Refine
Year of publication
Document Type
Way of publication
- Open Access (3)
Keywords
- Mistuning (12)
- Damping (9)
- Blisk (7)
- Turbines (5)
- Blades (4)
- Blisks (4)
- Rotors (4)
- Aeroelasticity (3)
- Compressor Blisk (3)
- Compressors (3)
Institute
BTU
Auf Grund der im Rahmen eines Testfluges subjektiv durch den Piloten festgestellten hohen Schwingungsamplituden wird das dynamische Verhalten eines Ultraleichtflugzeugmotors inklusive der Motoraufhängung untersucht. Hierin wir der numerische Teil der Untersuchun-gen durch eine finite Elemente Simulation abgedeckt, in deren Rahmen die wesentlichen Ei-genschwingformen der Antriebseinheit samt Motorträger identifiziert wurden. Ergänzend mit den Ergebnissen einer experimentellen Modalanalyse und Betriebsschwingungsmessungen konnten wesentliche Informationen gewonnen werden, aus denen als Maßnahme zur Schwin-gungsreduzierung die Erhöhung der Schwungradmasse abgeleitet wurde.
Theoretical frequencies and mode shapes of the high multi-flue industrial chimney, which is located in the power station of Opole, interacting with soil have been evaluated through the application of the finite element method. The aim of the present paper is to study the free vibrations of this chimney applying dynamic testing in full scale to confirm a calculation model and to obtain important information on the effect of soil interacting with the chimney.
Initiiert durch die im Rahmen eines Testfluges subjektiv durch den Piloten festgestellten hohen Schwingungsamplituden wird das dynamische Verhalten eines Ultraleichtflugzeugmotors inklusive der Motoraufhängung untersucht. Hierin wir der numerische Teil der Untersuchungen durch eine finite Elemente Simulation abgedeckt, in deren Rahmen die wesentlichen Eigenschwingformen der Antriebseinheit samt Motorträger identifiziert wurden. Ergänzend mit den Ergebnissen einer experimentellen Modalanalyse und Betriebsschwingungsmessungen konnten wesentliche Informationen gewonnen werden, aus denen als Maßnahme zur Schwin-gungsreduzierung die Erhöhung der Schwungradmasse abgeleitet wurde.
Theoretical and experimental free vibrations of tall industrial chimney with flexibility of soil
(2005)
Simulation fluidgedämpfter Strukturschwingungen mittels partitionierter Fluid-Struktur-Kopplung
(2005)
Theoretische und experimentelle Untersuchungen von Schaufelschwingungen bei Verdichterintegralrädern
(2006)
Radial turbine wheels designed as blade integrated disks (blisk) are widely used in various industrial applications. However, related to the introduction of exhaust gas turbochargers in the field of small and medium sized engines, a sustainable demand for radial turbine wheels has come along. Despite those blisks being state of the art, a number of fundamental problems, mainly referring to fluid-structure-interaction and, therefore, to the vibration behavior, have been reported. Aiming to achieve an enhanced understanding of fluid-structure-interaction in radial turbine wheels, a numerical method, able to predict forced responses of mistuned blisks due to aerodynamic excitation, is presented. In a first step, the unsteady aerodynamic forcing is determined by modeling the spiral casing, the stator vanes, and the rotor blades of the entire turbine stage. In a second step, the aerodynamic damping induced by blade vibration is computed using a harmonic balance technique. The structure itself is represented by a reduced order model being extended by aerodynamic damping effects and aerodynamic forcings. Mistuning is introduced by adjusting the modal stiffness matrix based on results of blade by blade measurements that have been performed at rest. In order to verify the numerical method, the results are compared with strain-gauge data obtained during rig-tests. As a result, a measured low engine order excitation was found by modeling the spiral casing. Furthermore, a localization phenomenon due to frequency mistuning could be proven. The predicted amplitudes are close to the measured data.
The forced response of an E3E-type high pressure compressor (HPC) blisk front rotor is analyzed with regard to varying mistuning and the consideration of the fluid-structure interaction (FSI). For that purpose, a reduced order model is used in which the disk remains unchanged and mechanical properties of the blades, namely stiffness and damping, are adjusted to measured as well as intentional blade frequency mistuning distributions. The aerodynamic influence coefficient technique is employed to model the aeroelastics. Depending on the blade mode, the exciting engine order, and aerodynamic influences, it is sought for the worst mistuning distributions with respect to the maximum blade displacement based on optimization analyses. Genetic algorithms using blade-alone frequencies as design variables are applied. The validity of the Whitehead limit is assessed in this context. In particular, the question is addressed if and how far aeroelastic effects, mainly caused by aerodynamic damping, combined with mistuning can even cause a reduction of the forced response compared to the ideally tuned blisk. It is shown that the strong dependence of the aerodynamic damping on the interblade phase angle is the main driver for a possible response attenuation considering the fundamental as well as a higher blade mode. Furthermore, the differences to the blisk vibration response without a consideration of the flow and an increase of the disk's stiffness are discussed. Closing, the influence of pure damping mistuning is analyzed again using optimization.
The forced response of the first rotor of an engine 3E (technology program) (E3E)-type high pressure compressor (HPC) blisk is analyzed with regard to varying mistuning, varying engine order (EO) excitations and the consideration of aero-elastic effects. For that purpose, subset of nominal system modes (SNM)-based reduced order models are used in which the disk remains unchanged while the Young's modulus of each blade is used to define experimentally adjusted as well as intentional mistuning patterns. The aerodynamic influence coefficient (AIC) technique is employed to model aero-elastic interactions. Furthermore, based on optimization analyses and depending on the exciting EO and aerodynamic influences it is searched for the worst as well as the best mistuning distributions with respect to the maximum blade displacement. Genetic algorithms using blade stiffness variations as vector of design variables and the maximum blade displacement as objective function are applied. An allowed limit of the blades' Young's modulus standard deviation is formulated as secondary condition. In particular, the question is addressed if and how far the aero-elastic impact, mainly causing aerodynamic damping, combined with mistuning can even yield a reduction of the forced response compared to the ideally tuned blisk. It is shown that the strong dependence of the aerodynamic damping on the interblade phase angle is the main driver for a possible response attenuation considering the fundamental blade mode. The results of the optimization analyses are compared to the forced response due to real, experimentally determined frequency mistuning as well as intentional mistuning.
Using the example of a compressor test blisk with 29 blades different sources of mistuning and their consequences for the forced response are analysed under consideration of aeroelastic effects. In particular the impact of superimposing intentional structural mistuning by both random structural mistuning and aerodynamic mistuning is studied. For this purpose reduced order models of the blisk are adjusted for different mistuning distributions. The mistuning itself is characterized by assigning individual stiffness parameters to each blade. The aeroelastic coupling is included employing aerodynamic influence coefficients. By means of genetic algorithm optimizations, structural mistuning patterns are found which yield a mitigation of the forced response below that of the tuned design reference. Ideally a nearly 50 % reduction of maximum response magnitudes is computed for the fundamental bending mode and large mistuning. The solutions found have been proven to be robust with respect to additional random and aerodynamic mistuning in case of large intentional structural mistuning.
The potential of intentional mistuning to reduce the maximum forced response is analyzed within the development of an axial turbine blisk for ship diesel engine turbocharger applications. The basic idea of the approach is to provide an increased aerodynamic damping level for particular engine order excitations and mode shapes without any significant distortions of the aerodynamic performance. The mistuning pattern intended to yield a mitigation of the forced response is derived from an optimization study applying genetic algorithms. Two blisk prototypes have been manufactured a first one with and another one without employing intentional mistuning. Hence, the differences regarding the real mistuning and other modal properties can be experimentally determined and evaluated as well. In addition, the experimental data basis allows for updating structural models which are well suited to compute the forced response under operational conditions. In this way, the real benefit achieved with the application of intentional mistuning is demonstrated.
The effect of intentional mistuning has been analyzed for an axial turbocharger blisk with the objective of limiting the forced response due to low engine order excitation (LEO). The idea behind the approach was to increase the aerodynamic damping for the most critical fundamental mode in a way that a safe operation is ensured without severely losing aerodynamic performance. Apart from alternate mistuning a more effective mistuning pattern is investigated, which has been derived by means of optimization employing genetic algorithms. In order to keep the manufacturing effort as small as possible only two blade different geometries have been allowed which means that an integer optimization problem has been formulated. Two blisk prototypes have been manufactured for the purpose of demonstrating the benefit of the intentional mistuning pattern identified in this way: A first one with and a second one without employing intentional mistuning. The real mistuning of the prototypes has been experimentally identified. It is shown that the benefit regarding the forced response reduction is retained in spite of the negative impact of unavoidable additional mistuning due to the manufacturing process. Independently, further analyzes have been focused on the robustness of the solution by considering increasing random structural mistuning and aerodynamic mistuning as well. The latter one has been modeled by means of varying aerodynamic influence coefficients (AIC) as part of Monte Carlo simulations. Reduced order models have been employed for these purposes.
With the objective of attenuating the forced response of an axial turbine blisk for ship Diesel engine applications efforts have been made to increase the aerodynamic damping contribution for the most critical modes. In this regard the potential of intentional mistuning is investigated since it offers the opportunity to ensure a safe operation without a severe loss of aerodynamic performance. Genetic algorithms have been chosen to derive an optimized mistuning pattern resulting in a forced response clearly below that of the tuned counterpart. In order to keep the manufacturing effort within a limit only two possible blade geometries are allowed, which means that an integer optimization problem has been formulated. For the purpose of demonstrating the benefit of the intentional mistuning pattern found, two blisk prototypes have been manufactured: One with and another one without employing intentional mistuning for purposes of comparison. Furthermore, this offers the opportunity for an experimental determination of actually manufactured mistuning and other modal properties as well. The experimental data basis is employed to update structural models, which are well suited to demonstrate the forced response reduction under operational conditions. Finally, the robustness of the gain achieved with intentional mistuning could be proved towards both additional but unavoidable random structural and aerodynamic mistuning.
Turbolader tragen erheblich zur Steigerung des Motorenwirkungsgrads bei. Rotierende Komponenten sind infolge der Fliehkraft, der zur Aufladung notwendigen Strömungsumlenkungen, der instationären Druckschwankungen der Strömung sowie von Temperaturgradienten als hochbelastete Laufräder einzustufen, die unter erheblicher Schwingungsanfälligkeit leiden. Am Lehrstuhl Strukturmechanik und Fahrzeugschwingungen der BTU Cottbus-Senftenberg wurde im Rahmen eines FVV-Forschungsvorhabens der Einfluss der fertigungsbedingten Toleranzen auf eben jenes Schwingungsverhalten untersucht. Es wird nachgewiesen, dass Intentional Mistuning zu signifikant niedrigeren Belastungen führen kann.
Surrogate Models for the Prediction of Damping Ratios in Coupled Acoustoelastic Rotor-Cavity Systems
(2021)
The oil and gas, chemical, and process industries employ centrifugal compressors for a wide range of applications. Due to this, the conditions, under which centrifugal compressors have to operate, vary significantly from case to case. Gas pipeline compressors, for example, may feature discharge pressures well over 100 bar. In other fields of application, like gas injection for enhanced oil recovery, discharge pressures over 600 bar and gas densities over 300 kg/m^3 are not uncommon. During the last decades, comprehensive research was conducted on the impact of high pressure operating conditions on the vibrational behavior of centrifugal compressor wheels. In multiple studies, acoustic modes building up in the side cavities were found to be a potential source of high cycle fatigue in radial compressors. Nowadays, it is well-known that an increase in gas pressure levels leads to a more pronounced fluid-structure interaction between the side cavities and the impeller resulting in a frequency shift of the acoustic and structural modes.
For the safe operation of compressors, it is necessary to predict these coupled natural frequencies accurately. The state-of-the-art approach to achieve this objective is the finite element method. In a recently published paper, the authors presented a generalized model to predict the natural frequencies and mode shapes of acoustoelastic rotor-cavity systems. This approach reduces the computational cost significantly while retaining the accuracy of a finite element simulation. So far, the model was only validated using measurement data of an impeller at standstill under varying cavity pressures. In this study, the authors show that the generalized model can predict the natural frequencies of rotating systems with sufficient accuracy by using measurement data of a disk spinning at multiple rotational speeds in a cylindrical cavity.
As it is not always possible to avoid operating close to or accelerate through a resonance of the compressor, it is crucial to know the damping present within the system that limits the amplitudes for a given excitation force. While many studies focus on the identification of damping ratios in axial turbomachines, only a few publications concentrate on the damping of radial impellers. Therefore, the authors present measurement data acquired from the test rig at University Duisburg-Essen, Chair of Turbomachinery, which reveals the damping behavior of a spinning disk under varying operating conditions. Three surrogate models are proposed to predict the identified damping behavior. The first one is based solely on a one-dimensional piston model. The second approach uses an enhanced version of the generalized method, while the third one is a combination of both. After deriving these three models, the measurement data is used to validate the surrogate systems. The paper concludes with a discussion of the measurement results and the benefits and limitations of the proposed models.
The radial turbine impeller of an exhaust turbocharger is analyzed in view of both free vibration and forced response. Stator vane rings located upstream between engine and turbine wheel are applied to guide the exhaust gases in optimized flow directions. Hence, turbine wheels are subjected to aerodynamic excitations causing forced vibrations of blades and the whole turbine. Due to random blade mistuning resulting from unavoidable inaccuracies in manufacture or material inhomogeneities, localized modes of vibration may arise, which involve the risk of severely magnified blade displacements and inadmissibly high stress levels compared to the tuned counterpart. In consequence, damages may occur along with a dramatic decrease of efficiency or even a total failure during engine operation as worst-case scenarios. Contrary, the use of intentional mistuning has proved to be an efficient measure to mitigate the forced response.
Independently, the presence of aerodynamic damping is significant with respect to limit the forced response since structural damping ratios of blade integrated disks (blisks) typically take extremely low values. Thus, a detailed knowledge of respective damping ratios would be desirable while developing a robust blisk design. For this, far-reaching experimental investigations are carried out to determine damping curves of a comparative wheel within a wide pressure range by simulating operation conditions in a pressure tank. They are the basis to develop empirical formulas for damping estimation which could be be taken into account during future design processes. In order to get an idea of the real structural behaviour, further measurements are conducted to determine the present mistuning of the turbine wheel, which facilitates to update structural models and finally allows to compute the forced response in an accurate manner.
Reduced order models are built up for designing suitable intentional mistuning patterns by using the subset of nominal system mode (SNM) approach introduced by Yang and Griffin [1], which conveniently allows for accounting both differing mistuning patterns and the impact of aeroelastic interaction. For this, the aerodynamic damping curves are determined by means of computational flow simulations. The SNM approach finally provides appropriate mistuning patterns by conducting optimization studies based on genetic algorithms. The robustness of the found solutions is proved by additionally superimposing both random mistuning and experimentally determined mistuning of the original wheel.
Finite element analyses are carried out in order to identify appropriate measures to implement intentional mistuning patterns, which are featuring only two different blade designs. In detail, the impact of specific geometric modifications on blade natural frequencies is investigated. After implementation of the intentional mistuning pattern, which will be described in Part 2 of this paper later on, the success of taken measures will be reviewed based on both, experimental testing at standstill conditions and in a test stand by running the wheel under realistic operational conditions.
[1] Yang, M. T., Griffin, J. H., „A Reduced-Order model of Mistuning Using a Subset of Nominal System Modes“. J Eng Gas Turb Power, 123, pp. 893-900 (2001).
The radial turbine impeller of an exhaust turbocharger is analyzed in view of both free vibration and forced response. Due to random blade mistuning resulting from unavoidable inaccuracies in manufacture or material inhomogeneities, localized modes of vibration may arise, which involve the risk of severely magnified blade displacements and inadmissibly high-stress levels compared to the tuned counterpart. Contrary, the use of intentional mistuning (IM) has proved to be an efficient measure to mitigate the forced response. Independently, the presence of aerodynamic damping is significant with respect to limit the forced response since structural damping ratios of integrally bladed rotors typically take extremely low values. Hence, detailed knowledge of respective damping ratios would be desirable while developing a robust rotor design. For this, far-reaching experimental investigations are carried out to determine the damping of a comparative wheel within a wide pressure range by simulating operation conditions in a pressure tank. Reduced-order models are built up for designing suitable intentional mistuning patterns by using the subset of nominal system modes approach introduced by Yang and Griffin (2001, “A Reduced-Order Model of Mistuning Using a Subset of Nominal System Modes,” J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power, 123(4), pp. 893–900), which conveniently allows for accounting both differing mistuning patterns and the impact of aeroelastic interaction by means of aerodynamic influence coefficients. Further, finite element analyses are carried out in order to identify appropriate measures of how to implement intentional mistuning patterns, which are featuring only two different blade designs. In detail, the impact of specific geometric modifications on blade natural frequencies is investigated. The first part of this three-part paper is focused on designing the IM pattern. The second and third part following, later on, will address the topics (i) experimental validation after implementation of the IM pattern at rest and under rotation, and (ii) the development of an approach for fast estimating damping ratios in the design phase.
Surrogate Models for the Prediction of Damping Ratios in Coupled Acoustoelastic Rotor-Cavity Systems
(2022)
Centrifugal compressors are versatile machines that many industries employ for a wide range of different applications, including the production of highly compressed gases. During the last decades, comprehensive research was conducted on the impact of high-pressure operating conditions on the vibrational behavior of radial compressors. In various studies, acoustic modes building up in the side cavities were found to be a potential source of high cycle fatigue. Nowadays, it is well-known that an increase in gas pressure levels leads to a more pronounced fluid-structure interaction between the side cavities and the impeller resulting in a frequency shift of the acoustic and structural modes. In a recently published paper, the authors presented a generalized model which can predict this behavior. As it is not always possible to avoid operating close to or accelerating through a resonance, it is crucial to know the damping present within the system. Currently, only a few publications concentrate on the damping of radial impellers. Therefore, the authors present measurement data acquired from a test rig at the University of Duisburg-Essen, which reveals the damping behavior of a disk under varying operating conditions. Two surrogate models are proposed to predict the identified damping behavior. The first one is based solely on a one-dimensional piston model and the second approach uses an enhanced version of the generalized method. Finally, the measurement data is used to validate both surrogate systems.
The effect of different intentional mistuning (IM) patterns is investigated with respect to the forced response of an academic axial blisk. It could be shown in numerical analyses that a preliminary use of sensitivity algorithms helps to understand the feasibility and efficiency of introducing geometric changes of the blades. The implementation of IM patterns requires conducting intensive sensitivity studies based on FE simulations in order to identify the consequences of slight geometrical blade modifications on natural frequencies. Typical changes might be a modification of fillet radii or partial modifications of blade thickness, which are most suitable to adjust a target natural frequency without a severe loss of aerodynamic performance. A software tool developed at Irkutsk SAU is employed to evaluate the impact of mass and stiffness contributions, and with that, geometric deviations on blade natural frequencies.
Intensive blade vibration due to aerodynamic excitation of blisks is known as major source of high cycle fatigue, which may cause severe failures of turbine and compressor wheels during operation. The problem is relevant for several sectors of industry such as power generation, aviation or vehicle manufacturing. In consequence, there is a broad request of preventing any inadmissible vibration at any time. The application of IM can be regarded as powerful tool to avoid both, large forced responses and self-excited vibration. However, there is a lack of knowledge about how to implement mistuning without strong distortions of the flow passage. The main objective of this work is to close this gap based on comprehensive numerical analyses with regard to the effects of intended geometric modifications of blades on modal quantities.
Using FE models, the effectiveness of the proposed block models of mistuning is analyzed with and without taking into account the operational speed of the axial impeller. In conclusion, the consequences of different IM implementations on the forced response of an academic blisk are discussed. In particular, the most promising IM patterns are identified yielding the least forced response.
A radial turbine impeller of an exhaust turbocharger is analyzed in view of both free vibration and forced response. Due to random blade mistuning resulting from unavoidable inaccuracies in manufacture or material inhomogeneities, localized modes of vibration may arise, which involve the risk of severely magnified blade displacements and inadmissibly high stress levels compared to the tuned counterpart. Contrary, the use of intentional mistuning (IM) has proved to be an efficient measure to mitigate the forced response.
In part one of this three-part paper fundamental analyses have been carried out to find a suitable intentional mistuning pattern which is featuring only two different blade designs [1]. This part is focused on the implementation and validation of the intentional mistuning pattern and discusses the detailed geometric adaption of the turbine wheel hardware. The final design of the geometric adaption is developed in terms of manufacturability and efficiency so that a reliable and robust solution is presented. Its machined adaption is validated by both vibration testing at rest and optical measurements so that manufacturing deviations are detected and their impacts discussed and evaluated. Reduced order models are built up for checking the effect of the implemented intentional mistuning pattern on the forced response by using the subset of nominal system modes (SNM) approach introduced by Yang and Griffin [2], which conveniently allows for accounting both the design intention of the mistuning pattern and the actually machined implementation due to manufacturing deviations.
The analysis of the structural dynamics of multistage cyclic structures as linked components is required to model the interstage coupling. In turbomachinery, this can result in a collaboration between different compressor or turbine stages. This paper investigates the coupling between two rear drum blade integrated disk stages of an axial compressor to support the mechanical design process. Considering the vibration modeshapes of a multistage system, different components may coparticipate in the dynamics. For this reason, criteria to identify the modes affected by the coupling and to quantify this coupling are defined. This allows to distinguish between modes with interstage coupling, requiring the multistage system for their description, and uncoupled modes, involving a single stage. In addition, it is of interest to research methods to reduce the impact of the coupling on the vibrating system without drastically altering the geometry of the components. The vibration analyses of a two-stage compressor generalized geometry, representative of a compressor rear drum blisk, are presented as a study case. The use of a reducing method allows to describe the behavior of the nominal multistage system with a computationally efficient technique, enabling a parametric analysis of the stages' coupling. The investigation considers the effect of a set of geometrical and mechanical parameters on the dynamics, identifying the driving parameters of the coupled vibration characteristics.
A last stage steam turbine wheel is analyzed with the objective to alleviate the flutter susceptibility by employing intentional mistuning (IM). In particular, the operation at nominal speed under part-load conditions may cause unfavorable flow conditions facilitating flow separation. In consequence, negative aerodynamic
damping ratios occur for the first bending mode family in some circumstances.
Employing intended alternate mistuning of adequate magnitude has proved to be a promising measure to stabilize rotors in terms of avoiding self-excited vibration phenomena. From the manufacturing point of view, this two-blade design is advantageous as well and hence, chosen here as a first measure to attenuate flutter susceptibility. Two prototypes of bladed disks series have been made, which are exhibiting small but unavoidable deviations from the design intention due to manufacturing. The real blade alone frequencies have been identified within foregoing experimental investigations. Numerical modal analyses carried out for the prototypes as manufactured finally reveal that there is an additional positive contribution of random mistuning in terms of further enhancing the least aerodynamic damping ratio. Another promising and robust IM pattern is found by using generic algorithms to optimize the least aerodynamic damping ratio yielding stable conditions at any time as well. Moreover, it shows that IM combined with random mistuning also mitigates the maximum forced response at part-speed conditions.
The effect of intentional mistuning has been analyzed for an axial turbocharger blisk with the objective of limiting the forced response due to low engine order excitation (LEO). The idea behind the approach was to increase the aerodynamic damping for the most critical fundamental mode in a way that a safe operation is ensured without severely losing aerodynamic performance. Apart from alternate mistuning a more effective mistuning pattern is investigated, which has been derived by means of optimization employing genetic algorithms. In order to keep the manufacturing effort as small as possible only two blade different geometries have been allowed which means that an integer optimization problem has been formulated. Two blisk prototypes have been manufactured for the purpose of demonstrating the benefit of the intentional mistuning pattern identified in this way: A first one with and a second one without employing intentional mistuning. The real mistuning of the prototypes has been experimentally identified. It is shown that the benefit regarding the forced response reduction is retained in spite of the negative impact of unavoidable additional mistuning due to the manufacturing process. Independently, further analyzes have been focused on the robustness of the solution by considering increasing random structural mistuning and aerodynamic mistuning as well. The latter one has been modeled by means of varying aerodynamic influence coefficients (AIC) as part of Monte Carlo simulations. Reduced order models have been employed for these purposes.
Aiming to limit the forced response of an axial turbine blisk for ship Diesel engine applications efforts have been made to increase the aerodynamic damping contribution for the most critical modes.
In this regard the potential of intentional mistuning is investigated since it offers the opportunity to ensure a safe operation without a severe loss of aerodynamic performance. Genetic algorithms have been chosen to derive an optimized mistuning pattern. In order to keep the manufacturing effort within
a limit only two possible blade geometries are allowed which means that an integer optimization problem has been formulated. For the purpose of demonstrating the benefit of the intentional mistuning
pattern found, two blisk prototypes have been manufactured: One with and another one without employing intentional mistuning for purposes of comparison. Furthermore, this offers the opportunity for
an experimental determination of mistuning being really manufactured and other modal properties as well. The experimental data basis is employed to update structural models which are well suited to demonstrate the forced response reduction under operational conditions.
The forced response of the first rotor of an E3E-type high pressure compressor blisk is analyzed with regard to varying mistuning, varying engine order excitations and the consideration of aeroelastic effects. For that purpose, SNM-based reduced order models are used in which the disk remains unchanged while the Young’s modulus of each blade is used to define experimentally adjusted as well as intentional mistuning patterns. The aerodynamic influence coefficient technique is employed to model aeroelastic interactions. Furthermore, based on optimization analyses and depending on the exciting EO and aerodynamic influences it is searched for the worst as well as the best mistuning distributions with respect to the maximum blade displacement. Genetic algorithms using blade stiffness variations as vector of design variables and the maximum blade displacement as objective function are applied. An allowed limit of the blades’ Young’s modulus standard deviation is formulated as secondary condition. In particular, the question is addressed if and how far the aeroelastic impact, mainly causing aerodynamic damping, combined with mistuning can even yield a reduction of the forced response compared to the ideally tuned blisk. It is shown that the strong dependence of the aerodynamic damping on the inter-blade phase angle is the main driver for a possible response attenuation considering the fundamental blade mode. The results of the optimization analyses are compared to the forced response due to real, experimentally determined frequency mistuning as well as intentional mistuning.
Copyright © 2014 by Rolls-Royce Deutschland Ltd & Co KG
A mistuned radial turbine impeller is analyzed with respect to the impact of varying ambient pressures and temperatures as well on frequency response functions and modal damping ratios. Beginning at room conditions, a finite element model of an impeller wheel at rest is updated based on experimentally determined mistuning in terms of blade dominated frequencies. The following numerical forced response analyses yield a maximum blade displacement amplification of 67% compared to the tuned reference. In addition, modal damping ratios are determined in dependence on the ambient pressure ranging from technical vacuum at 1 mbar up to 6000 mbar in a pressure chamber. Shaker excitation and laser Doppler vibrometry response measurement is employed in this context. A linear dependence of modal damping ratios on ambient pressure and a dominating damping contribution of the surrounding air even for higher modes could be proved. Moreover, the experimental determination of frequency response functions (FRF) at technical vacuum yields a better separation of resonance peaks compared to room conditions at 1013 mbar and hence, this data allows for more accurate model-updates in principle. It is proved that numerical models updated regarding mistuning at room conditions are well suited to predict the forced response at arbitrary pressures if measured modal damping ratios at these pressures are considered. Finally, within analyzing the effect of increasing structural temperatures with the surrounding air at 1013 mbar included slightly decreasing resonance frequencies but strongly increasing FRF-amplitudes are determined.
Copyright © 2014 by ASME
This paper describes preparation, execution and evaluation of a comprehensive bladed disk spin test series. At the example of an turbine impeller the effects of rotation and temperature are analyzed with special focus on mistuning and damping. The forced response is measured synchronously via 13 identical positioned strain gauges on each blade as well as via blade tip-timing. Subsequently it is possible to compare the results of both systems. During the test series rotational speed varies in the range from 10.000 up to 19.000 RPM. Simultaneously, the wheel is heated up to 820 K by an oven. A number of pre-selected natural frequencies, damping ratios and operating deflection shapes are evaluated and compared with respect to different rotational speeds and impeller temperatures.
Copyright © 2015 by ASME
The forced response of an E3E-type high pressure compressor blisk front rotor is analyzed with regard to intentional mistuning and its robustness towards additional random mistuning. Both a chosen alternating mistuning pattern and artificial mistuning patterns optimized concerning the forced response are considered. Focusing on three different blade modes, subset of nominal system mode-based reduced order models are employed to compute the forced response. The disk remains unchanged while the Young’s modulus of each blade is used to define the particular mistuning pattern. The well established aerodynamic influence coefficient technique is employed to model aeroelastic coupling and hence to consider the strongly mode- and inter blade phase angle-dependent aerodynamic damping contribution.
It has been found that a reduction of the maximum forced response beyond that of the tuned reference can be achieved for particular mistuning patterns and all modes considered. This implies an exciting engine order which would cause a low nodal diameter mode in case of a tuned blisk. At best a nearly 50% reduction of maximum response magnitudes is computed for the fundamental bending mode and large mistuning. The solution proved to be robust towards additional random mistuning of reasonable magnitude, which is of particular interest with regard to a potential technical realization. In case of small mistuning as assumed for the first torsion and the longitudinal bending mode the advantage of achieving response magnitudes beyond the tuned reference gets lost indeed, if random mistuning is superimposed. However, mostly a lower response level is calculated compared to responses obtained from models adjusted to mistuning determined by experiment.
Copyright © 2015 by ASME
Experimentelle und theoretische Untersuchungen des dynamischen Verhaltens von Fernmeldetürmen
(2000)
The forced response of an E3E-type HPC-blisk front rotor is analyzed with regard to varying mistuning and the consideration of the fluid-structure interaction (FSI). For that purpose, a reduced order model is used in which the disk remains unchanged and mechanical properties of the blades namely stiffness and damping are adjusted to measured as well as intentional blade frequency mistuning distributions. The aerodynamic influence coefficient technique is employed to model the aeroelastics. Depending on the blade mode, the exciting engine order and aerodynamic influences it is sought for the worst mistuning distributions with respect to the maximum blade displacement based on optimization analyses. Genetic algorithms using blade alone frequencies as design variables are applied. The validity of the Whitehead-limit is assessed in this context. In particular, the question is addressed if and how far aeroelastic effects, mainly caused by aerodynamic damping, combined with mistuning can even cause a reduction of the forced response compared to the ideally tuned blisk. It is shown that the strong dependence of the aerodynamic damping on the inter-blade phase angle is the main driver for a possible response attenuation considering the fundamental as well as a higher blade mode. Furthermore, the differences to the blisk vibration response without a consideration of the flow and an increase of the disk’s stiffness are discussed. Closing, the influence of pure damping mistuning is analyzed again using optimization.
Die Verbesserung von Kalibriermethoden für Hochdruckverdichterstufen in ausgeführter Integralbauweise verlangt von den Ingenieuren ein detaillierteres Verständnis der strukturdynamischen Zusammenhänge dieses komplexen Bauteils. Als Ausgangsbasis werden zunächst für das perfekte Normdesign bei Ausnutzung der vorliegenden zyklischen Rotationssymmetrie numerische Ergebnisse vorgestellt. Dabei stehen bezüglich des Schwingverhaltens die Kopplungseffekte zwischen Scheibe und Schaufeln im Mittelpunkt, wobei experimentelle Untersu-chungen am realen Bauteil ergänzend hinzugezogen werden. Zukünftig wird in einem weiteren Schritt im Rahmen erheblich aufwendigerer Berechnungen mit der Berücksichtigung von Imperfektionen hinsichtlich der filigranen Schaufeln die Rotationssymmetrie aufgegeben und somit die Basis für eine gezielte Beeinflussung des Schwingverhaltens infolge von Mistuning - Effekten geschaffen.
The investigation of the excitation of turbocharger rotors to quantify the High-Cycle-Fatigue (HCF) risk is still a demanding task nowadays. The common way to investigate such phenomena is to look either at the turbine or the compressor rotor in an isolated manner. This approach gives mostly reliable results, if the investigated excitation pattern is stemming from the up- or downstream parts in the machine. However, there is a lack of studies on the existence of responses, which may exist due to the coupling between compressor and turbine. With the increase of computational capabilities and the improvement of FE tools, it is possible to create a full rotor model featuring the compressor and the turbine wheel as well as the bearings to investigate the dynamical behavior of the full rotor at different resonances.
To carry out such an investigation, both wheels and the shaft are modeled. The axial, as well as the radial bearings, are modelled realistically by suitable elements and values. Due to the asymmetry of damping and stiffness properties, the resulting system matrices are asymmetrical as well. The eigenfrequencies and mode shapes of such a system can be obtained in a reasonable time by carrying out a modal analysis using the QR damp eigensolver in Ansys APDL.
The present paper will show the differences in dynamical system effects of a mid-size turbocharger with different shaft support conditions. For this purpose, the FE simulation with the full rotor and fixed support at the radial bearing position, which is comparable to the isolated rotor consideration, will be compared to the model featuring the detailed bearing modeling with stiffness and damping values originating from the OEM. Besides the detailed process of modeling the bearings, the mutual influence of both rotor wheels at certain eigenfrequencies is analyzed. This allows to conclude on the level of detailing needed to ensure that dynamical system effects are properly accounted.
The service life of today’s turbochargers is limited among other things by the mechanical load caused by blade vibrations. In this context, the precise determination of the resonance operating points and the estimation of the vibration magnitudes are essential for an accurate assessment of the service life of the turbocharger components. Forced blade vibrations in radial turbines are primarily flow induced. Flow induced blade vibrations are caused by the nonuniform flow field in the circumferential direction which acts on the blades as a cyclic pressure fluctuation. Previous studies identified the inlet guide vane (IGV) as well as the spiral turbine housing as the primary sources of the non-uniform flow field.
In the present study a thorough experimental investigation of the synchronous blade vibrations of a radial turbine is performed. A detailed description of the experimental setup is given. In this setup the vibrations are captured with two redundant measurement systems during real turbocharger operation. Strain gauges, applied on certain blades, as well as optical tip-timing sensors distributed on the circumference of the turbine shroud are used. The advantages of the combined usage of these two measuring systems are shown in the paper.
Initially, the blade vibration modes are determined experimentally in stand still tests and numerically calculated through FEM models. This served for the creation of a Campbell diagram, which determined the speed ranges that are examined. The mistuning, which is not taken into account in the numerics, is therefore determined via the experiment. In addition, the experimental results are compared with those of numerics and the frequencies from standstill test. The first part of this two-part paper is focused on the vibrations caused by the “nominal” IGV. This “nominal” IGV has twice the number of blades compared to the rotor. Part 2 will analyze the changes of the blade vibrations due to the application of two different IGVs.
The manufacturing geometrical variability in axial compressors is a stochastic source of uncertainty, implying that the real geometry differs from the nominal design. This causes the real geometry to lose the ideal axial symmetry. Considering the aerofoils of a stator vane, the geometrical variability affects the flow traversing it. This impacts the downstream rotor, especially when considering the aeroelastic excitation forces. Optical surface scans coupled with a parametrization method allow for acquiring the information relative to the real aerofoils geometries. The measured data are included in a multi-passage and multi-stage CFD setup to represent the mistuned flow. In particular, low excitation harmonics on the rotor vane are introduced due to the geometrical deviations of the upstream stator. The introduced low engine orders as well as their amplitude depend on the stator geometries and their order. A method is proposed to represent the phenomena in a reduced CFD domain, limiting the size and number of solutions required to probabilistically describe the rotor excitation forces. The resulting rotor excitation forces are reconstructed as a superposition of disturbances due to individual stator aerofoils geometries. This indicates that the problem is linear in in the combination of disturbances from single passages.
The last stage bladed disk of a steam turbine is analyzed with respect to both flutter susceptibility and limitation of forced response. Due to the lack of variable stator vanes unfavorable flow conditions may occur which increases the risk of flutter at part load conditions. For this reason, intentional mistuning is employed with the objective to prevent any self-excited vibrations. A first step in this direction is done by choosing alternate mistuning, which keeps the manufactural efforts in limits. In this sense, two different series of blades have been made. However, small deviations from the design intention are unavoidable due to the manufacturing procedure, which could be proved by bonk tests carried out earlier. The influence of these additional deviations is considered in numerical simulations. Moreover, the strong dependence of blade frequencies on the speed is taken into account since centrifugal stiffening effects significantly attenuate the blade-to-blade frequency difference. Focusing on the first flap mode it could be shown that a mitigation of flutter susceptibility is achieved by prescribing alternate mistuning, which indeed evokes an increase of originally small aerodynamic damping ratios. Nevertheless, the occurrence of negative damping ratios could not be completely precluded at part load conditions. That is why optimization studies are conducted based on genetic algorithms with the objective function of maximizing the lowest aerodynamic damping ratios. Finally, mistuning patterns could be identified featuring a tremendous increase of aerodynamic damping ratios. The robustness of the solutions could be proved by superimposing additional random mistuning.
Radial turbine wheels are commonly designed as integrally bladed rotors featuring extremely low structural damping in comparison to separate designs of blades and disk. Consequently, they are more prone to vibration. Moreover, random blade mistuning due to unavoidable inaccuracies in manufacture or material inhomogeneities can severely increase the maximum forced blade vibration amplitude compared to the tuned counterpart. Unfortunately, this response magnification may worsen in case of small damping. Since modes exhibiting blade dominated vibration are usually considered vulnerable in this regard, the influence of disk and shaft and its mounting conditions seems to be negligible. In this paper, reduced order models are employed in order to simulate the forced response of a radial turbine wheel. Experimental modal analyses have been carried out to provide realistic damping ratios considering both the single turbine wheel hardware as well as the full rotor mounted in a turbocharger test rig. Test runs are conducted and non-intrusive blade-tip-timing technology provides measurement data to validate the simulation models. Contrary to the original presumption, it is shown that additional structural damping contributed by assembling can significantly influence the forced response even though the focus is on blade dominated vibration.
The manufacturing geometrical variability in axial compressors is a stochastic source of uncertainty, implying that the real geometry differs from the nominal design. This causes the real geometry to lose the ideal axial symmetry. Considering the aerofoils of a stator vane, the geometrical variability affects the flow traversing it. This impacts the downstream rotor, especially when considering the aeroelastic excitation forces. Optical surface scans coupled with a parametrisation method allow for acquiring the information relative to the real aerofoils geometries. The measured data are included in a multi-passage and multi-stage CFD setup to represent the mistuned flow. In particular, low excitation harmonics on the rotor vane are introduced due to the geometrical deviations of the upstream stator. The introduced low engine orders, as well as their amplitude, depend on the stator geometries and their order. A method is proposed to represent the phenomena in a reduced CFD domain, limiting the size and number of solutions required to probabilistically describe the rotor excitation forces. The resulting rotor excitation forces are reconstructed as a superposition of disturbances due to individual stator aerofoils geometries. This indicates that the problem is linear in the combination of disturbances from single passages.
Creating very detailed finite element models of aero-engines is a very time-consuming process especially if structured meshes have to be generated for thousands of parts. Isogeometric analysis offers the possibility of an accelerated model creation process while achieving higher accuracy by using the non-uniform rational B-spline functions used for the geometry description also as basis functions for the finite element analysis. In this case, no meshing is necessary anymore. Here, we demonstrate this process by applying a self-developed tool which creates a geometry description and a computational model of a part at the same time. By the help of this tool we build up a simplified mechanical aero-engine model, which is used for transient implicit computations simulating the acceleration process of the rotor. We discuss the results as well as the computational time of isogeometric models in comparison to classical finite element models.
This contribution investigates the implementation and verification of intentional mistuning (IM) to a radial turbine wheel of an exhaust turbocharger. In principle, inaccuracies in manufacture or material inhomogeneities may lead to random blade mistuning and thus localized modes with severely magnified blade vibrations can occur. With regard to axial compressors and turbines, IM has proved to be an efficient measure to mitigate the forced response. For radial turbine wheels, on the other hand, a successful implementation of IM into a wheel hardware has not yet been presented. This work aims at the design, implementation, and verification of successful IM considering both measurements at standstill and test runs on a turbocharger test rig.
The fundamental analyses have been carried out in part one [1] of this three-part paper in order to find a suitable IM-pattern featuring only two different blade designs. The AABB sequence was identified to be the most promising one in terms of mitigating the maximum forced response of the fundamental bending mode at the considered operating point. In concrete terms, a 40% attenuation of the maximum forced response was predicted by employing reduced order models.
The second part [2] discussed the detailed geometric adaption of the turbine wheel hardware focussing on the implementation and validation of the IM pattern under laboratory conditions (standstill). Part three is about validating the efficacy of IM under operating conditions. In that sense, the successful implementation of IM and thus the machining of the wheel hardware are investigated within the framework of test runs on a turbocharger test rig. Test runs are conducted for both a wheel with and a wheel without IM. Non-intrusive blade-tip-timing (BTT) technology is employed to record forced response data. A well-known approach to evaluate the raw data namely times of arrival (TOA) without the availability of a once-per-revolution (OPR) signal is adapted, implemented, and applied for the evaluation. The results are compared to those received by using a commercial evaluation software for BTT measurement data. Finally, the actual gain achieved by means of IM is discussed in detail.
The analysis of the structural dynamics of multistage cyclic structures as linked components is required to model the interstage coupling. In turbomachinery, this can result in a collaboration between different compressor or turbine stages. This paper investigates the coupling between two rear drum blade integrated disk stages of an axial compressor to support the mechanical design process.
Considering the vibration modeshapes of a multistage system, different components may co-participate in the dynamics. For this reason, a criteria to identify the modes affected by the coupling and to quantify this coupling is defined. This allows to distinguish between modes with inter-stage coupling, requiring the multistage system for their description, and uncoupled modes, involving a single stage. In addition, it is of interest to research methods to reduce the impact of the coupling on the vibrating system without drastically altering the geometry of the components.
The vibration analyses of a two-stage compressor generalized geometry, representative of a compressor rear drum blisk, is presented as a study case. The use of a reducing method allows to describe the behavior of the nominal multistage system with a computationally efficient technique, enabling a parametric analysis of the stages’ coupling. The investigation considers the effect of a set of geometrical and mechanical parameters on the dynamics, identifying the driving parameters of the coupled vibration characteristics.
Modal and Aeroelastic Analysis of a Mistuned Compressor Blisk Using an Equivalent Blisk Model
(2011)
Simulation and Investigation of an Intentionally Mistuned Blisk Rotor in a High Pressure Compressor
(2022)
In modern aircraft engines, blade integrated disk (blisk) is widely implemented. While blisk rotor design brings numerous advantages including weight reduction, aerodynamic efficiency improvement, and manufacturing simplification, its low mechanical damping due to the absence of friction between disk and blades makes the rotor more susceptible to vibration. Given that damage to blisk rotor sometimes requires the whole assembly to be replaced, effort has been made to alleviate the unexpected vibration amplitude within operating range, among which intentional mistuning is regarded as one of the commonly used technique. Mistuning refers to blade-to-blade deviation of mechanical properties, which is inevitable in practice due to manufacturing tolerances or wear. Through the application of intentional mistuning, it is expected that the amplitude of synchronous or nonsynchronous vibration (NSV) will be reduced without severely losing aerodynamic performance.
In this paper, the effect of intentional mistuning has been investigated for the blisk rotor of a 1.5-stage transonic research compressor at Technical University of Darmstadt. According to the previous test campaign, the baseline rotor has shown its susceptibility to NSV due to first torsion mode in the near stall region. The rotor was then intentionally mistuned. Subsequent tests have proven a successful suppression of flutter problem. In order to have a comprehensive understanding of the effect of the applied mistuning pattern, simulations are performed using a FVM based CFD solver to produce comparable results as shown in the test campaign. In the simulation, mistuned systems are modelled in comparison with the nominal tuned reference. Geometrical disturbance and frequency disturbance are introduced to the tuned model first separately and then simultaneously. In this way, contribution of aerodynamic and structural mistuning to the suppression of NSV is identified based on the CFD results. Later, system eigenvalues of the mistuned aeromechanical model are determined by making use of the blade individual response in time domain. The obtained results are compared with mistuned eigenvalues calculated by a reduced order model (ROM), which utilizes the idea of subset of nominal modes (SNM). This makes it possible to demonstrate the feasibility of using SNM to carry out stability analysis when designing mistuning pattern for vibration of NSV type. It also allows a compare between the linear structural model of the SNM and the non-linear aeromechanic model of the CFD solver on capturing the non-linear nature of the flow, especially in the context of NSV.
Application of Intentional Mistuning to Reduce the Vibration Susceptibility of a Steam Turbine Wheel
(2022)
Intentional mistuning (IM) is employed on a last stage turbine wheel to alleviate both the flutter susceptibility and maximum forced response. Primarily, operations at nominal speed under part-load conditions may cause unfavorable flow conditions facilitating flow separation. As a consequence, the original design intention with identical blades features negative aerodynamic damping ratios with respect to the first bending mode family. In order to prevent any self-excited vibration phenomena, intentional alternate mistuning is utilized to increase the least aerodynamic damping ratio as far as it takes a positive value and hence, to contribute to a stabilization of the rotor. For the purpose of numerically analyzing the vibration behavior, reduced order models are built up, which are based on modal reduction techniques, namely the subset of nominal system modes (SNM) [1] and the fundamental mistuning model (FMM) [2]. These types of models conveniently allow for considering both, different mistuning distributions in terms of probabilistic analyses and the aeroelastic interaction by means of prescribing aerodynamic damping ratios and aeroelastic natural frequencies of the tuned counterpart or aerodynamic influence coefficients, respectively. A detailed study is presented regarding the correction of frequency mistuning magnitudes in terms of considering the impact of centrifugal stiffening, which plays a significant role in case of long low pressure turbine blades featuring high aspect ratios.
Since alternate IM cannot be implemented perfectly, every bladed wheel as manufactured will exhibit small but unavoidable structural deviations from the design intention, which are known as random mistuning. To ensure the robustness of the IM solution in terms of positive aerodynamic damping ratios at any time, comprehensive probabilistic analyses are conducted with respect to superimposing random structural mistuning at first. Secondly, the impact of varying mistuning magnitude is analyzed. Thirdly, the robustness towards aerodynamic mistuning is investigated by means of small variations of aeroelastic influence coefficients and consequently, the inter blade phase angle dependent aerodynamic damping curves. Moreover, it becomes apparent that alternate IM superimposed with both, random structural and aerodynamic mistuning also mitigates the maximum forced response at part-speed conditions.
Radial turbine wheels of exhaust gas turbochargers are permanently exposed to centrifugal, thermal, and aerodynamic loading. However, since these wheels are commonly designed as integral structures featuring relatively little mechanical damping, they are prone to the impact of unavoidable structural random mistuning, which may evoke severe magnifications of the forced response. Nonetheless, the safe operation of turbochargers has to be ensured at any time so that the contribution of aerodynamic damping is of particular importance. Moreover, the application of intentional mistuning is known to be a suitable measure to limit or even reduce the forced response by means of increasing the resulting aerodynamic damping.
In this paper, two turbine wheels of the same type are considered, one manufactured with and another one without intentional mistuning. Experimental determinations of the mistuning patterns actually reveal deviations from the design intentions, which are considered in updated numerical models. Forced response simulations demonstrate that the targeted response reduction affected by intentional mistuning is achieved anyhow. Furthermore, the general robustness of the solution is proved with respect to the maximum forced response by means of comprehensive probabilistic numerical analyses addressing the impact of additional random structural mistuning, the magnitude of intentional mistuning, and aerodynamic mistuning.
Grundlegende Untersuchungen zum Schwingungsverhalten von Verdichterlaufrädern in Integralbauweise
(2009)
The manufacturing geometrical variability is a source of uncertainty, which cannot be avoided in the realization of machinery components. Deviations of a part geometry from its nominal design are inevitably present due to the manufacturing process. In the case of the aeroelastic forced response problem within axial compressors, these uncertainties may affect the vibration characteristics. For this reason, the impact of geometrical uncertainties due to the manufacturing process onto the modal forcing of axial compressor blades is investigated in this study. The research focuses on the vibrational behavior of an axial compressor rotor blisk. In particular, the amplitude of the forces acting as a source of excitation on the vibrating blades is studied. The geometrical variability of the upstream stator is investigated as input uncertainty. The variability is modeled starting from a series of optical surface scans. A stochastic model is created to represent the measured manufacturing geometrical deviations from the nominal model. A data reduction methodology is proposed in order to represent the uncertainty with a minimal set of variables. The manufacturing geometrical variability model allows to represent the input uncertainty and probabilistically evaluate its impact on the aeroelastic problem. An uncertainty quantification is performed in order to evaluate the resulting variability on the modal forcing acting on the vibrating rotor blades. Of particular interest is the possible rise of low engine orders due to the mistuned flow field along the annulus. A reconstruction algorithm allows the representation of the variability during one rotor revolution. The uncertainty on low harmonics of the modal rotor forcing can be therefore identified and quantified.
This study is centered on the aeroelastic problem for axial compressors blisk airfoils in presence of geometrical uncertainties. The combined problem of structural dynamics and unsteady aerodynamics is of interest for these machines due to the stress induced by the blades vibration. In this field, deviations from the nominal cyclic symmetry (in geometry, material or fluid properties) are generally referred to as mistuning. In particular, the geometrical mistuning is addressed resulting from the manufacturing process of blisk airfoils. The impact of these uncertainties on the aeroelastic problem is evaluated, focusing on the aerodynamic damping.
The analysis of the manufacturing geometrical variability is approached in a probabilistic manner. A model representing the uncertainty is created starting from a dataset of optical surface scans. The measured geometries are parameterized in order to numerically describe the differences from the nominal geometry with a set of variables. The creation of a mean geometry of the measured blades allows to simplify the description of the uncertainty, which can be then modelled describing the distributions of geometrical deviations over the blade height. In order to create a stochastic model for the geometrical uncertainty, a data reduction method is implemented in the model. This aims to describe the variability within a minimum required accuracy while using a minimal set of variables. For this purpose, an Autoencoder is used to define a compressed representation of the dataset of interest. The method is based on the training of a Neural-Network, which tries to represent the identity function for the given data while forcing a variables reduction in the intermediate layers. A regularization method for the reduced variables is also introduced in order to avoid correlations and normalize the distributions.
The computation of the aerodynamic damping is performed using a CFD solver. A steady-state representation of the investigated axial compressor rig is validated using available experimental data. The unsteady computations are done for one configuration at one shaft speed, which is representative of two relevant crossings in the Campbell diagram for the studied blisk. This indicates resonance conditions for two vibrational mode shapes of the component. The Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients (AIC) method is used to calculate the aerodynamic damping curve for the two vibrational mode shapes of interest. This allows to obtain the damping values over the different inter-blade phase angles with one single solution per mode shape, while reducing the domain to a sub-assembly of the investigated blisk. The Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) uses the implemented geometrical variability model and the defined solution method for the calculation of the aerodynamic damping. To describe the input uncertainty (manufacturing geometrical variability) the space of the variables resulting from the Autoencoder data reduction is used. A sampling is generated, representing with each sample a set of three mistuned blades. For each sample, the three resulting blade surfaces are inserted in the AIC setup, representing the vibrating blade as well as the relative direct upstream and downstream blades. This allows to evaluate the uncertainty on the amplitude and phase of the influence coefficients relative to the three blades and finally on the aerodynamic damping curve.
The data reduction provided by the Autoencoder proved to be very efficient, especially if compared to linear methods as the principal components analysis. This allowed to include in the UQ multi-passage variations for a better representation of a real geometry. The output uncertainty on the aerodynamic damping could therefore be evaluated taking these effects in consideration. The results can be combined in an aeroelastic reduced order model with the mistuning of the mechanical properties of the component to represent the mistuned blades vibrations.
A last stage steam turbine wheel is analyzed with the objective to alleviate the flutter susceptibility by employing intentional mistuning (IM). In particular, the operation at nominal speed under part-load conditions may cause unfavorable flow conditions facilitating flow separation. In consequence, negative aerodynamic damping ratios occur for the first bending mode family in some circumstances. Employing intended alternate mistuning of adequate magnitude has proved to be a promising measure to stabilize rotors in terms of avoiding self-excited vibration phenomena. From the manufacturing point of view, this two-blade design is advantageous as well and hence, chosen here as a first measure to attenuate flutter susceptibility. Two prototypes of bladed disks series have been made, which are exhibiting small but unavoidable deviations from the design intention due to manufacturing. The real blade alone frequencies have been identified within foregoing experimental investigations. Numerical modal analyses carried out for the prototypes as manufactured finally reveal that there is an additional positive contribution of random mistuning in terms of further enhancing the least aerodynamic damping ratio. Another promising and robust IM pattern is found by using generic algorithms to optimize the least aerodynamic damping ratio yielding stable conditions at any time as well. Moreover, it shows that IM combined with random mistuning also mitigates the maximum forced response at part-speed conditions.
The manufacturing geometrical variability is a source of uncertainty, which cannot be avoided in the realization of a machinery. Deviations of a component geometry from its nominal design are inevitably present due to the manufacturing process. In the case of the aeroelastic forced response problem within axial compressors, these uncertainties may affect the vibration characteristics. For this reason, the impact of geometrical uncertainties due to the manufacturing process onto the modal forcing of axial compressor blades is investigated in this study.
The research focuses on the vibrational behavior of an axial compressor rotor blisk (blade-integrated disk) and in particular the amplitude of the forces acting as source of excitation on the vibrating blades (modal forcing). Within this context, the geometry of the upstream stator plays an important role as in general the main harmonics of the rotor excitation forces are produced by its wake. Therefore, small variations of the upstream stators geometries, such as the ones caused by the manufacturing process, may affect the resulting forcing. In particular, the geometrical variability of the upstream stator implies that the hypothesis of a cyclic-symmetrical flow is no longer valid. This may cause the introduction of lower harmonic components in the modal forces, generally referred to as Low Engine Orders (LEO).
The geometrical variability is modelled starting from a series of optical surface scans. A set of optical measurements of manufactured stator blades originating from the same nominal design constitutes the baseline dataset on which the geometrical model is built. The measured blades as well as the relative nominal geometry are parametrized to describe the individual blades surfaces. The parameterization is accomplished by slicing the surfaces in radial sections and describing each of these with a set of NACA-like parameters [1]. The measured geometrical deviations from the nominal model can therefore be described as an offset of such parameters. A reduced representation of the variables representing the input uncertainty (noise variables) is obtained via Principal Components Analysis. Afterwards a sampling on the reduced noise variables domain can be done to represent the modelled uncertainty and perform an Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) on the relative quantities of interest, in this case the modal forcing.
The computation of the modal forcing is done through a CFD solver, computing the unsteady flow field around the rotor blades. The domain considered in this case is a 1.5 stage of the axial compressor, including the rotor and the up- and down-stream stators. The solutions are initialized from a validated steady state solution of the considered compressor rig. The time-dependent pressure field calculated on the rotor blades is projected onto the relative vibrational mode shapes of interests (from structural modal analyzes). The resulting forces are analyzed by means of their spectrum, evaluating the amplitudes for the present engine orders (higher harmonics of the shaft mechanical speed).
The UQ uses Monte Carlo methods to evaluate the impact of the geometrical variability onto the modal forcing. The modelled uncertainty on the geometries is introduced into the CFD solver to compute the deviations on the quantities of interest. A reconstruction of the forces acting on the rotor during one revolution is obtained. This allows to evaluate the uncertainty on the present engine orders as well as the possible rise of LEO for the rotor blades in presence of a mistuned upstream stator.
[1]: Lange A., Vogeler K., Gümmer V., Schrapp H. and Clemen C. (2009). “Introduction of a Parameter Based Compressor Blade Model for Considering Measured Geometry Uncertainties in Numerical Simulation.” Proceedings of ASME Turbo Expo. GT2009-59937
Moderne Verbrennungskraftmaschinen müssen ein stetig wachsendes Anforderungsprofil in Bezug auf Wirtschaftlichkeit, Leistung und Umweltfreundlichkeit erfüllen. In diesem Zusammenhang hat die Turboaufladung von Verbrennungsmotoren an Bedeutung gewonnen. Bei Turboladern kleiner und mittlerer Baugröße, deren Turbinen einen Durchmesser zwischen 30 und 250 mm aufweisen, kommen vornehmlich gegossene Laufräder zum Einsatz. Am Institut für Verkehrstechnik der Brandenburgischen Technischen Universität Cottbus-Senftenberg wurde im Rahmen eines FVV-Forschungsvorhabens der Einfluss charakteristischer Betriebsgrößen eines Turboladers auf das strukturdynamische Verhalten solcher Radialturbinenräder untersucht.
The last stage bladed disk of a steam turbine is analyzed with respect to both flutter susceptibility and limitation of forced response. Due to the lack of variable stator vanes unfavorable flow conditions may occur which can lead to flow separation in some circumstances. Consequently, there is the risk of flutter in principle, particularly at nominal speed under part load conditions. For this reason, intentional mistuning is employed by the manufacturer with the objective to prevent any self-excited vibrations. A first step in this direction is done by choosing alternate mistuning, which keeps the manufactural efforts in limits since only two different blade designs are allowed. In this sense, two different series of blades have been made. However, it is well known that small deviations from the design intention are unavoidable due to the manufacturing procedure, which could be proved by bonk tests carried out earlier. The influence of these additional but unwanted deviations is considered in numerical simulations. Moreover, the strong dependence of blade frequencies on the speed is taken into account since it significantly attenuates the blade to blade frequency difference in this particular case.
Within an academic study the turbine wheel is modelled as blade integrated disk in order to demonstrate fundamental effects of intentional mistuning on flutter susceptibility and forced response. For that purpose, reduced order models are built up by using the subset of nominal system mode approach introduced by Yang and Griffin [1], which conveniently allows for taking into account both differing mistuning patterns and the impact of aeroelastic interaction. Focusing on the first flap mode it could be shown that a mitigation of flutter susceptibility is achieved by prescribing alternate mistuning, which indeed affects an increase of originally small aerodynamic damping ratios. Nevertheless, the occurrence of negative damping ratios could not be completely precluded at part load conditions. That is why optimization studies are conducted based on genetic algorithms with the objective function of maximizing the lowest aerodynamic damping ratios. Again only two different blade designs are admitted. Finally, mistuning patterns could be identified causing a tremendous increase of aerodynamic damping ratios. The robustness of the solutions found could be proved by superimposing additional random mistuning. Another study is focused on the impact of mistuning strength.
Further analyses are addressing the forced response at part speed conditions, where different resonance crossings are becoming apparent in the Campbell plot. An increase of the forced response compared to the tuned counterpart is partly unpreventable because of unfavorable aerodynamic damping curves. Independently, the maximum forced response has to be limited also in case of applying large intentional mistuning.
[1] Yang, M. T., Griffin, J. H., „A Reduced-Order model of Mistuning Using a Subset of Nominal System Modes“. J Eng Gas Turb Power, 123, pp. 893-900 (2001).
This paper aims at contributing to a better understanding of the effect of Tyler–Sofrin Modes (TSMs) on forced vibration responses by analysing a 4.5-stage research axial compressor rig. The first part starts with a brief review of the involved physical mechanisms and necessary prerequisites for the generation of TSMs in multistage engines. This review is supported by unsteady CFD simulations of a quasi 2D section of the studied engine. It is shown that the amplitude increasing effect due to mistuning can be further amplified by the presence of TSMs. Furthermore, the sensitivity with respect to the structural coupling of the blades and the damping as well as the shape of the expected envelope is analysed.
The second part deals with the Rotor 2 blisk of the research compressor rig. The resonance of a higher blade mode with the engine order of the upstream stator is studied in two different flow conditions realised by different variable stator vane (VSV) schedules which allows to separate the influence of TSMs from the impact of mistuning. A subset of nominal system modes representation of the rotor is used to describe its mistuned vibration behaviour, and unsteady CFD simulations are used to characterise the present strength of the TSMs in the particular operating conditions. Measured maximum amplitude vs blade pattern and frequency response functions are compared against the predictions of the aeromechanical models in order to assess the strength of the TSMs as well as its influence on vibration levels.
In order to prepare an advanced 4-stage high-pressure compressor rig test campaign, details regarding both accomplishment and analysis of preliminary experiments are provided in this paper. The superior objective of the research project is to contribute to a reliable but simultaneously less conservative design of future high pressure blade integrated disks (blisk). It is planned to achieve trend-setting advances based on a close combination of both numerical and experimental analyses. The analyses are focused on the second rotor of this research compressor, which is the only one being manufactured as blisk. The comprehensive test program is addressing both surge and forced response analyses e.g. caused by low engine order excitation. Among others the interaction of aeroelastics and blade mistuning is demanding attention in this regard. That is why structural models are needed, allowing for an accurate forced response prediction close to reality. Furthermore, these models are required to support the assessment of blade tip timing (BTT) data gathered in the rig tests and strain gauge (s/g) data as well. To gain the maximum information regarding the correlation between BTT data, s/g-data and pressure gauge data, every blade of the second stage rotor (28 blades) is applied with s/g. However, it is well known that s/g on blades can contribute additional mistuning that had to be considered upon updating structural models.
Due to the relevance of mistuning, efforts are made for its accurate experimental determination. Blade-by-blade impact tests according to a patented approach are used for this purpose. From the research point of view, it is most interesting to determine both the effect s/g-instrumentation and assembling the compressor stages on blade frequency mistuning. That is why experimental mistuning tests carried out immediately after manufacturing the blisk are repeated twice, namely, after s/g instrumentation and after assembling. To complete the pre-test program, the pure mechanical damping and modal damping ratios dependent on the ambient pressure are experimentally determined inside a pressure vessel. Subsequently the mistuning data gained before is used for updating subset of nominal system mode (SNM) models. Aerodynamic influence coefficients (AICs) are implemented to take aeroelastic interaction into account for forced response analyses. Within a comparison of different models, it is shown for the fundamental flap mode (1F) that the s/g instrumentation significantly affects the forced response, whereas the impact of assembling the compressor plays a minor role.
A novel approach for the identification of tuned aerodynamic damping, system frequencies, forcing and mistuning has been introduced in the first part of this paper. It is based on the forced response equations of motion for a blade dominated mode family. A least squares formulation allows to identify the system’s parameters directly from measured frequency response functions (FRFs) of all blades recorded during a sweep through a resonance. The second part has dealt with its modification and application to experimental modal analyses of blisks at rest.
This 3rd part aims at presenting the application of the approach to blade tip timing (BTT) data acquired in rig tests. Therefore, blisk rotors of two different engines are studied: a single stage fan rig and a 4.5 stage high pressure compressor (HPC) rig. The rig test campaign of the fan blisk included also an intentional mistuning experiment that allows to study the performance of the identification approach for a similar rotor with two different mistuning levels. It is demonstrated that the approach can identify aerodynamic damping curves, system frequencies, mistuning pattern and forced travelling wave modes (TWMs) from state of the art BTT data monitored during rig or engine tests. All derived mistuning patterns could be verified with reference measurements at standstill. The derived aerodynamic damping curves and system frequencies show a reasonable agreement with simulations. For the HPC case a multitude of excited TWMs could be identified which also lines up with previous simulations.
An axial turbine blisk for turbocharger applications is analyzed with respect to the effect of intentional mistuning on the forced response. Originally, the intentional mistuning pattern has been designed by employing a genetic algorithm optimization in order to reduce the forced response caused by low engine order excitation (LEO) of the fundamental flap mode. The solution found has been implemented in a prototype of that blisk. For the purpose of comparison, a second reference blisk has been manufactured without intentional mistuning. The actual mistuning distributions of the blisks have been identified by employing blade-by-blade impact testing. Alternatively, a new inverse approach has been employed, which is based on a least squares formulation and benefits from less experimental effort. Based on the information gained by the aforementioned testing procedures, subset of nominal systems (SNM)-models have been updated, which allow for considering the aeroelastic coupling by means of aerodynamic influence coefficients (AIC). Despite of small but unavoidable deviations from the design intention it could be proved within numerical simulations that the intended 70 per cent reduction of the maximum forced response is nevertheless achieved.
In addition, the paper is addressing the effect of the aforementioned intentional mistuning pattern on a higher mode, which is relevant for the durability as well. Hence, new SNM-models have to be updated in order to calculate the forced response due to EO-excitation caused by the nozzle guide vane. Although the original mistuning pattern has been optimized solely for reducing the forced response of the fundamental flap mode, it hardly affects the higher mode forced response in a negative manner.
Turbocharging is known to be a well-established technology for an engine's efficiency and power output by forcing extra compressed air into the combustion chamber. The centrifugal loads, necessary flow deflections, unsteady pressure fluctuations, and structural temperature gradients put a high strain on rotating components. Additionally, those components are prone to high-cycle fatigue. The Chair of Structural Mechanics and Vehicle Vibrational Technology at the BTU Cottbus-Senftenberg investigated the impact of manufacturing tolerances on the vibrational behavior of several turbine and compressor impellers. Finally, it is shown that intentional mistuning can lead to significantly lower stresses.
Secure Power for Jet Engines
(2006)
Recent demands for a reduction of specific fuel consumption of jet engines have been opposed by increasing propulsive efficiency with higher bypass ratios and increased engine sizes. At the same time the challenge for the engine development is to design safe and efficient fan blades of high aspect ratios. Since the fan is the very first rotor stage, it experiences significant distortions in the incoming flow depending on the operating conditions. Flow distortions do not only lead to a performance and stall margin loss but also to remarkable low engine order (LEO) excitation responsible for forced vibrations of fundamental modes. Additionally, fans of jet engines typically suffer from stall flutter, which can be additionally amplified by reflections of acoustic pressure waves at the intake. Stall flutter appears before approaching the stall line on the fan’s characteristic and limits its stable operating range. Despite the fact that this “flutter bite” usually affects only a very narrow speed range, it reduces the overall margin of safe operation significantly. With increasing aspect ratios of ultra-high bypass ratio jet engines the flutter susceptibility will probably increase further and emphasizes the importance of considering aeromechanical analyses early in the design phase of future fans. This paper aims at proving that intentional mistuning is able to remove the flutter bite of modern jet engine fans without raising issues due to heavily increased forced vibrations induced by LEO excitation. Whereas intentional mistuning is an established technology in mitigating flutter, it is also known to amplify the forced response. However, recent investigations considering aeroelastic coupling revealed that under specific circumstances mistuning can also reduce the forced response due to engine order excitation. In order to allow a direct comparison and to limit costs as well as effort at the same time, the intentional mistuning is introduced in a non-destructive way by applying heavy paint to the blades. Its impact on the blade’s natural frequencies is estimated via finite element models with an additional paint layer. In parallel, this procedure is experimentally verified with painted fan blades in the laboratory. A validated SNM (subset of nominal system modes) representation of the fan is used as a computational model to characterize its mistuned vibration behavior. Its validation is done by comparing mistuned mode shape envelopes and frequencies of an experimental modal analysis at rest with those obtained by the updated computational model. In order to find a mistuning pattern minimizing the forced response of mode 1 and 2 at the same time and satisfying stability and imbalance constraints, a multi-objective optimization has been carried out. Finally, the beneficial properties of the optimized mistuning pattern are verified in a rig test of the painted rotor.
Copyright © 2017 by Rolls-Royce Deutschland Ltd & Co KG
The potential of intentional mistuning to reduce the maximum forced response is analyzed within the development of an axial turbine blisk for ship diesel engine turbocharger applications. The basic idea of the approach is to provide an increased aerodynamic damping level for particular engine order excitations and mode shapes without any significant distortions of the aerodynamic performance. The mistuning pattern intended to yield a mitigation of the forced response is derived from an optimization study applying genetic algorithms. Two blisk prototypes have been manufactured a first one with and another one without employing intentional mistuning. Hence, the differences regarding the real mistuning and other modal properties can be experimentally determined and evaluated as well. In addition, the experimental data basis allows for updating structural models which are well suited to compute the forced response under operational conditions. In this way, the real benefit achieved with the application of intentional mistuning is demonstrated.
Copyright © 2017 by ASME
Due to increasing requirements of future engine projects, much effort has been spent on the design of more efficient turbomachinery blades in the recent years. Besides aerodynamic efficiency constraints, these designs need to meet structural criteria ensuring that they are safe and robust with respect to High Cycle Fatigue (HCF). The estimation of the resonant vibration amplitude is done based on the aerodynamic force and the overall damping level. Since, for many applications the contribution of mechanical damping is often rather low compared to the aerodynamic counterpart, the determination of the aerodynamic damping is vital for the estimation of the forced vibration response. This second part is meant to contribute to a simplified computation of the aerodynamic damping during operation by making additional assumptions: The investigated mode family shall not suffer from flutter, has a high reduced frequency and the influence of adjacent blades is negligible. Under these circumstances a simplified approach can be introduced that allows for the computation of the mean value of the aerodynamic damping based on a steady state CFD solution of the regarded stage. It is well known, that the aerodynamic damping of a blade mode family depends on the inter blade phase angle (IBPA) and its direction of propagation, which is not covered by the simplified approach. For higher modes the difference between the minimum and maximum damping is often low and the mean value is a good approximation, whereas for fundamental modes there is often a significant difference. However, it is shown that considering a mistuned vibration response of the rotor, the expected value of the mistuned damping exhibits the mean value of IBPA-dependent aerodynamic damping. CFD simulations of an oscillating airfoil indicate a certain validity range of the simplified approach based on a modified reduced frequency and inlet Mach number, which allows to determine for which industrial applications the approach is most suitable. Finally, this range of validity is verified with experimentally determined overall damping values from strain gauge measurements during operation for 2 different industrial applications, an axial compressor stage of a jet engine and a radial turbine stage of a turbocharger.
Copyright © 2016 by Rolls-Royce Deutschland Ltd & Co KG