Retaining classical concepts - hidden costs. Commentary on Lewis Aron's >the internalized primal scene<

  • The paper >Unlawful Entry: Male Fears of Psychic Penetration< is discussed. The paper's author, Dianne Elise, argues that the key to masculine development in contemporary Western culture is the imperative to penetrate and not to be penetrated. Therefore, penetration of either the body or the mind becomes a threat to the stability of many men. Men begin life with an experience of passive excitement – they are penetrated in the nursing situation. Elise argues that subsequent developmental experience forecloses the capacity for penetration and, with it, for emotional capacity. She suggests that men who have great difficulty allowing emotional access should be considered to be suffering from the >citadel complex.< In this commentary, it is argued that Elise confounds the metaphor and the actuality of penetration. Furthermore, she adopts a rhetorical position that creates a meta-message. She adopts a scientific voice to describe masculine development in concrete, positivist terms. This choice of stance undercuts her stated intention to question traditional psychoanalytic gender stereotypy. Although she advocates emotional openness to penetration, she establishes herself and by extension the analyst as an all-knowing, impenetrable authority.

Export metadata

Additional Services

Share in Twitter Search Google Scholar
Metadaten
Author:Emmanuel Kaftal
Parent Title (English):Psychoanalytic Dialogues Vol. 11 (2001), pp. 541-548.
Document Type:Articles
Language:English
Year of first Publication:2001
Release Date:2017/11/20
Format:xerox upon request / Fotokopie auf Anfrage
IdNo:Kaftal_E_2001
Erich Fromm's Library and Erich Fromm Archive:Articles / Artikel
Licence (German):
Einverstanden ✔
Diese Webseite verwendet technisch erforderliche Session-Cookies. Durch die weitere Nutzung der Webseite stimmen Sie diesem zu. Unsere Datenschutzerklärung finden Sie hier.