TY - GEN A1 - Khosh Bin Ghomash, Shahin A1 - Bachmann, Daniel A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Impact of Rainfall Movement on Flash Flood Response: A Synthetic Study of a Semi-Arid Mountainous Catchment T2 - Water N2 - Rainfall is a spatiotemporally varied process and key to accurately capturing catchment runoff and determining flood response. Flash flood response of a catchment can be strongly governed by a rainfall’s spatiotemporal variability and is influenced by storm movement which drives a continuous spatiotemporal change throughout a rainfall event. In this work, the sensitivity of runoff and flooded areas to rainfall movement are assessed in the Kan catchment (Iran). The allochthonous nature of floods in the catchment and how they interact with the effects of rainfall movement are investigated. Fifty synthetic rain hyetographs are generated and traversed over the catchment under different velocities and directions and used to force a 1D/2D hydrodynamic model. The results suggest rainfall movement affects the runoff response in different degrees. Peak discharge, hydrograph shapes and flooded areas are affected. Storms with higher velocities result in higher peaks and faster onsets of runoff and consequently higher flooded areas in comparison to slower storms. The direction of the movement also plays a role. Storms moving along the average direction of the stream result in higher peaks and flooded areas. The relevance of storm direction is greater for slow moving storms. Additionally, the influence of rainfall movement is modulated by hyetograph structure, and the allochthonous behavior is greatly dependent on the location within the drainage network at which it is assessed. KW - storm movement KW - rainfall/runoff simulation KW - runoff generation KW - flash-flood KW - rainfall variability Y1 - 2022 UR - https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/14/12/1844 U6 - https://doi.org/10.3390/w14121844 SN - 2073-4441 VL - 14 IS - 12 ER - TY - GEN A1 - Khosh Bin Ghomash, Shahin A1 - Bachmann, Daniel A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Storm movement effects on the flash flood response of the Kan catchment T2 - EGU General Assembly 2022, Vienna, Austria, 23–27 May 2022 N2 - Rainfall is a complex, spatial and temporally variated process and one of the core inputs for hydrological and hydrodynamic modelling. Most rainfalls are known to be moving storms with varying directions and velocities. Storm movement is known to be an important influence on runoff generation, both affecting peak discharge and the shape of hydrographs. Therefore, exploring the extent rainfall dynamics affect runoff generation and consequently flooded areas, can be an asset in effective flood risk management. In this work, we study how storm movement (e.g. characterized by velocity and direction) can affect surface flow generation, water levels and flooded areas within a catchment. Moreover, the influence of rainfall temporal variability in correlation with storm movement is taken into account. This is achieved by means of numerical-based, spatially explicit surface flow simulations using the tool ProMaIDes (2021), a free software for risk-based evaluation of flood risk mitigation measures. The storm events are generated using a microcanonical random cascade model and further on trajected across the catchment area. The study area is the Kan river catchment located in the province of Tehran (Iran) with a total area of 836 km², which has experienced multiple flooding events in recent years. Due to its semi-arid climate, steep topography with narrow valleys, this area has high potential for flash flood occurrence as a result of high intensity precipitation. The results of this study show a range of possible magnitudes of influence of rainfall movement on the catchment´s runoff response. The resulting flood maps highlight the importance of rainfall velocity and most importantly the direction of the movement in the estimation of flood events as well as their likelihood in catchment area. Moreover, its shown that the magnitude of influence of storm velocity and direction on discharge strongly depends on the location within the river network which it is measured. Y1 - 2022 U6 - https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu22-2494 ER - TY - GEN A1 - Khosh Bin Ghomash, Shahin A1 - Bachmann, Daniel A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Effects ofWithin-Storm Variability on Allochthonous Flash Flooding: A Synthetic Study T2 - Water N2 - Rainfall is a spatiotemporally variated process and one of the key elements to accurately capture both catchment runoff response and floodplain extents. Flash floods are the result of intense rainfall, typically associated to highly variable rain in both space and time, such as convective storms. In this work, the extent within-storm variability affects runoff and flooding is explored. The Kan catchment (Tehran, Iran) is used as base topography for the simulations. The allochthonous nature of floods in the catchment and how they interact with the effects of storm variability are further investigated. For this, 300 synthetic rainfall signals with different hyetograph variabilities are generated and imposed on a 1D/2D hydrodynamic model. Additionally, a set of simulations with different levels of spatial variability are performed. The results suggest that temporal and spatial variability affect the runoff response in different degrees. Peak discharge and hydrograph shapes, as well as flooded areas, are affected. The effect of storm temporal variability is shown to be significantly higher than storm spatial variability and storm properties such as return period, duration, and volume. Further on the influence of storm spatiotemporal variability on stream discharge and flood response is seen to be strongly dependent on the location within the drainage network at which it is assessed. KW - flash flood KW - rainfall variability KW - rainfall/runoff simulation KW - runoff generation Y1 - 2023 U6 - https://doi.org/10.3390/w15040645 SN - 2073-4441 VL - 15 IS - 4 ER - TY - GEN A1 - Khosh Bin Ghomash, Shahin A1 - Bachmann, Daniel A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Introducing a dynamic spatiotemporal rainfall generator for flood risk analysis T2 - EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 24–28 Apr 2023 N2 - Precipitation scenario analysis is a crucial step in flood risk assessment, in which storm events with different probabilities are defined and used as input for the hydrological/hydrodynamic calculations. Rainfall generators may serve as a basis for the precipitation analysis. With the increase in the use of high resolution spatially-explicit hydrological/hydrodynamic models in flood risk calculations, demand for synthetic gridded precipitation input is increasing. In this work, we present a dynamic spatiotemporal rainfall generator. The model is capable of generating catchment-scale rainfields containing moving storms, which enable physically-plausible and spatiotemporally coherent precipitation events. This is achieved by the tools event-based approach, where dynamic storms are identified as clusters of related data that occur at different locations in space and time, and are then used as basis for event regeneration. The implemented methodology, mainly inspired by Dierden et al. (2019), provides an improvement in the spatial coherence of precipitation extremes, which can in turn be beneficial in flood risk calculations. The model has been validated under different databases such as the radar-based RADALON dataset or spatially-interpolated historical raingauge timeseries of different catchments in Germany, which is also presented in this work. The validation indicates the models ability to adequately preserve observed storm statistics in the generated timeseries. The generator is developed as an extension to the state-of-the-science flood risk modelling tool ProMaIDes (Promaides 2023). The model also puts great focus on user accessibility with offering features such as an easy installation process, support for most operating systems, a user interface and an online user manual. Y1 - 2023 UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU23/EGU23-2599.html UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU23/EGU23-2599.html?pdf U6 - https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-2599 ER - TY - GEN A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - García-Navarro, Pilar T1 - Rainfall/runoff simulation with 2D full shallow water equations: Sensitivity analysis and calibration of infiltration parameters T2 - Journal of Hydrology N2 - One of the most difficult issues in the development of hydrologic models is to find a rigorous source of data and specific parameters to a given problem, on a given location that enable reliable calibration. In this paper, a distributed and physically based model (2D Shallow Water Equations) is used for surface flow and runoff calculations in combination with two infiltration laws (Horton and Green–Ampt) for estimating infiltration in a watershed. This technique offers the capability of assigning a local and timedependent infiltration rate to each computational cell depending on the available surface water, soil type or vegetation. We investigate how the calibration of parameters is affected by transient distributed Shallow Water model and the complexity of the problem. In the first part of this work, we calibrate the infiltration parameters for both Horton and Green–Ampt models under flat ponded soil conditions. Then, by means of synthetic test cases, we perform a space-distributed sensitivity analysis in order to show that this calibration can be significantly affected by the introduction of topography or rainfall. In the second part, parameter calibration for a real catchment is addressed by comparing the numerical simulations with two different sets of experimental data, corresponding to very different events in terms of the rainfall volume. We show that the initial conditions of the catchment and the rainfall pattern have a special relevance in the quality of the adjustment. Hence, it is shown that the topography of the catchment and the storm characteristics affect the calibration of infiltration parameters. KW - Finite volumes KW - Shallow-water equations KW - Hydrologic modeling KW - Infiltration models KW - Rain-runoff generation Y1 - 2016 UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2016.03.021 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2016.03.021 SN - 0022-1694 VL - 536 SP - 496 EP - 513 ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Jozefik, Zoltan A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Towards a physically-based multi-scale ecohydrological simulator for semi-arid regions T2 - European Geosciences Union General Assembly 2017 Vienna, Austria, 23–28 April 2017 N2 - The use of numerical models as tools for describing and understanding complex ecohydrological systems has enabled to test hypothesis and propose fundamental, process-based explanations of the system system behaviour as a whole as well as its internal dynamics. Reaction-diffusion equations have been used to describe and generate organized pattern such as bands, spots, and labyrinths using simple feedback mechanisms and boundary conditions. Alternatively, pattern-matching cellular automaton models have been used to generate vegetation self-organization in arid and semi-arid regions also using simple description of surface hydrological processes. A key question is: How much physical realism is needed in order to adequately capture the pattern formation processes in semi-arid regions while reliably representing the water balance dynamics at the relevant time scales? In fact, redistribution of water by surface runoff at the hillslope scale occurs at temporal resolution of minutes while the vegetation development requires much lower temporal resolution and longer times spans. This generates a fundamental spatio-temporal multi-scale problem to be solved, for which high resolution rainfall and surface topography are required. Accordingly, the objective of this contribution is to provide proof-of-concept that governing processes can be described numerically at those multiple scales. The requirements for a simulating ecohydrological processes and pattern formation with increased physical realism are, amongst others: i. high resolution rainfall that adequately captures the triggers of growth as vegetation dynamics of arid regions respond as pulsed systems. ii. complex, natural topography in order to accurately model drainage patterns, as surface water redistribution is highly sensitive to topographic features. iii. microtopography and hydraulic roughness, as small scale variations do impact on large scale hillslope behaviour iv. moisture dependent infiltration as temporal dynamics of infiltration affects water storage under vegetation and in bare soil Despite the volume of research in this field, fundamental limitations still exist in the models regarding the aforementioned issues. Topography and hydrodynamics have been strongly simplified. Infiltration has been modelled as dependent on depth but independent of soil moisture. Temporal rainfall variability has only been addressed for seasonal rain. Spatial heterogenity of the topography as well as roughness and infiltration properties, has not been fully and explicitly represented. We hypothesize that physical processes must be robustly modelled and the drivers of complexity must be present with as much resolution as possible in order to provide the necessary realism to improve transient simulations, perhaps leading the way to virtual laboratories and, arguably, predictive tools. This work provides a first approach into a model with explicit hydrological processes represented by physicallybased hydrodynamic models, coupled with well-accepted vegetation models. The model aims to enable new possibilities relating to spatiotemporal variability, arbitrary topography and representation of spatial heterogeneity, including sub-daily (in fact, arbitrary) temporal variability of rain as the main forcing of the model, explicit representation of infiltration processes, and various feedback mechanisms between the hydrodynamics and the vegetation. Preliminary testing strongly suggests that the model is viable, has the potential of producing new information of internal dynamics of the system, and allows to successfully aggregate many of the sources of complexity. Initial benchmarking of the model also reveals strengths to be exploited, thus providing an interesting research outlook, as well as weaknesses to be addressed in the immediate future. Y1 - 2017 UR - http://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2017/EGU2017-14851.pdf N1 - EGU2017-14851 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Domin, Andrea A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Nonlinear effects of microtopography on macroscopic rainfall-runoff partitioning a the hillslope scale: a modelling study T2 - European Geosciences Union General Assembly 2017 Vienna, Austria, 23–28 April 2017 N2 - The quantitative description and prediction of hydrological response of hillslopes or hillslope-scale catchments to rainfall events is becoming evermore relevant. At the hillslope scale, the onset of runoff and the overall rainfall-runoff transformation are controlled by multiple interacting small-scale processes, that, when acting together produce a response described in terms of hydrological variables well-defined at the catchment and hillslope scales. We hypothesize that small scale features such microtopography of the land surface will will govern large scale signatures of temporal runoff evolution. This can be tested directly by numerical modelling of well-defined surface geometries and adequate process description. It requires a modelling approach consistent with fundamental fluid mechanics, well-designed numerical methods, and computational efficiency. In this work, an idealized rectangular domain representing a hillslope with an idealized 2D sinusoidal microtopography is studied by simulating surface water redistribution by means of a 2D diffusive-wave (zero-inertia) shallow water model. By studying more than 500 surfaces and performing extensive sensitivity analysis forced by a single rainfall pulse, the dependency of characteristic hydrological responses to microtopographical properties was assessed. Despite of the simplicity of periodic surface and the rain event, results indicate complex surface flow dynamics during the onset of runoff observed at the macro and micro scales. Macro scale regimes were defined in terms of characteristics hydrograph shapes and those were related to surface geometry. The reference regime was defined for smooth topography and consisted of a simple hydrograph with smoothly rising and falling limbs with an intermediate steady state. In constrast, rough surface geometry yields stepwise rising limbs and shorter steady states. Furthermore, the increase in total infiltration over the whole domain relative to the smooth reference case shows a strong non-linear dependency on slope and the ratio of the characteristic wavelength and amplitude of microtopography. The coupled analysis of spatial and hydrological results also suggests that the hydrological behaviour can be explained by the spatiotemporal variations triggered by surface connectivity. This study significantly extents previous work on 1D domains, as our results reveal complexities that require 2D representation of the runoff processes. Y1 - 2017 UR - http://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2017/EGU2017-8115.pdf N1 - EGU2017-8115 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Maurer, Thomas A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph A1 - Gerke, Horst H. T1 - Dynamik der initialen (öko-) hydrologischen Entwicklung – Modellierung von Anfangsbedingungen und Wasserflüssen in einem exemplarischen Einzugsgebiet T2 - Abstract-Sammlung zu Posterbeiträgen, eingereicht zum Tag der Hydrologie in Trier 2017, 23. 03. – 24. 03. 2017 Y1 - 2017 UR - https://www.uni-trier.de/fileadmin/fb6/prof/PHY/PDF-Dateien/TdH2017_4Abstracts_Poster.pdf SP - S. 20 ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Maurer, Thomas A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph A1 - Gerke, Horst H. T1 - Flow processes on the catchment scale – modeling of initial structural states and hydrological behavior in an artificial exemplary catchment T2 - European Geosciences Union General Assembly 2017 Vienna, Austria, 23–28 April 2017 N2 - Landscapes that are heavily disturbed or newly formed by either natural processes or human activity are in a state of disequilibrium. Their initial development is thus characterized by highly dynamic processes under all climatic conditions. The primary distribution and structure of the solid phase (i.e. mineral particles forming the pore space) is one of the decisive factors for the development of hydrological behavior of the eco-hydrological system and therefore (co-) determining for its – more or less – stable final state. The artificially constructed ‚Hühnerwasser‘ catchment (a 6 ha area located in the open-cast lignite mine Welzow-Süd, southern Brandenburg, Germany) is a landscape laboratory where the initial eco-hydrological development is observed since 2005. The specific formation (or construction) processes generated characteristic sediment structures and distributions, resulting in a spatially heterogeneous initial state of the catchment. We developed a structure generator that simulates the characteristic distribution of the solid phase for such constructed landscapes. The program is able to generate quasi-realistic structures and sediment compositions on multiple spatial levels (1 cm up to ∼ 100 m scale). The generated structures can be i) conditioned to actual measurement values (e.g., soil texture and bulk distribution); ii) stochastically generated, and iii) calculated deterministically according to the geology and technical processes at the excavation site. Results are visualized using the GOCAD software package and the free software Paraview. Based on the 3D-spatial sediment distributions, effective hydraulic van-Genuchten parameters are calculated using pedotransfer functions. The hydraulic behavior of different sediment distribution (i.e. versions or variations of the catchment’s porous body) is calculated using a numerical model developed by one of us (Caviedes-Voullième). Observation data are available from catchment monitoring are available for i) determining the boundary conditions (e.g., precipitation), and ii) the calibration / validation of the model (catchment discharge, ground water). The analysis of multiple sediment distribution scenarios should allow to approximately determine the influx of starting conditions on initial development of hydrological behavior. We present first flow modeling results for a reference (conditioned) catchment model and variations thereof. We will also give an outlook on further methodical development of our approach. Y1 - 2017 UR - http://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2017/EGU2017-6639.pdf N1 - EGU2017-6639 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - GEN A1 - Pueyo, Y. A1 - Kéfi, S. A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier T1 - Modelling the role of allelopathy on semiarid ecosystems controlled by plant-water feedbacks T2 - XIV MEDECOS & XIII AEET meeting, Human driven scenarios for evolutionary and ecological changes, Abstract book, 31st January - 4th February 2017, Seville, Spain N2 - Plant-plant biotic interactions (i.e. interference and facilitation) are important for the functioning of semi-arid ecosystems. Interference goes beyond competition for resources, and it can involve chemical interactions such as allelopathy. The presence of allelopathy can change the net interaction outcome between plants. For example, allelopathy can be a weapon of an inferior competitor for a limited resource. The output of the biotic interactions between a competitive superior and a competitive inferior plant competing for a limited resource could change if the competitive inferior plant is allelopathic. Moreover, in semiarid ecosystems, vegetation pattern is patchy, and plant establishment occurs predominantly in vegetation patches. Thus, community dynamics are highly dependent on local interactions between plants. Allelopathy could be relevant for plant community dynamics exploiting dynamic and patchy scarce resources, but this mechanism has seldom been explored. We aim to investigate the role of allelopathic interactions on ecosystem dynamics ruled by plant-water feedbacks with a modelling approach to understand its relevance and consequences for semi-arid ecosystems. Allelopathy was included mechanistically, by diffusion of allelopathic compounds with water movements in a spatially-explicit two species model (allelopathic and susceptible plants). We found that the balance between sensitivity to allelopathic compounds and cost of the allelopathic production is key for determining community composition at steady state. Moreover, the range of conditions that presented bistability was widened with the inclusion of allelopathy. These results imply that the ecosystem would be less resilient after perturbations and degraded states could be more stable when allelopathic plants dominate the community. Y1 - 2017 UR - http://www.medecos-aeet-meeting2017.es/ABSTRACT_BOOK_421_p.htm SP - S. 185 PB - Asociación Española de Ecología Terrestre (AEET) CY - Madrid ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Domin, Andrea A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - A numerical study on the influence of mìcrotopography on raìnfall-runoff-infiltration partitioning T2 - 4th International Symposium of Shallow Flows (ISSF 2017), Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands, 26.-28.06.2017 N2 - Microtopographic features, although minute relative to the hillslope scales, are not insignificant in terms of runoff generation, rain-runoff-infiltration partitioning and overall hillslope hydrological signals. As-sessing the effects of such small scale features, arguably requires mathematical models that can cope with microtopraphic complexity to adequately represent surface water dynamics, which in turn deter-mine hydrological signals at the hillslope scale. In this work, rain-runoff simulations are perfomed with a 2D shallow water model on a rectangular domain representing a hillslope with an idealized 2D sinusoidal microtopography. Several combinations of slope, wavelength and amplitudes were used to create over 500 surfaces on which simulations were performed in order to assess their hydrological response in terms of rainfallrunoff-infiltration partitioning. The results were analysed through several dimensionless indices which allow to observe the dependency of characteristic hydrological responses to mi-crotopography properties. They reveal a complex dependency of hydrological signatures to surface microtopography. In particular, the results show that the fraction of rainfall that results in infiltration is increased following a particular non-linear dependency on surface smoothness. Additionally, hydrograph properties and surface flow connectivity also show emerging patterns in response to microtopography. KW - shallow flows KW - microtopography KW - rainfall-runoff KW - onset of runoff KW - infiltration Y1 - 2017 UR - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318226057_A_numerical_study_on_the_influence_of_microtopography_on_rainfall-runoff-infiltration_partitioning ER - TY - GEN A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Morales-Hernández, Mario A1 - Juez, Carmelo A1 - Lacasta, Asier A1 - García-Navarro, Pilar T1 - Two-Dimensional Numerical Simulation of Bed-Load Transport of a Finite-Depth Sediment Layer: Applications to Channel Flushing T2 - Journal of Hydraulic Engineering N2 - Numerical modeling of bed-load transport in shallow flows, particularly oriented toward environmental flows, is an active field of research. Nevertheless, other possible applications exist. In particular, bed-load transport phenomena are relevant in urban drainage systems, including sewers. However, few applications of coupled two-dimensional (2D) shallow-water and bed-load transport models can be found, and their transfer from environmental applications — usually river and floodplain — into sewer applications requires some adaptation. Unlike to river systems, where there is a thick layer of sediment that constitutes a movable riverbed, sewer systems have thin layers of sediment that need to be removed, thus exposing a rigid, nonerodible surface. This problem requires careful numerical treatment to avoid generating errors and instability in the simulation. This paper deals with a numerical approach to tackle this issue in an efficient way that allows large-scale studies to be performed and provides empirical evidence that the proposed approach is accurate and applicable for sewage and channel-flushing problems. KW - Shallow water KW - Exner equation KW - Maximum erodability KW - Finite-depth sediment layer KW - Thin sediment layer KW - Partially erodible bed KW - Channel flushing KW - Graphics-processing unit (GPU) computing Y1 - 2017 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)HY.1943-7900.0001337 SN - 0733-9429 SN - 1943-7900 VL - 143 IS - 9 SP - 04017034 ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullieme, Daniel A1 - Andezhath Mohanan, Anju A1 - Brück, Yasemine A1 - Zaplata, Markus K. A1 - Hinz, Christoph ED - Schütze, Niels ED - Müller, Uwe ED - Schwarze, Robert ED - Wöhling, Thomas ED - Grundmann, Jens T1 - Effect of surface water redistribution on vegetation encroachment in the constructed Hühnerwasser catchment T2 - M³ - Messen, Modellieren, Managen in Hydrologie und Wasserressourcenbewirtschaftung. Beiträge zum Tag der Hydrologie am 22./23. März 2018 an der Technischen Universität Dresden N2 - The artificial Hühnerwasser catchment has experienced a significant and monitored evolution since 2005, changing from a post-mining landscape to an almost fully vegetated ecosystem. The early stages showed a fast rate of ecohydrological evolution with changing dominating processes and feedbacks. The evolution of rill vegetation encroachment is one of such complex co-evolving processes. We hypothesise that rill vegetation encroachment is driven by the evolution of the hydrologic/hydraulic regime of the rill network, which in turn affects the regime, potentially creating a stabilising positive feedback. We further hypothesise that rill vegetation occurs later than hillslope vegetation, and follows a particular establishment and encroachment timeline in response to the changing hydrological/hydraulic regimes. That is, the early runoff-dominated regime results in higher flows, velocities, transport and erosion capacity, thus favouring seed flushing and seedling uprooting. On the other hand, as the system transitions from a runoffdominated into an infiltration- and ET-dominated system, flow, velocity, transport and erosion capacity in the rill network are reduced, making seed establishment in the rills more likely. We explore these hypothesis with two complementary approaches: an analysis of the spatiotemporal distribution of vegetation and a process-based numerical modelling study. Firstly, we assess aerial photography of rill vegetation encroachment between 2007 and 2012 in terms of several vegetation types to derive temporal indicators of encroachment. The analysis reveals that in the initial stages, a rill network developed in the hillslope. Shortly after vegetation first established on hillslopes, the rill network became progressively vegetated. Different pioneering species established heterogeneously, at different times and encroached into the rills at different rates. However, despite the volume of data, it is difficult to assess which are the governing and limiting processes which respectively drive and constrain how and at which rate vegetation encroaches into the rills. In consequence, a pilot modelling study to identify the relative relevance of rill network geometry, bare soil infiltration, hillslope vegetation heterogeneity and intra-storm variability on the hydraulic response of the rill network and its possible impact on encroachment. The overall results suggest that vegetation encroachment may be controlled by the rill network hydraulic regime, but such regime is the result of a complex superposition of responses of all the aforementioned factors, of which rill geometry appears to be a dominant one. Furthermore, the simulations showed that vegetation spatial heterogeneity has an impact on the hydraulic regime coupled to the presence of temporal rainfall variability. Altogether, these results show that the governing coevolving ecohydrological processes are interacting and are strongly affected by spatial and temporal heterogeneities. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://tu-dresden.de/bu/umwelt/hydro/ihm/hydrologie/ressourcen/dateien/tdh2018/TdH_2018_Abstractband.pdf SP - S. 91 PB - Technische Universität CY - Dresden ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullieme, Daniel A1 - Martı́nez-Aranda, Sergio A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier A1 - García-Palacín, Ignacio A1 - García-Navarro, Pilar ED - Schütze, Niels ED - Müller, Uwe ED - Schwarze, Robert ED - Wöhling, Thomas ED - Grundmann, Jens T1 - Measuring 2D transient shallow water surfaces: raising the benchmark challenges for 2D shallow water solvers T2 - M³ - Messen, Modellieren, Managen in Hydrologie und Wasserressourcenbewirtschaftung. Beiträge zum Tag der Hydrologie am 22./23. März 2018 an der Technischen Universität Dresden N2 - In the past decade, shallow water (SW) solvers have been dramatically improved both in terms of accuracy and computational power. The mathematical, numerical and computational improvements available in state-of-the-art solvers now allow for large scale, long term, high resolution simulations of river flooding, flash floods, dam-break phenomena, rainfall-runoff simulation and extensions into pollutants, substance and sediment transport, etc. SW solvers have been benchmarked against a set of test cases, ubiquitious in the literature. The solvers have been systematically verified against 1D and some 2D analytical solutions and validated further against 1D and 2D laboratory experiments, as well as some well-documented real-scale field cases. However, despite the 2D nature of many of these benchmark tests, none of them report 2D water surface elevation. Typically a few profiles are measured and reported, and more often, only a few points are available. Moreover, in field cases, often not even fully transient data is available. The reason for the inavailability of 2D transient water surface data is due to the technical difficulty of measuring a (fast) moving water surface. In most of the reported experiments, pressure gauges are often used to register water depth evolution, and sometimes PIV techniques have been used to obtain velocity fields. In experimental fluid mechanics, measuring the evolution of a free surface has received little attention, as it has been mainly understood as a problem for SW flows, and more recently for free surface granular flows. In consequence, this work aims to generate a new benchmarking dataset in which 2D transient water surfaces are available for SW model developers and users to further test and challenge these models. We argue that the availability of this new data can help identify limitations in the current generation of solvers, thus laying the ground for improvements in the near future. We present laboratory-scale experimental results on steady and unsteady 2D water surfaces performed in a laboratory flume, ranging from steady transcritical flow to dam-break flows around obstacles. The transient water surface was captured using a commercial-grade RGBD sensing device which allows to capture a high-frequency succession of 3D color-coded point clouds. The channel bed can also be registered in the same manner, thus also allowing to compute the 2D transient water-depth field. Color coding also allows to easily differentiate the channel bed, sidewalls and obstacles. The result of the experimental study is a novel collection of 2D benchmark SW cases, with transient water depth and water elevation data for the entire visible flow field. Furthermore, we compare the experimental measurements to 2D shallow water simulations performed with an extensively tested state-of-the-art solver to assess the suitability of this dataset to perform as benchmark test cases and identify some potential limitations of current models. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://tu-dresden.de/bu/umwelt/hydro/ihm/hydrologie/ressourcen/dateien/tdh2018/TdH_2018_Abstractband.pdf SP - S. 23 PB - Technische Universität CY - Dresden ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - The role of topography and intra-annual rainfall variability in semi-arid vegetation self-organisation: a multi-scale modelling study T2 - European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2018, Vienna, Austria N2 - Coevolution of hydrological and vegetation dynamics in semi-arid regions has been widely observed to result in vegetation self-organisation (VSO). Many hypothesis of VSO’s underlying ecohydrological processes and feedbacks have been studied relying on mathematical models, which have been key to evaluate the sensitivity of ecohydrological systems to environmental factors and drivers. Although this ecohydrological coevolution is essentially multiscale, researchers have continued to be constrained by the simplicity of the models which are unable to cope with the multiscale, process-based complexity of fast-moving surface water over complex topographies driven by varying rainfall, during decade-to-century long VSO processes. This limitation has not allowed deep exploration of the role and sensitivity of key environmental factors such as topography and rainfall variability, and the lack of proper hydrodynamics still constrains adequate sediment transport modelling and its feedback effects on VSO. We hypothesize that the intra-storm water redistribution by surface runoff at the hillslope scale is strongly controlled by both topography and storm intensity and may control VSO. This requires for these environmental factors to be accurately represented in models and their their hydraulic and hydrological effects properly reflected. This work provides the first systematic study of the effects of topography and intra-annual rainfall distributions on vegetation band formation at the hillslope scale. Simulations were performed with a physically-based numerical model solving the Zero-Inertia approximation to the shallow water equations for surface flow coupled to the HilleRisLambers-Rietkerk vegetation model, allowing to explicitly represent arbitrary topography. An idealized study of ecohydrological evolution over 30 years was performed, solving with a temporal resolution in the seconds scale. Plane, convex and convex hillslope topologies with different slopes were used, while forcing the model with different annual rainfalls along a semi-arid rainfall gradient, with discrete events of different frequencies. We describe results in terms of evolution of total biomass, hydrological water balance, and of the spatial properties of banded vegetation. Results show that both topography and intra-annual rainfall distribution can play a shaping and governing role in VSO by controlling surface water redistribution and the hydrologic water balance. Increasing slopes favours runoff over infiltration, reducing the available water for vegetation and resulting in different evolutions of vegetation band geometry and band migration. Hillslope topology plays a strong role in the internal water redistribution of the system. Plane and convex surfaces behave similarly, but concave surfaces exhibit a different ecohydrological behaviour, despite the very small topological differences. Different intra-annual rainfall distributions result in different rainfall intensities for the same total annual rainfall which strongly affect the band formation and evolution process: higher intensities lead to less available water, to which vegetation adapts by spatially clustering in bands with different geometrical properties. The study also shows that it is computationally feasible (a few hours runtime) to perform decade-to-century long simulations of these systems with physically-based numerical models paving the way to simulate natural systems with arbitrary topography and high-resolution rainfall data, and is a first step in introducing physically-based sediment transport processes and feedbacks in these studies. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-17423.pdf N1 - EGU2018-17423 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Brück, Yasemine A1 - Andezhath Mohanan, Anju A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph A1 - Zaplata, Markus K. T1 - Spatio-temporal development of rill vegetation in the Hühnerwasser Catchment T2 - European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2018, Vienna, Austria N2 - The artificial catchment “Hühnerwasser” was built in a post-mining landscape, as a field experiment to observe and monitor early-development ecosystems at hillslope scale. Early on, rain-induced rill and channels formation was observed, followed by vegetation growth in between rills, and later on inside the rills. In this work, we aim to describe the temporal evolution of the spatial distribution of rill vegetation. In general terms, we hypothesize four different encroachment patterns might occur: (1) The vegetation spreads from the top of the rills downstream. The underlying hypothesis would be a higher establishment probability due to a lower velocity of surface runoff and therefore less transport probability compared to downstream rill segments. (2) The vegetation starts growing downstream and moves upwards. In this case we can hypothesize that the spatial distribution of the vegetation is dominated by water availability, which is higher or more stable downstream. (3) The vegetation encroaches from the sides into the rills, meaning that inter-rill vegetation governs vegetation encroachment inside the rills. (4) If no patterns are detected it might mean that the encroachment process depends strongly on very local conditions, or perhaps that the underlying assumption of an initially homogeneous seed distribution is false. To investigate the rills formation and rill vegetation encroachment processes, rills and vegetation patches inside these rills were identified and digitized from aerial photographs of the catchment from 2007 to 2012. Different vegetation types were identified based on the colour and texture of the patches. The geometrical properties of the rill segments and vegetation patches were used to define how the different vegetation types have distributed in space and how this distribution has changed over time. Rill mapping reveals a large increase of rill area from 2007 to 2008 and only a small rise from 2008 to 2009. Starting in 2010 dense vegetation prevents a precise mapping of the rills in the aerial photographs, so we assume that there is no change in rill area from 2009 to 2012. In 2007 vegetation covered only 1.4% of the rill area. There is only a small increase of this area in 2008 compared to the later years. In 2012 more than 50% of the rill area is covered by plants. Ten different vegetation types have been identified in the aerial photographs, starting with two types in 2007. By 2012 nine types are spotted in the rills of the catchment. Some of these vegetation types show an encroachment from up- to downstream (e.g. Tussilago farfara), some from down- to upstream like Phragmites australis, whose creeping rhizomes can also promote such spreading. Others reveal no patterns. To better assess and identify the underlying processes leading to these encroachment processes shown by the different vegetation types further data analysis –e.g. comparison with ground based vegetation mapping– and process-based hydrological modelling is necessary to fully explain these observations and assessing additional competition effects, which may be at play. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-13391.pdf N1 - EGU2018-13391 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Andezhath Mohanan, Anju A1 - Brück, Yasemine A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Rill hydrodynamics and its impact on rill vegetation encroachment: a modelling study of the constructed Hühnerwasser catchment T2 - European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2018, Vienna, Austria N2 - The Hühnerwasser catchment is a monitored, early-development constructed catchment within the Lower Lausatia post-mining landscape in Germany. Observations have shown that a sequence of landscape-forming processes occurred, including the initial vegetation establishment stages, which are the main interest of this study. In the initial stages of geomorphic development a surface drainage network of rills was formed as vegetation started to appear on the hillslopes and subsequently inside the rill network. Observations and analysis of the rill vegetation establishment suggest that different vegetation types encroach into the rill network at different times, rates and form different directions. We hypothesize that these encroachment processes may respond to the runoff properties of the catchment at such time: velocity distribution in the rills might play a significant role in flushing seeds in high-velocity reaches of the rill network, thus favouring the appearance of vegetation in low-velocity regions. Consequently, the goal of this study is to assess the magnitudes and spatiotemporal behaviour of velocity in the rill network, to assess its possible impact on seed flushing and rill vegetation encroachment. One rill subcatchment of Hühnerwasser was selected to perform an explorative study of rill hydrodynamics and their impact on vegetation establishment. Two vegetation states were simulated: bare hillslopes and vegetated hillslopes. The vegetated cover polygons were obtained from digitized aerial photography, and stochastically dissagregated 10-minute resolution precipitation data were used, selecting events with early, middle and late peak storm intensities. A 2D explicit finite volume scheme solving the Zero-Inertia approximation to the shallow water equations was used to simulate surface flow in the subcatchment. The preliminary modelling results suggest that that there is no clear overall velocity gradient in the downstream direction along the rills. In fact, velocity in the rills may increase or decrease along the rill following local topography and rill geometry. Consequently, no global trend for the probability of seeds being transported can be established. The results also shows that varying rainfall intensity and rainfall intrastorm distribution –in the absence of hillslope vegetation– does not affect the rill locations of maximum velocities, but mostly affect the magnitude of velocity. In the presence of hillslope vegetation –and thus heterogeneous infiltration conditions in the hillslopes– the spatial distribution of velocity is strongly affected, and can be in fact governed not by topography or rill geometry, but by the spatial heterogeneity of infiltration capacity. Furthermore, the time at which maximum discharge and velocities occur may not match that of maximum intensity. That is, emerging temporal dynamics arise due to the introduction of spatial heterogeneity, which also manifests in the fact that outflow from the subcatchment exhibits a intensity-thresholded behaviour. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-13392.pdf N1 - EGU2018-13392 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Convergent biomass, divergent patterns: Can initial conditions govern vegetation self-organisation? T2 - European Geosciences Union, General Assembly 2018, Vienna, Austria N2 - Vegetation self-organisation in water-limited ecosystems in semi-arid climates has been extensively studied by means of numerical simulation using a set of different reaction-diffusion-equations. Most of such models and studies have been concerned with the long-term steady ecohydrological states on domains with periodic boundaries and forced by steady rainfall, whilst little interest has been given to the transient states which lead to them as well as the spatiotemporal multiscale nature of the feedback processes. It is generally accepted that alternative random initial biomass distributions do not significantly affect the resulting steady state vegetation patterns. However, the role of the initial hydrological conditions –initial surface and subsurface water– has not been explored, mainly due to the interest in the long-term steady state. Nonetheless, vegetation patterns are directly linked to the water distribution occurring at much shorter time scales than vegetation growth, and because they have been shown to be sensitive to annual rainfall, it is reasonable that the initially available water will also play a role. We therefore hypothesize that the initially available water will play a role in the transient process leading to a steady ecohydrological state, and that the steady vegetation patterns will differ in response to the water availability in time during the entire process. In this contribution we explore the role of initial hydrological conditions on both the transient and longterm steady ecohydrological state. A simulation study was performed using the HilleRisLambers-Rietkerk ecohydrological model on a flatland varying the initial available water whilst also spanning the rainfall gradient (90 – 360 mm/year) . The results were assessed in terms of the evolution and steady state of total biomass yield and hydrological water balance, as well as a quantitative assessment of both transient and steady vegetation patterns. The results show that the initially available water does play a role, not only in the early transient state, but in the long-term steady state, and indeed in the geometry of the converged vegetation pattern. Furthermore, although the steady state biomass yield may be the same for varying initial conditions, the final patterns still differ, e.g., a reduction to one-fourth initial water availability results in more but smaller vegetation patches, while a reduction to one-eigth initial water results in less, but larger patches, and a reduction to one-sixteenth results in a completely new pattern, although total biomass is the same for all. This suggests that long-term average rainfall may govern the total biomass but the initial conditions may play a relevant shaping role in the long term spatial distributions of steady ecohydrological states of water-limited ecohydrosystems. This is relevant, among other reasons, because the resilience of the system is associated to the vegetation patterns. It also suggests that neither the temporal distribution of rainfall nor the system’s evolution cannot be neglected to understand the environmental factors which lead to a steady ecohydrological state, since multiple paths may be possible. This warrants further developments from the ecohydrological modelling community and further study of transient states through process-based models. Y1 - 2018 UR - https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EGU2018/EGU2018-13684.pdf N1 - EGU2018-13684 PB - European Geophysical Society CY - Katlenburg-Lindau ER - TY - GEN A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Cellular Automata and Finite Volume solvers converge for 2D shallow flow modelling for hydrological modelling T2 - Journal of Hydrology N2 - Surface flows of hydrological interest, including overland flow, runoff, river and channel flow and flooding have received significant attention from modellers in the past 30 years. A growing effort to address these complex environmental problems is in place in the scientific community. Researchers have stud-ied and favoured a plethora of techniques to approach this issue, ranging from very simple empirically-based mathematical models, to physically-based, deductive and very formal numerical integration of systems of partial-differential equations. In this work, we review two families of methods: cell-based simulators – later called Cellular Automata – and Finite Volume solvers for the Zero-Inertia equation, which we show to converge into a single methodology given appropriate choices. Furthermore, this convergence, mathematically shown in this work, can also be identified by critically reviewing the exist-ing literature, which leads to the conclusion that two methods originating from different reasoning and fundamental philosophy, fundamentally converge into the same method. Moreover, acknowledging such convergence allows for some generalisation of properties of numerical schemes such as error behaviour and stability, which, importantly, is the same for the converging methodology, a fact with practical implications. Both the review of existing literature and reasoning in this work attempts to aid in the effort of synchronising and cross-fertilizing efforts to improve the understanding and the outlook of Zero-Inertia solvers for surface flows, as well as to help in clarifying the possible confusion and parallel develop-ments that may arise from the use of different terminology originating from historical reasons. Moreover, synchronising and unifying this knowledge-base can help clarify model capabilities, applicability and modelling issues for hydrological modellers, specially for those not deeply familiar with the mathematical and numerical details. KW - Surface runoff KW - Zero-inertia equation KW - Shallow-water equations KW - Cellular Automata KW - Finite Volume KW - Diffusive-wave equation Y1 - 2018 UR - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022169418304438 U6 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2018.06.021 SN - 0022-1694 VL - 563 SP - 411 EP - 417 ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Fernández-Pato, Javier A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - Zero-Inertia vs full shallow water equations: a comparison for rainfall-runoff modelling T2 - Computational Methods in Water Resources XXII (CMWR 2018), Bridging gaps between data, models, and predictions KW - Shallow water equations KW - Diffusive-wave equation KW - rainfall-runoff Y1 - 2018 UR - https://www.irisa.fr/sage/jocelyne/CMWR2018/pdf/CMWR2018_paper_147.pdf ER - TY - CHAP A1 - Caviedes-Voullième, Daniel A1 - Hinz, Christoph T1 - An ecohydrological model to explore topographic and rainfall variability effects on vegetation self-organisation T2 - Computational Methods in Water Resources XXII (CMWR 2018), Bridging gaps between data, models, and predictions KW - Vegetation self-organisation KW - complex topography KW - rainfall variability Y1 - 2018 UR - https://www.irisa.fr/sage/jocelyne/CMWR2018/pdf/CMWR2018_paper_54.pdf ER -