Research on Erich Fromm’s Theory of Consumer Alienation, Master thesis, Philosophy, Jilin University, Changchun, Jilin, China 2024.
- [Chinese abstract not available] Based on his historical context, Fromm absorbed the essence of previous thoughts such as Marx’s theory of alienation and Freud’s psychoanalysis, continued the Western humanistic critique tradition, and analyzed the phenomenon of consumption alienation in capitalist society from a social psychology perspective, thus constructing a consumption alienation theory with a unique perspective and humanistic concern. Fromm’s profound insights into consumption alienation not only provide a correct view of the issues and inherent drawbacks of consumption in capitalist society but also offer crucial theoretical support and inspiration for combating irrational consumption trends in China’s consumer market and realizing people’s aspirations for a better life. This paper, grounded in Fromm’s critical perspective on capitalist consumption alienation and its value orientation, starts from Fromm’s preliminary analysis of the phenomenon of capitalist consumption alienation, and further explores the causes and dissolution paths of consumption alienation. Finally, it dia¬lectically examines the strengths and limitations of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory from a Marxist perspective. Specifically, it explores the following four aspects: First, it examines the historical background and theo¬retical origins of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory. Historically, the advanced capitalist countries in the West accelerated productivity growth through Fordist production methods and ushered in an era of mass consumption. However, this material prosperity did not bring true happiness and freedom. Instead, frequent social crises such as the two World Wars and economic crises led to people’s suffering, wide¬spread loneliness, and helplessness. Theoretically, Fromm, after deeply studying and absorbing Marx’s theory of alienation, Freud’s psychoanalytic theory, and Marcuse’s theory of consumption alienation, further developed and innovated to form his unique consumption alienation theory. Second, it analyzes the main content of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory. Fromm first defines the connotation of consumption alienation from a social psychology perspective, viewing alienation as the deprivation of individual productivity, manifested as a profound psychological experience. Essentially, con¬sumption alienation is a psychological experience of the separation of human existence and essence in consumption stimulated by capitalism, severing the true connection between people and consumption. Next, Fromm reveals the real manifestations of consumption alienation in capitalist society. This includes the alienation of the consumption subject, characterized by changes in consumer roles, needs, and per¬ceptions; the alienation of the consumption object, characterized by the commodification of identity, per¬sonality, and leisure time; the alienation of consumption means, characterized by the abstraction of money and the shift towards ownership priority; and the alienation of consumption purposes, characterized by the deviation from survival value to material satisfaction. Finally, Fromm emphasizes the triple dangers brought by consumption alienation, covering aspects such as mental negativity, resource depletion, and inter¬per¬sonal estrangement, revealing deep crises on the spiritual, ecological, and survival levels. Third, it deeply explores the causes and dissolution paths of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory. Fromm believes that the distortion of inherent needs rooted in human nature, especially the needs for relatedness, transcendence, and a sense of identity in capitalist society, is the internal mechanism of con¬sumption alienation. The large-scale industrial machinery, private ownership, advertising strategies, and the resulting social character in capitalist society jointly act and further exacerbate consumption alienation. Therefore, regarding the dissolution path of consumption alienation, Fromm proposes solutions on two levels. On the personal level, cultivating a productive character and emphasizing an existence-oriented way of living are key to overcoming consumption alienation; on the social level, establishing a humanistic socialist society supported by comprehensive economic, political, and cultural reforms is considered a fea¬sible solution to the problem of consumption alienation. This cause analysis and solution design that com¬bines individual psychology with social structure highlight the core features and uniqueness of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory. Fourth, it objectively evaluates the contributions and limitations of Fromm’s consumption alienation theory. Fromm insights into the inherent needs in human nature from a psychological perspective and his critique of consumption alienation in capitalist society enrich the research perspectives and methods of Marxism. At the same time, his proposed solutions express a deep concern for human existence and development, emphasizing the value of human subjectivity and have certain referential value. However, Fromm’s thoughts on consumption alienation also have certain limitations. His theory has contradictions and ambiguities, and the reform plan based on an abstract theory of human nature carries a strong utopian color in practice, deviating from Marxism and lacking the practical nature of Marxism. [Translation: www.cnki.net, 1/2025]