and nanoplastics (CUSP) working group WG3-Inter-Laboratory Comparisons an overview of the existing detection methods revealing advantages and disadvantages regarding the analytical tasks is being compiled. There is a clear need to develop high class characterized reference materials for MNPs in the size ranges of 100-10 µm and smaller than 10 µm, so that these can be used to validate methods and to make results comparable. Inter-laboratory comparisons (ILCs) on model samples with complex matrices regarding mass, or water samples for number-based methods, will help us to advance the process of harmonization as well as to train users early in process of developing new methods. We plan to keep all five CUSP projects well-connected also with the 'outside' MNP projects and ILCs and to extract the optimum of needs, capabilities, and efforts in order to launch new VAMAS ILCs which should expand already available ones. T2 - CUSP Meeting and General Assembly of PlasticsFatE CY - Online meeting DA - 13.12.2021 KW - CUSP KW - Microplastic KW - Inter-lab comparison KW - VAMAS KW - Reference materials PY - 2021 UR - https://cusp-research.eu/about/ AN - OPUS4-54036 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan A1 - Altmann, Korinna T1 - Validation of microplastics detection methods and proficiency testing: Suitable microplastic reference materials for interlaboratory comparison N2 - Since microplastics (MPs) can be found everywhere and are becoming a problem of high concern, it is necessary to understand their physico-chemical properties. To obtain reliable analytical data a set of validated methods for sampling, sample preparation, detection, and data evaluation are needed. To meet these needs an interlaboratory comparison (ILC) with 84 participants worldwide has been organized under the international pre-standardisation platform VAMAS (www.vamas.org/twa45/) as Project 2 “Development of standardized methodologies for characterisation of microplastics with microscopy and spectroscopy methods” within the Technical Working Area TWA 45 “Micro and Nano Plastics in the Environment”. In this ILC thermo-analytical methods (Py-GC/MS and TED-GC/MS) and vibrational methods (µ-Raman and µ-FTIR) have been tested and compared by providing a set of microplastic representative test materials and measurement protocols developed at BAM. The defined measurands were: particle number concentration, particle size distribution (PSD), and polymer identity and mass content. To increase the statistical quality, 6 samples were shipped together with blank samples. Hence, the ILC provides information on precision and accuracy of the results obtained with different methods as well as strengths and limitations of the proposed protocols. T2 - SETAC 34th Meeting CY - Seville, Spain DA - 05.05.2024 KW - ILC KW - Microplastic KW - Method validation KW - Stakeholder KW - Reference materials KW - Polyethylene KW - Polyethylene Terephtalate PY - 2024 AN - OPUS4-60039 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan A1 - Benismail, Nizar A1 - Altmann, Korinna T1 - Interlaboratory comparisons for obtaining reliable data on microplastic detection methods N2 - Since microplastics (MPs) can be found everywhere and are becoming a problem of high concern, it is necessary to understand their occurrence and fate in the environment. However, to obtain data of high quality is very challenging, since measurement operating procedures differ from laboratory to laboratory. Currently, there are no standardized methods to analyze microplastics. One promissing possibility to adress standardization of the methodology and operating procedures are interlaboratory comparisons (ILCs). In this contribution we report the first results of an ILC on microplastic detection methods organized under the pre-stantdardisation plattform of VAMAS (www.vamas.org/twa45/) as Project 2 “Development of standardized methodologies for characterisation of microplastics with microscopy and spectroscopy methods”, within the Technical Working Area TWA 45 “Micro and Nano Plastics in the Environment”. The ILC has gathered 84 participants all over the world representing all continents. BAM, as the project leader, produced a set of reference microplastic materials, which have been distributed to all the participants together with the measurement protocols and reporting data templates. T2 - SETAC 34th Meeting CY - Seville, Spain DA - 05.05.2024 KW - ILC KW - Microplastic KW - Py-GC/MS KW - Polyethylene KW - µ-Raman KW - µ-FTIR KW - Polyethylene Terephtalate KW - TED-GC/MS PY - 2024 AN - OPUS4-60038 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Altmann, Korinna A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Getting reliable data on microplastic detection methods by means of ILC N2 - There is an urgent demand for reliable data on microplastic analysis, particularly on its physico-chemical properties as well as validated methodology to obtain such data. Through interlaboratory comparisons (ILCs) it becomes possible to assess accuracy and precision of methods by involving many laboratories around the world. At BAM, my tasks focused around organisation of an ILC on physico-chemical characterisation of microplastic detection methods under the international pre-standardisation platform VAMAS (www.vamas.org/twa45/) as Project 2 “Development of standardized methodologies for characterisation of microplastics with microscopy and spectroscopy methods” under the Technical Working Area TWA 45 “Micro and Nano Plastics in the Environment”. With a proud number of 84 participants this ILC is able to provide superior statistical results. Thermoanalytical (Py-GC/MS and TED-GC/MS) and vibrational (µ-IR and µ-Raman) methods were asked for identification and quantification of microplastic test samples according to mass or particle number. Preliminary results indicate which methods show a higher accuracy and precision and reveal some sample preparation ideas which work best for microplastics characterisation. At the end of the ILC an overall plausibility of the results will be assessed. T2 - CUSP Early Career Researchers Meeting CY - Online meeting DA - 21.11.2023 KW - Micro- and Nanoplastics KW - Interlaboratory comparison KW - Microplastic reference materials PY - 2023 AN - OPUS4-59056 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER - TY - CONF A1 - Ciornii, Dmitri A1 - Waniek, Tassilo A1 - Braun, Ulrike A1 - Altmann, Korinna A1 - Hodoroaba, Vasile-Dan T1 - Interlaboratory Comparisons – ILCs (2022-2023) N2 - To obtain reliable data on micro- and nanoplastics (MPs, NPs) BAM (Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing) is organizing interlaboratory comparisons (ILCs). Main focus is detection and physico-chemical characterisation. The accuracy and precision of the results of different laboratories and comparability of the results among the participants are addressed. The ILCs will be performed in the following order: i) ILC #1: Detection and Characterisation of MPs (1-1000 µm) and ii) ILC #2: Detection and Characterisation of NPs (< 1 µm). For the ILC #1 the parameters to be analysed are: particle size distribution, shape, mass content, particle concentration, with thermoanalytic (Py-GC/MS, TED-GC/MS) and spectroscopy (µ-Raman, µ-FTIR) methods. For the ILC #2 the parameters are: particle size distribution, shape, particle concentration, with methods such as spectroscopical (Raman), Electron Microscopies (SEM, AFM), etc. Exact measurands and methods are still under discussion. BAM will provide test materials of well-known stability and homogeneity. ILC participants will include partners of the CUSP (the European research cluster to understand the health impacts of micro- and nanoplastics), and any other institutions over the world. The ILCs will take place under the international pre-standardisation platform VAMAS, new Technical Working Area 35 “Micro and Nano Plastics in the Environment” (http://www.vamas.org/twa45/). T2 - Progressing Together: 2nd CUSP Annual Meeting at the JRC (Ispra) CY - Ispra, Italy DA - 08.06.2022 KW - ILC KW - Micro- and nanoplastics KW - VAMAS KW - Analytical methods PY - 2022 AN - OPUS4-55097 LA - eng AD - Bundesanstalt fuer Materialforschung und -pruefung (BAM), Berlin, Germany ER -